A way to solve the black hole paradox

Alex Wilkins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0262-4079(24)00055-1

2024-01-01

Abstract:We may be able to measure “islands” that contain copies of information that black holes have lost

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

On information paradox and the fate of black holes

A.Morozov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217732324500251

2023-04-01

Abstract:A sketchy review of the "island" paradigm in black hole evaporation theory, which actually brings us back to the old idea that interior of black hole decouples from our universe after Page time, so that Hawking radiation is entangled with emerging new universe, thus leaving no room for the information paradox. Instead this provides a self-consistent description of multiverse, where every black hole in a parent universe is a white hole -- the origin -- of a new one.

High Energy Physics - Theory
Black Hole: The Interior Spacetime

Yen Chin Ong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789813203952_0081

2016-02-14

Abstract:The information loss paradox is often discussed from the perspective of the observers who stay outside of a black hole. However, the interior spacetime of a black hole can be rather nontrivial. We discuss the open problems regarding the volume of a black hole, and whether it plays any role in information storage. We also emphasize the importance of resolving the black hole singularity, if one were to resolve the information loss paradox.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Islands outside the horizon

Ahmed Almheiri,Raghu Mahajan,Juan Maldacena

2023-08-09

Abstract:We consider an AdS$_2$ black hole in equilibrium with a bath, which we take to have a dual description as (0+1)-dimensional quantum mechanical system coupled to a (1+1)-dimensional field theory serving as the bath. We compute the entropies of both the quantum mechanical degrees of freedom and of the bath separately, while allowing contributions from entanglement wedge "islands". We find situations where the island extends {\it outside} the black hole horizon. This suggests possible causality paradoxes which we show are avoided because of the quantum focusing conjecture. Finally, we formulate a version of the information paradox for a black hole in contact with a bath in the Hartle-Hawking state, and demonstrate the role of islands in resolving this paradox.

High Energy Physics - Theory
Debunking the black hole information paradox

Andrzej Dragan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1003.0094

2010-02-27

Abstract:The vivid debate concerning the paradox of information being lost when objects are swallowed by a black hole is shown to be void. We argue that no information is ever missing for any observer neither located above, nor falling beneath the event horizon. The information is preserved in a classical scenario of eternal black holes and semi-classical one allowing Hawking radiation.

Quantum Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Black Holes and Information: A New Take on an Old Paradox

K. L. H. Bryan,A. J. M. Medved

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/7578462

2017-01-01

Advances in High Energy Physics

Abstract:Interest in the black hole information paradox has recently been catalyzed by the newer “firewall” argument. The crux of the updated argument is that previous solutions which relied on observer complementarity are in violation of the quantum condition of monogamy of entanglement, with the prescribed remedy being to discard the equivalence principle in favor of an energy barrier (or firewall) at the black hole horizon. Differing points of view have been put forward, including the “ER = EPR” counterargument and the final-state solution, both of which can be viewed as potential resolutions to the apparent conflict between quantum monogamy and Einstein equivalence. After reviewing these recent developments, this paper argues that the ER = EPR and final-state solutions can—thanks to observer complementarity—be seen as the same resolution of the paradox but from two different perspectives: inside and outside the black hole.

physics, particles & fields
How the black-to-white hole scenario resolves the information loss paradox

Pierre Martin-Dussaud

2024-11-02

Abstract:This article explains the resolution to the Hawking information loss paradox within the framework of the black-to-white hole scenario.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Information Scrambling at Quantum Hall Interfaces and Their Analog to Black Hole Event Horizon

Ken K. W. Ma,Kun Yang

2024-08-01

Abstract:The black hole information paradox has been hotly debated for the last few decades without a full resolution. This makes it desirable to find analogues of this paradox in simple and experimentally accessible systems, whose resolutions may shed light on this longstanding and fundamental problem. Here, we review and resolve the apparent "information paradox" in two different interfaces separating Abelian and non-Abelian quantum Hall states. In both cases, the information carried by the pseudospin degree of freedom of the Abelian anyons get scrambled when they cross the interface and enter the non-Abelian quantum Hall liquid. Nevertheless, it is found that the scrambling mechanism depends on the nature of the interface. The corresponding analogues of different concepts in black hole physics such as event horizon, black hole interior, Hawking radiation, and Page curve will also be discussed.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Do Black Holes Destroy Information?

John Preskill

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-th/9209058

1992-09-16

High Energy Physics - Theory

Abstract:I review the information loss paradox that was first formulated by Hawking, and discuss possible ways of resolving it. All proposed solutions have serious drawbacks. I conclude that the information loss paradox may well presage a revolution in fundamental physics. (To appear in the proceedings of the International Symposium on Black Holes, Membranes, Wormholes, and Superstrings.)
Navigating the Conjectural Labyrinth of the Black Hole Information Paradox

Galina Weinstein

2023-10-05

Abstract:This paper explores the enduring black hole information and firewall paradoxes, challenges that have prompted many proposals, conjectures, and theories. Noteworthy among these are the ER = EPR conjecture and AdS/CFT correspondence, which suggest possible avenues toward the yet-to-be-realized unified theory of quantum gravity. This discourse offers a comprehensive analysis of the aforementioned paradoxes, drawing upon insights from efforts to reconcile the schism between general relativity and quantum mechanics.

History and Philosophy of Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory
Islands Far Outside the Horizon

Raphael Bousso,Geoff Penington

2023-12-21

Abstract:Information located in an entanglement island in semiclassical gravity can be nonperturbatively reconstructed from distant radiation, implying a radical breakdown of effective field theory. We show that this occurs well outside of the black hole stretched horizon. We compute the island associated to large-angular momentum Hawking modes of a four-dimensional Schwarzschild black hole. These modes typically fall back into the black hole but can be extracted to infinity by relativistic strings or, more abstractly, by asymptotic boundary operators constructed using the timelike tube theorem. Remarkably, we find that their island can protrude a distance of order $\sqrt{\ell_p r_{\rm hor}}$ outside the horizon. This is parametrically larger than the Planck scale $\ell_p$ and is comparable to the Bohr radius for supermassive black holes. Therefore, in principle, a distant observer can determine experimentally whether the black hole information paradox is resolved by complementarity, or by a firewall.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
Binary Black Hole Information Loss Paradox & Future Prospects

Ayan Mitra,Pritam Chattopadhyay,Goutam Paul,Vasilios Zarikas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2004.04695

2020-04-09

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

Abstract:Various techniques to tackle the black hole information paradox have been proposed. A new way out to tackle the paradox is via the use of a pseudo-density operator. This approach has successfully dealt with the problem with a two qubit entangle system for a single black hole. In this paper, we present the interaction with a binary black hole system by using an arrangement of the three qubit system of Greenberger Horne Zeilinger (GHZ) state. We show that our results are in excellent agreement with the theoretical value. We have also studied the interaction between the two black holes by considering the correlation between the qubits in the binary black hole system. The results depict a complete agreement with the proposed model. In addition to the verification, we also propose how modern detection of gravitational waves can be used on our optical setup as an input source, thus bridging the gap with the gravitational wave's observational resources in terms of studying black hole properties with respect to quantum information and entanglement.
Black Holes, Cavities and Blinking Islands

Dmitry S. Ageev,Irina Ya. Aref'eva,Timofei A. Rusalev

2023-11-28

Abstract:Placing a black hole in a cavity is known to be a natural way to study different scales in gravity, issues related to the thermodynamic instability and gravity effective theories. In this paper, we consider the evolution of the entanglement entropy and entanglement islands in the two-sided generalization of the Schwarzschild black hole in a cavity. Introducing a reflecting boundary in the eternal black exteriors we regulate infrared modes of Hawking radiation and find that entanglement entropy saturates at some constant value. This value could be lower than black hole thermodynamic entropy, thus not leading to Page formulation of information paradox. Concerning the entanglement islands, we find a universal effect induced by the boundary presence, which we call ``blinking island" -- for some time the entanglement island inevitably disappears, thus leading to a short-time information paradox.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
Resolving the black hole information paradox

Samir D. Mathur

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217751X00002147

2000-07-08

Abstract:The recent progress in string theory strongly suggests that formation and evaporation of black holes is a unitary process. This fact makes it imperative that we find a flaw in the semiclassical reasoning that implies a loss of information. We propose a new criterion that limits the domain of classical gravity: the hypersurfaces of a foliation cannot be stretched too much. This conjectured criterion may have important consequences for the early Universe.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Closed universes with black holes but no event horizons as a solution to the black hole information problem

Frank J. Tipler,Jessica Graber,Matthew McGinley,Joshua Nichols‐Barrer,Christopher Staecker,F. J. Tipler,J. Graber,M. McGinley,J. Nichols-Barrer,C. Staecker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.11895.x

IF: 4.8

2007-08-01

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

Abstract:We show that it is possible for the information paradox in black hole evaporation to be resolved classically. Using standard junction conditions, we attach the general closed spherically symmetric dust metric to a space–time satisfying all standard energy conditions but with a single point future c‐boundary. The resulting Omega Point space–time, which has NO event horizons, nevertheless has black hole type trapped surfaces and hence black holes. However, since there are no event horizons, information eventually escapes from the black holes. We show that a scalar quintessence field with an appropriate exponential potential near the final singularity would give rise to an Omega Point final singularity.

astronomy & astrophysics
Islands in cosmology

Thomas Hartman,Yikun Jiang,Edgar Shaghoulian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP11(2020)111

IF: 6.379

2020-11-21

Journal of High Energy Physics

Abstract:A quantum extremal island suggests that a region of spacetime is encoded in the quantum state of another system, like the encoding of the black hole interior in Hawking radiation. We study conditions for islands to appear in general spacetimes, with or without black holes. They must violate Bekenstein's area bound in a precise sense, and the boundary of an island must satisfy several other information-theoretic inequalities. These conditions combine to impose very strong restrictions, which we apply to cosmological models. We find several examples of islands in crunching universes. In particular, in the four-dimensional FRW cosmology with radiation and a negative cosmological constant, there is an island near the turning point when the geometry begins to recollapse. In a two-dimensional model of JT gravity in de Sitter spacetime, there are islands inside crunches that are encoded at future infinity or inside bubbles of Minkowski spacetime. Finally, we discuss simple tensor network toy models for islands in cosmology and black holes.

physics, particles & fields
(Information) Paradox Lost

Tim Maudlin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1705.03541

2017-05-06

History and Philosophy of Physics

Abstract:Since Stephen Hawking's original 1975 paper on black hole evaporation, there has been a consensus that the problem of "loss of information" is both deep and troubling. It is also thought that resolution of the problem may hold some conceptual keys to the unification of gravity with the other forces. I argue that this consensus view is mistaken. The so-called "information loss paradox" arises rather from the inaccurate application of foundational principles, involving both mathematical and conceptual errors. The resources for resolving the "paradox" are familiar and uncontroversial, as has been pointed out in the literature. The problem ought to have been dismissed 40 years ago. Recent radical attempts to solve the problem are blind alleys, solutions in search of a problem.
Fuzzy spaces topology change as a possible solution to the black hole information loss paradox

C.A.S. Silva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2009.05.031

IF: 4.95

2009-06-01

Physics Letters B

Abstract:The black hole information loss paradox is one of the most intricate problems in modern theoretical physics. A proposal to solve this is one related with topology change. However it has found some obstacles related to unitarity and cluster decomposition (locality). In this Letter we argue that modelling the black hole's event horizon as a noncommutative manifold – the fuzzy sphere – we can solve the problems with topology change, getting a possible solution to the black hole information loss paradox.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields, nuclear
The Black Hole Information Paradox: Is Omniscience a Fundamental Property of the Universe?

Jabi Elijah Shriki MD

DOI: https://doi.org/10.61707/j1ykyn55

2024-09-21

International Journal of Religion

Abstract:We seek to examine the ontological aspects of the resolution of the black hole information paradox. Several concepts which are now central to our understanding of quantum mechanics arose from our resolution to this paradox, and these concepts point to the conservation of all information, even on a quantum level. If quantum information is conserved and can never be erased or destroyed, then this indicates that all information is at least theoretically, ultimately retrievable and knowable from the event horizon of the universe. Ontologically, this supports the contention that a repository of all information in the universe must therefore exist. Herein, we trace the steps in this contention and conclude with the argument that our understanding of the universe points to the existence of an omniscient entity.
Hawking radiation as tunneling is non-Markovian: An information-theoretic solution to the paradox of black hole information loss

Zeqian Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1111.1821

2011-11-08

Mathematical Physics

Abstract:We present an information-theoretic solution to the paradox of black hole information loss.
Bounded islands in dS$_{2}$ multiverse model

Wen-Hao Jiang,Yun-Song Piao

2024-03-27

Abstract:The cosmological event horizons are observer-dependent, which might bring a paradox. As an example, in dS$_{2}$ multiverse model there are entanglement islands in crunching regions encoding the information of regions near future infinity of inflating or Minkowski bubbles, however, for two observers in different bubbles, since their island regions overlap, both observers will be able to get access to the information encoded in the overlapping region, indicating a violation of no-cloning theorem. In this paper, we present a different resolution to this paradox. Based on the Petz $\mathrm{R\acute{e}nyi}$ mutual information, we show that besides the quantum extremal surfaces there might be another boundary for the island in corresponding spacetime so that the island regions are bounded by ``division points" rather than extending to the rest of the entire spacetime. We also discuss the implications of our result.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

A way to solve the black hole paradox

On information paradox and the fate of black holes

Black Hole: The Interior Spacetime

Islands outside the horizon

Debunking the black hole information paradox

Black Holes and Information: A New Take on an Old Paradox

How the black-to-white hole scenario resolves the information loss paradox

Information Scrambling at Quantum Hall Interfaces and Their Analog to Black Hole Event Horizon

Do Black Holes Destroy Information?

Navigating the Conjectural Labyrinth of the Black Hole Information Paradox

Islands Far Outside the Horizon

Binary Black Hole Information Loss Paradox & Future Prospects

Black Holes, Cavities and Blinking Islands

Resolving the black hole information paradox

Closed universes with black holes but no event horizons as a solution to the black hole information problem

Islands in cosmology

(Information) Paradox Lost

Fuzzy spaces topology change as a possible solution to the black hole information loss paradox

The Black Hole Information Paradox: Is Omniscience a Fundamental Property of the Universe?

Hawking radiation as tunneling is non-Markovian: An information-theoretic solution to the paradox of black hole information loss

Bounded islands in dS$_{2}$ multiverse model