Hypotony Failure Criteria in Glaucoma Surgical Studies and Their Influence on Surgery Success
Alessandro Rabiolo,Giacinto Triolo,Daniela Khaliliyeh,Sang Wook Jin,Esteban Morales,Alessandro Ghirardi,Nitin Anand,Giovanni Montesano,Gianni Virgili,Joseph Caprioli,Stefano De Cillà
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ophtha.2024.01.008
IF: 14.277
2024-01-11
Ophthalmology
Abstract:Purpose Review hypotony failure criteria used in glaucoma surgical outcome studies and evaluate their impact on success rates. Design Systematic literature review and application of hypotony failure criteria to two retrospective cohorts. Participants 934 eyes and 1,765 eyes undergoing trabeculectomy and deep sclerectomy (DS) with a median follow-up of 41.4 and 45.4 months, respectively. Methods Literature-based hypotony failure criteria were applied to patient cohorts. IOP-related success was defined as: (A) IOP≤21 mmHg with ≥20% IOP reduction; (B) IOP≤18 mmHg with ≥20% reduction; (C) IOP≤15 mmHg with ≥25% reduction; (D) IOP≤12 mmHg with ≥30% reduction. Failure was defined as: IOP exceeding these criteria in two consecutive visits >3 months after surgery, loss of light perception, additional IOP-lowering surgery, or hypotony. Cox regression estimated failure risk for different hypotony criteria, using no hypotony as a reference. Analyses were conducted for each criterion and hypotony type (i.e., numerical [IOP threshold], clinical [clinical manifestations], mixed [combination of numerical and/or clinical criteria]). Main Outcome Measures Hazard ratio (HR) for failure risk. Results Of 2,503 studies found, 278 were eligible, with 99 (35.6%) studies lacking hypotony failure criteria. Numerical hypotony was predominant (157 studies [56.5%]). Few studies employed clinical hypotony (3 isolated [1.1%]; 19 combined with low IOP [6.8%]). Forty-nine different criteria were found, with IOP<6 mmHg, IOP<6 mmHg on ≥2 consecutive visits after 3 months, and IOP<5 mmHg being the most common (41 [14.7%], 38 [13.7%], and 13 [4.7%] studies, respectively). In both cohorts, numerical hypotony posed the highest risk of failure (HR between 1.51-1.21 for criteria A to D; p<0.001), followed by mixed hypotony (HR between 1.41-1.20 for criteria A to D; p<0.001), and clinical hypotony (HR between 1.12-1.04; p=0.07 for DS criteria D, p≤0.017 for other criteria). Failure risk varied greatly with various hypotony definitions, with HR ranging between 1.02-10.79 for trabeculectomy and 1.00-8.36 for DS. Discussion Hypotony failure criteria are highly heterogenous in the glaucoma literature, with few studies focusing on clinical manifestations. Numerical hypotony yields higher failure rates than clinical hypotony and can underestimate glaucoma surgery success rates. Standardizing failure criteria with an emphasis on clinically relevant hypotony manifestations is needed.
ophthalmology