Abstract:In decision-making scenarios, \textit{reasoning} can be viewed as an algorithm $P$ that makes a choice of an action $a^* \in \mathcal{A}$, aiming to optimize some outcome such as maximizing the value function of a Markov decision process (MDP). However, executing $P$ itself may bear some costs (time, energy, limited capacity, etc.) and needs to be considered alongside explicit utility obtained by making the choice in the underlying decision problem. Such costs need to be taken into account in order to accurately model human behavior, as well as optimizing AI planning, as all physical systems are bound to face resource constraints. Finding the right $P$ can itself be framed as an optimization problem over the space of reasoning processes $P$, generally referred to as \textit{metareasoning}. Conventionally, human metareasoning models assume that the agent knows the transition and reward distributions of the underlying MDP. This paper generalizes such models by proposing a meta Bayes-Adaptive MDP (meta-BAMDP) framework to handle metareasoning in environments with unknown reward/transition distributions, which encompasses a far larger and more realistic set of planning problems that humans and AI systems face. As a first step, we apply the framework to two-armed Bernoulli bandit (TABB) tasks, which have often been used to study human decision making. Owing to the meta problem's complexity, our solutions are necessarily approximate, but nevertheless robust within a range of assumptions that are arguably realistic for human decision-making scenarios. These results offer a normative framework for understanding human exploration under cognitive constraints. This integration of Bayesian adaptive strategies with metareasoning enriches both the theoretical landscape of decision-making research and practical applications in designing AI systems that plan under uncertainty and resource constraints.

Bayes beyond the predictive distribution

Meta-Learned Models of Cognition

Probabilistic programming versus meta-learning as models of cognition

Meta-learning as a bridge between neural networks and symbolic Bayesian models

Bayes in the Age of Intelligent Machines

Beyond Bayes-optimality: meta-learning what you know you don't know

Meta-learning in active inference

Meta-learning goes hand-in-hand with metacognition

More Flexible PAC-Bayesian Meta-Learning by Learning Learning Algorithms

Scientists Invent New Hypotheses, Do Brains?

Probabilistic Meta-Representations Of Neural Networks

Meta-prediction extends human cortical and subcortical reward learning

Learning from a lot: Empirical Bayes in high-dimensional prediction settings

The reinforcement metalearner as a biologically plausible meta-learning framework

Bayesian Model-Agnostic Meta-Learning

Bayesian Nonparametrics: An Alternative to Deep Learning

Predictive Processing, Rational Constructivism, and Bayesian Models of Development: Commentary

Toward a principled Bayesian workflow in cognitive science.

Computational Neuropsychology and Bayesian Inference

Metareasoning in uncertain environments: a meta-BAMDP framework