Perceptions of Vocal Performance Impairment in Singers with and without Hearing Loss
Gurmehr Brar,Einav Silverstein,Melissa Zheng,M Eugenia Castro,Raymond Goldsworthy,Lynn Helding,Michael M Johns
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2021.06.021
Abstract:Introduction: It is well understood that hearing plays an important role in accurate vocal production. Singers in particular rely on auditory cues and auditory feedback to reproduce specific pitch contours. Therefore, even mild hearing loss may have a detrimental effect on a singer's ability to perform. This study investigates the effect of hearing loss on self-reported vocal production in singers, specifically in the domains of pitch matching, pitch maintenance, vowel production, and dynamic control as well as the effect of hearing loss on vocal handicap. Methods: An 18-item electronic self-report survey was distributed to the members of the National Association of Teachers of Singing and to the Voice Foundation. Data collected included demographics, the Singing Voice Handicap Index-10 (SVHI-10), and a series of closed and open-ended questions. Demographic variables, variables related to the SVHI-10, and variables related to the newly introduced survey were included in a hierarchical regression analysis to determine significant relationships. Results: Among 206 eligible participants, 37 individuals reported a voice problem, 58 reported hearing loss, and 19 reported concurrent hearing loss and a voice problem. Among males, there were no significant differences between hearing impaired and normal hearing singers in reported pitch matching, pitch maintenance, dynamic control, and vowel matching when those with voice problems were excluded and included. However, in females, when singers with voice problems were excluded, there was a significant difference between hearing impaired and normal hearing singers in pitch matching (P = 0.38). Additionally, when singers with voice problems were included in the female subset, significant differences emerged between the hearing impaired and normal hearing singers in areas of pitch matching (P = 0.01) and vowel matching (P = 0.02). Further, controlling for gender, when excluding voice problems, there was a significant difference between the SVHI-10 scores of normal hearing (mean = 9.03) and hearing impaired participants (mean = 11.30, P = 0.02). This difference continued to be significant when including those with voice problems (normal hearing mean = 9.97, hearing impaired mean=14.1, P <0.0001). Additionally, individuals with hearing impairments were more likely to report higher perceived vocal handicap scores as reflected on the SVHI-10 than normal hearing respondents (P = 0.002). Other factors associated with higher likelihood of SVHI-10 score include older age (P = 0.008), having a voice problem (P <0.0001), and being paid to sing within the past six months (P = 0.001). Conclusion: When controlling for voice problems, singers with hearing impairments subjectively did not perceive that they performed less accurately on pitch matching, pitch maintenance, dynamic control, and vowel matching, yet they scored higher on the SVHI-10 indicating vocal handicap. Further study is needed to characterize the relationship between perceived and measured vocal accuracy in singers with hearing loss.