Point-counterpoint: sinusitis.

D. Nash

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/PIR.22-9-291

2001-09-01

Pediatrics in Review

Abstract:1. David Nash, MD* 1. 2. *Assistant Professor of Pediatrics Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, PA A reader writes, “Would the authors change their recommendations (Sinusitis. Pediatr Rev . 2001;22:111–117) in terms of the new data published by Garbutt et al in the April 2001 issue of Pediatrics ?” Previous work has clearly demonstrated that the sinuses can become infected with bacteria and that antimicrobial therapy increases both the rate and number of patients cured.((1))((2)) These studies have used some combination of clinical history, radiograph imaging, and sinus aspiration to diagnose acute bacterial sinusitis. The impracticality of sinus aspiration combined with the uncertainty associated with the interpretation of radiographic images of the sinuses has led to the use of clinical criteria to diagnose acute bacterial sinusitis. In fact, several national organizations recently developed recommendations for diagnosing this condition exclusively by clinical criteria.((3))((4))((5)) The Garbutt article is the first to examine the exclusive use of clinical criteria to identify patients who have acute sinusitis and to determine …