Abstract:Objective: This study aimed to investigate the accuracy of convolutional neural network models in the assessment of embryos using time-lapse monitoring. Data sources: A systematic search was conducted in PubMed and Web of Science databases from January 2016 to December 2022. The search strategy was carried out by using key words and MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) terms. Study eligibility criteria: Studies were included if they reported the accuracy of convolutional neural network models for embryo evaluation using time-lapse monitoring. The review was registered with PROSPERO (International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews; identification number CRD42021275916). Methods: Two reviewer authors independently screened results using the Covidence systematic review software. The full-text articles were reviewed when studies met the inclusion criteria or in any uncertainty. Nonconsensus was resolved by a third reviewer. Risk of bias and applicability were evaluated using the QUADAS-2 tool and the modified Joanna Briggs Institute or JBI checklist. Results: Following a systematic search of the literature, 22 studies were identified as eligible for inclusion. All studies were retrospective. A total of 522,516 images of 222,998 embryos were analyzed. Three main outcomes were evaluated: successful in vitro fertilization, blastocyst stage classification, and blastocyst quality. Most studies reported >80% accuracy, and embryologists were outperformed in some. Ten studies had a high risk of bias, mostly because of patient bias. Conclusion: The application of artificial intelligence in time-lapse monitoring has the potential to provide more efficient, accurate, and objective embryo evaluation. Models that examined blastocyst stage classification showed the best predictions. Models that predicted live birth had a low risk of bias, used the largest databases, and had external validation, which heightens their relevance to clinical application. Our systematic review is limited by the high heterogeneity among the included studies. Researchers should share databases and standardize reporting.

Multi-Task Deep Learning with Dynamic Programming for Embryo Early Development Stage Classification from Time-Lapse Videos

Developmental Stage Classification of Embryos Using Two-Stream Neural Network with Linear-Chain Conditional Random Field

EmbryosFormer: Deformable Transformer and Collaborative Encoding-Decoding for Embryos Stage Development Classification

Automating Blastocyst Formation and Quality Prediction in Time-Lapse Imaging with Adaptive Key Frame Selection

Embryo staging with weakly-supervised region selection and dynamically-decoded predictions

Deep learning-based embryo assessment of static images can reduce the time to live birth in in vitro fertilization

Deep learning mediated single time-point image-based prediction of embryo developmental outcome at the cleavage stage

Machine learning in time-lapse imaging to differentiate embryos from young vs old mice

Using deep learning to predict the outcome of live birth from more than 10,000 embryo data

Automated Measurements of Key Morphological Features of Human Embryos for IVF

Noninvasive time-lapse 3D subcellular analysis of embryo development for machine learning-enabled prediction of blastocyst formation

Multimodal Learning for Embryo Viability Prediction in Clinical IVF

Accurate Machine Learning Model for Human Embryo Morphokinetic Stage Detection

Deep learning for embryo evaluation using time-lapse: a systematic review of diagnostic test accuracy

Towards deep learning-powered IVF: A large public benchmark for morphokinetic parameter prediction

Predicting Pregnancy Rate Following Multiple Embryo Transfers Using Algorithms Developed Through Static Image Analysis.

Deep learning pipeline reveals key moments in human embryonic development predictive of live birth in IVF

Deep learning pipeline reveals key moments in human embryonic development predictive of live birth after in vitro fertilization

Deep Low-Shot Learning for Biological Image Classification and Visualization from Limited Training Samples

Deep learning-based reconstruction of embryonic cell-division cycle from label-free microscopy time-series of evolutionarily diverse nematodes

Improving Generation and Evaluation of Long Image Sequences for Embryo Development Prediction