Abstract:Electric vehicles (EVs) feature prominently in the United States' efforts to decarbonize the light-duty vehicle fleet and mitigate climate change. To spur EV adoption, public policy offers procurement incentives for individuals willing to purchase an EV instead of an internal combustion engine vehicle (ICEV). How cost-effective are such policies? To what extent does their efficiency vary across states? We address these questions using state-level data on projected electric grid carbon intensity and fuel prices, as well as models of vehicle utilization. Our approach focuses on comparable vehicle models that enable us to jointly estimate the lifecycle emissions and total cost of ownership (TCO) associated with ICEVs, hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs), and EVs. Our findings are fourfold. First, although EVs offer the largest emissions benefit relative to ICEVs, there exists significant state-level heterogeneity. Compared to HEVs' emissions advantage of 20.54 tons of CO 2 e, EVs' emissions advantage ranges from 10.18 to 58.83 tons of CO 2 e across states. Second, HEVs offer a more favorable cost-to-emissions advantage nationwide, with an average cost of $59/ton CO 2 e reduced compared to $192/ton CO 2 e reduced via EVs. Third, state-level variation in fuel prices and grid carbon intensity enable HEVs to offer emissions reductions at a minimum cost of $3/ton CO 2 e reduced, while EVs' minimum cost is $76/ton CO 2 e reduced. Fourth, envisioned grid decarbonization efforts are insufficient for EVs to deliver economically efficient cost-to-emissions advantages due to EVs' relatively high TCO. If EVs produced zero emissions in totality, realizing cost-effective emissions reductions would still necessitate lowering their TCO by an average of at least $3,200. We conclude that favorable abatement cost realization necessitates better targeting of procurement incentives at both the federal and state level. We demonstrate that this outcome can be achieved by incentivizing the adoption of HEVs and high-utilization EVs in the short run and by improving EVs' cost and continuing to invest in EV battery longevity in the long run.

With great power (prices) comes great tail pipe emissions? \\ A natural experiment of electricity prices and electric car adoption

Energy, Emissions, and Cost Impacts of Charging Price Strategies for Electric Vehicles

Electric Car Purchase Price as a Factor Determining Consumers’ Choice and their Views on Incentives in Europe

Prices and preferences in the electric vehicle market

Will changes in charging and gasoline prices affect electric vehicle sales? Evidence from China

Is electric car uptake driven by monetary factors? A total cost of ownership comparison between Norway and Italy

The Impact of Electric Vehicle Density on Local Grid Costs: Empirical Evidence from Norway

Investigating the impact of policies, socio-demography and national commitments on electric-vehicle demand: Cross-country study

The Road to a Low Emission Society: Costs of Interacting Climate Regulations

Electric vehicle adoption in a mature market: A case study of Norway

Pricing indirect emissions accelerates low—carbon transition of US light vehicle sector

Network Externality and Subsidy Structure in Two-Sided Markets: Evidence from Electric Vehicle Incentives

Which state is the cleanest of them all? Pricing long run heterogeneity in carbon abatement costs across America.

The Effect of Reducing Electric Car Purchase Incentives in the European Union

Who Is More Likely to Buy Electric Vehicles?

The Impact of Subsidies and Charging Facilities on Demand for Electric Vehicles in China

Consumer Tax Credits for EVs: Some Quasi-Experimental Evidence on Consumer Demand, Product Substitution, and Carbon Emissions

Empirical grid impact of in-home electric vehicle charging differs from predictions

Consumer Adoption of Plug-In Electric Vehicles in Selected Countries

No Longer Riding Dirty: the Effect of Electronic Vehicle Subsidies on Automobile Markets

Electric vehicle usage, pollution damages, and the electricity price elasticity of driving