Abstract:The quantification of human DNA extracts from forensic samples plays a key role in the forensic genetics process, ensuring maximum efficiency and avoiding repeated analyses, over-amplified samples, or unnecessary examinations. In our laboratory, we use the Quantifiler® Trio system to quantify DNA extracts from a wide range of samples extracted from traces (bloodstains, saliva, semen, tissues, etc.), including swabs from touched objects, which are very numerous in the forensic context. This method has been extensively used continuously for nine years, following an initial validation process, and is part of the ISO/IEC 17025 accredited method. In routine practice, based on the quantitative values determined from the extracts of each trace, we use a standard method or a low-copy-number method that involves repeating the amplification with the generation of a consensus genetic profile. Nowadays, when the quantification results are less than 0.003 ng/μL in the minimum extraction volume (40 μL), we do not proceed with the DNA extract analysis. By verifying the limits of the method, we make a conscious cost-benefit choice, in particular by using the least amount of DNA needed to obtain sufficiently robust genetic profiles appropriate for submission to the Italian DNA Forensic Database. In this work, we present a critical re-evaluation of this phase of the method, which is based on the use of standard curves obtained from the average values of the control DNA analysed in duplicate. Considering the various contributions to uncertainty that are difficult to measure, such as manual pipetting or analytical phases carried out by different operators, we have decided to thoroughly investigate the contribution of variability in the preparation of calibration curves to the final results. Thus, 757 samples from 20 independent experiments were re-evaluated using two different standards for the construction of curves, determining the quantitative differences between the two methods. The experiments also determined the parameters of the slope, Y-intercept, R2, and the values of the synthetic control probe to verify how these parameters can provide information on the final outcome of each analysis. The outcome of this revalidation demonstrated that it is preferable to use quantification ranges rather than exact quantitative limits before deciding how to analyse the extracts via PCR or forgoing the determination of profiles. Additionally, we present some preliminary data related to the analysis of samples that would not have been analysed based on the initial validation, from which genetic profiles were obtained after applying a concentration method to the extracts. Our goal is to improve the accredited analytical method, with a careful risk assessment as indicated by accreditation standards, ensuring that no source of evidence is lost in the reconstruction of a criminal event.

Developmental validation of a multiplex qPCR assay for simultaneous quantification of nuclear and mitochondrial DNA

Looking into the Quantification of Forensic Samples with Real-Time PCR

Simultaneous quantitative assessment of circulating cell-free mitochondrial and nuclear DNA by multiplex real-time PCR.

A Custom qPCR Assay to Simultaneously Quantify Human and Microbial DNA

Multiplex time-reducing quantitative polymerase chain reaction assay for determination of telomere length in blood and tissue DNA

The Usefulness of qPCR Data for Sample Pre-Assessment and Interpretation of Genetic Typing Results

Quantitation of human mitochondrial DNA and whole mtGenomes sequencing of fingernail/hair shaft samples

An Assessment of the Performance Limitations of the Integrated QuantifilerTM Trio-HRM Assay: A Forensic Tool Designed to Identify Mixtures at the Quantification Stage

Validation of the DNATyper™15 PCR Genotyping System for Forensic Application

Forensic efficiency evaluation of a mtDNA whole genome sequencing system constructed with long fragment amplification strategy on DNA nanoball sequencing platform

Multiplex Mutagenically Separated Polymerase Chain Reaction Assay For Rapid Detection Of Human Mitochondrial Dna Variations In Coding Area

Development and Validation of Novel 8-Dye Short Tandem Repeat Multiplex System for Forensic Applications.

Evaluation of microfluidics-based droplet PCR combined with multiplex STR system in forensic science

Developmental Validation of the Microreader 23HS Plex ID System: A Novel Supplementary Non‐CODIS STR Multiplex Assay for Forensic Application

Detection and Quantification of Large Scale Deletions of Human Mitochondrial DNA by Real‐time PCR

Cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1-based human RNA quantification to enhance mRNA profiling in forensic biology

Developing a multiplex mtSNP assay for forensic application in Han Chinese based on mtDNA phylogeny and hot spot.

Development and validation of a 4-color multiplexing spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) genotyping assay on a novel integrated digital PCR instrument

Rapid and Sensitive Human-Specific DNA Quantitation Using a Microfluidic Amplification Module at the Point-of-Care

Development of a SNP-STRs Multiplex for Forensic Identification

Development and Validation of a Forensic Multiplex System With 38 X-InDel Loci