A Radiocarbon Dated Pollen Sequence from the Wells Mastodon Site Near Rochester
J. Gordon
Abstract:A radiocarbon date (1-586, 12,000=450) has been obtained from wood beneath a mastodon (Mastodon americanus) in north-central Indiana. The sediment sequence includes 72 inches of marl at the base, overlain by 12 inches of sand, capped by 34 inches of peat. The peat is truncated at the top by fire and cultivation. Pollen spectra from the marl associated with the mastodon burial indicate a predominantly coniferous forest consisting of spruce (Picea), fir (Abies), birch (Betula), and ash (Fraxinus) with small amounts of oak (Quercus), Hickory (Carya), and elm (Ulmus) pollen. Field evidence and pollen data indicate that the animal died prior to the formation of the peat. Correlation of this sequence with other radiocarbon-dated pollen sequences indicates that the mastodon died prior to the replacement of spruce pollen by oak pollen approximately 10,500 years ago. Molluscan data support the inferences derived from the pollen analysis. A vertebra and the right lower jaw of a Mastodon americanus were uncovered in 1959 in the excavation of a drainage ditch on a farm five miles west of Rochester, Indiana (fig. 1). Cursory probing by Mr. James Wells, owner of the farm, and James Cope and James Thorp of Earlham College revealed more bones a few feet below the bottom of the ditch. About 25 persons, under the direction of James Cope and Gertrude Ward of Earlham's Joseph Moore Museum, assisted during the summer of 1960 in the recovery of most of the mastodon skeleton. A. M. Gooding assisted with the dig, studied the geological setting and stratigraphy, and collected samples for pollen, molluscan, and radiocarbon analysis. John O'Brien, an Earlham senior geology major, studied and prepared the molluscan data, and J. Gordon Ogden, III, with technical assistance by Barbara Spross, prepared and analyzed the pollen samples. A pollen diagram and discussion of the conditions of burial are included in this report. GEOLOGICAL SETTING The Wells Mastodon Site is located in a broad area of valley train and outwash deposits between the Maxinkuckee and Packerton Moraines of Cary age (fig. 2). Outwash sands around the mastodon site have been worked by the wind in places, and groups of low dune hills interrupt the otherwise flat topography of the area. The water table is high, natural drainage poor, and extensive areas are covered with peat (Carlisle muck soil; Rogers, 1956) which lap onto the dune hills. The peat is commonly underlain with marl of variable thickness. The sluggish Mud Creek drainage system (fig. 1), along one tributary of which the Wells mastodon site is located, probably originally connected a series of small lakes and ponds in the area. STRATIGRAPHY OF MASTODON SITE The drainage ditch in which the mastodon was exposed was cut initially to a Manuscript received February 16, 1964. THE OHIO JOURNAL OF SCIENCE 65(1): 1, January, 1965. ANSEL M. GOODING AND J. GORDON OGDEN, III Vol. 65 depth of about 5 ft to improve the Carlisle muck soil for agricultural use. Excavation for the skeleton extended across the drainage ditch, and a pit was opened which measured about 30 ft across and 8 ft deep (fig. 3). The following stratigraphic section on the south side of the pit was measured, described, and sampled for pollen and radiocarbon analysis: Unit Thickness Description 3 34 in. Peat—dense, black to brown. Upper few inches showed effects of burning of surface vegetation. 2 12 in. Sand—well-sorted quartz sand, probably largely windblown, containing numerous fine streaks of finely divided organic matter. 1 72 in. Marl—gray, consisting almost entirely of fragments of gastropod and pelecypod shells. An occasional piece of wood was encountered in this unit, but no concentration of plant remains. Radiocarbon-dated wood sample collected at 90 in. from surface (1-586,12,000 ±450). Bottom 28 in. determined by auger. Bottom of marl probably on till. Later extension of the pit to the north showed the same stratigraphy, although units varied slightly in thickness. INTERPRETATION OF FIELD DATA The Wells mastodon is exceptionally well preserved and few of the bones are broken or fragmented. Except for the left legs and the pelvis, which probably FIGURE 1. Location of the Wells Mastodon Site, near the center of the SE 14., Sec. 17, T.3ON. R.2E., in Fulton County, Indiana. 2 No. 1 POLLEN SEQUENCE FROM WELLS MASTODON SITE, INDIANA 3 lie deeper in the marl, most of the skeleton was recovered. None of the bones show rodent teeth marks or other evidence of surface exposure after death. All of the skeletal remains were found in marl (unit 1), mostly in a zone between 5 and 7 ft below the surface, although some bones extended vertically downward to greater depths. The skull, with the lower jaws and the right tusk in place, was overturned to the left about 130 degrees. Most of the rest of the bones were found approximately in their proper positions with respect to this orientation of the skull. Although, obviously, the marl sediment around the skeleton must have been disturbed by the animal in his death struggles, and by later oozing into skeletal cavities, the field evidence suggests that burial occurred before the completion of