The role of individual decision-making in the manufacturing of bone retouchers

Eva Francesca Martellotta,Valerio Giuliano Zinnarello,Marco Peresani
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-024-01945-2
IF: 2.213
2024-03-02
Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences
Abstract:Bone retouchers, while often underrated, stand out as widespread tools throughout the Palaeolithic, typically linked to breaking bones for marrow extraction. Although bone retouchers are commonly considered a by-product of butchering activities, the possibility of intentional manufacturing has been rarely considered but should not be dismissed. In our experimental protocol, we explore decision-making processes involved in manufacturing bone retouchers, focusing on how these decisions are guided by intentional production rather than solely marrow extraction. The results indicate that individuals employ specific techniques and make technological decisions, rapidly acquiring experience in retoucher manufacturing that extends beyond mere intuition. The choice of bone-breaking technique(s) reflects the intention behind either marrow extraction or producing suitable bone fragments for retouchers. This decision-making process is heavily influenced by the morphology of the bone, presenting challenges that individuals learn to overcome during the experiment. The analysis of the experimental percussion marks suggests that certain marks on specific skeletal elements indicate intentional bone retoucher manufacturing. We then propose a likelihood grid to assess the reliability of traces on each skeletal element in inferring intentional manufacturing. Given the abundance of bone retouchers in Middle Palaeolithic contexts, a thorough investigation into the intentionality behind their manufacturing processes could significantly impact their relevance within other Palaeolithic bone industries.
geosciences, multidisciplinary,anthropology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to explore the individual decision-making process in the production of Middle Paleolithic bone retouchers and to assess whether these decisions reflect intentional manufacture rather than merely being by-products of marrow extraction. The authors used experimental methods to study different bone fracturing techniques under various objectives and their impact on fracture marks. Specifically, the experiment set two objectives: one was to extract bone marrow (Objective A), and the other was to produce bone fragments suitable for use as retouchers (Objective B). The experimental results indicate that participants chose different techniques based on bone morphology when completing tasks and quickly learned and adapted during the experiment to achieve their respective goals. This research helps to reassess the manufacturing intent of bone retouchers found in archaeological discoveries and may have significant implications for understanding other bone tool industries in the Paleolithic era.