Mental Health in Medicine Crisis: A Quantitative Survey of the Mental Health of Rising/Current Physicians
E. Vanessa Spearman-McCarthy,Colin Miller,Danyelle Nelson,Sophia Samuel,Priscilla Ajala,Eathan Kepp,Ranah Ocampo,Maresa Tate,Sydney Jones
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.01.197
IF: 7.996
2024-02-22
American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
Abstract:Introduction Health professionals are some of the most resilient human beings in society. Every day they are exposed to disease, distress, and disability for reasons that are complex and multifaceted. The constant encounters with socio-environmental, occupational, and personal factors of patients can eventually begin to affect health professionals. Consequently, physicians are one of the largest groups of health professionals that suffer from mental health disorders, largely beginning in the first stages of medical training. During these periods, physicians learn and form the behaviors, attitudes, and habits that will shape the way that they operate in their practice and personal lives. Although these aspects are not always harmful, the way in which physicians choose to manage their health - physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually - can determine how optimal they perform patient care and participate in teamwork amongst their colleagues. However, due to the real and perceived barriers that physicians face, such as mental health stigmas amongst providers, workload, and confidential access to health services, many choose to forgo treatment for their mental health needs. Therefore, in this study, the question was raised regarding how likely physicians and physicians-in-training are willing to accept mental health treatment. Additional questions examined participant comfortability with mental health, knowledge of surrounding treatment programs at work and/or school, and the decision to pursue mental health treatment. We hypothesized that the majority of those who took the survey would choose answers that were neutral, largely due to avoidance of being controversial; lack of knowledge about their own or general mental health amongst their counterparts; and/or the minimal time and/or effort to complete the survey. Methods An anonymous electronic survey was created via SurveyMonkey to measure mental health perceptions among physicians and physicians-in-training. Survey was created by Medical College of Georgia's (MCG) Student Educational Enrichment Program (SEEP) Advanced Scholars in the summer of 2023. Survey questions were adapted from domestic and international surveys regarding the health and wellbeing of physicians and physicians-in-training. It analyzed if individuals within the field of medicine were supplied with adequate resources for their mental health, felt comfortable in disclosing their mental health status to colleagues or a supervisor, or felt comfortable seeking help for their mental health1-4. The survey was distributed to pre-medicine and medical students, residents, attendings and retired physicians via e-mail, social media, and text messaging. Survey responses were collected for one week before being closed for analysis. Results 171 participants (63.16% female; 36.26% male; 0.58% nonbinary/genderqueer) completed the survey. Majority of respondents identified as Black or African American (53.22%) and lived in the South Atlantic region of the USA (80.70%), with the least number of reported respondents from American Indian or Alaskan Native (0.00%) and those living in the Mountain region of the USA (0.59%). Average age of respondents was 28.5 years (SD = 39.00) with the majority ranging from 20-30 years of age (62.75%).Figures 1 and 4, representing all survey participants demonstrated that a large number of physicians and physicians-in-training acknowledged that mental health struggles were not openly discussed in the professional environment and that more than 50% of participant would not be comfortable in disclosing their own personal mental health struggles. Figures 2 and 5, representing physicians-in-training only showed similar data. Figures 3 and 7, representing physicians were similar. However, data suggests that practicing physicians were a little more comfortable in revealing personal struggles with mental illness, than physicians-in-training. Conclusions Although physicians experienced less openness in sharing struggles in the professional community compared to medical students, they were more likely to express their struggles with mental health than medical students. This may be due to a social stigma present among the professional community and an increase in coping strategies employed by physicians. As individuals progress through medical school and residency, they are more likely to adapt to stressful environments by incorporating coping mechanisms. These may include talking with friends and family, exercise, meditation, and use of prescription medication. Furthermore, the medical hierarchy can contribute to the inability to express mental health to the professional community due to the -Abstract Truncated-
psychiatry,geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology