Sex Differences in Aggression: Female Hermit Crabs Initiate Few Fights against Males and Lose Most of Those

Melissa Plasman,Luis M Burciaga,Guillermina Alcaraz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/732257

Abstract:AbstractIndividuals with similar biological requirements frequently compete for resources. Males and females have evolved different reproductive strategies in which females invest more in fecundity and males in intrasexual competition for mates. Although less common than within-sex competition, intersexual contests may occur to obtain resources. Interindividual differences in fighting ability bias the benefits and costs between opponents, and those differences are expected to be greater in intersexual contests. We compared the chela size, muscular strength, metabolic rate, and relative boldness of males and females of Calcinus californiensis Bouvier, 1898. We further investigated how these traits influence intra- and intersexual contests for shells, with both sexes assuming roles as attackers and defenders. Males and females do not differ in chela size, muscular strength, or boldness. While males exhibited higher metabolic rates, this did not explain contest initiation or outcomes. Surprisingly, females initiated fewer contests against males than against females, and those that did often lost. However, this outcome was not attributed to sexually dimorphic traits. Instead, fighting success correlated with individual boldness and rapping frequency. Interestingly, rapping performance did not correlate with boldness, metabolic rate, or muscular strength, contrary to expectations. Our result reaffirms the common disadvantage of females as attackers in intersexual contests. However, they proved adept at defending their shells in both intra- and intersexual scenarios. This result, in addition to their typically efficient exploratory ability, raises questions about resource acquisition and distribution pathways in each sex.