Tailored Intraoperative MRI Strategies in High-Grade Glioma Surgery: A Machine Learning–Based Radiomics Model Highlights Selective Benefits
Martin Aichholzer,Philip Rauch,Lucia Kastler,Josef Pichler,Kathrin Aufschnaiter-Hiessböck,Francisco Ruiz-Navarro,Stefan Aspalter,Saskia Hartl,Wolfgang Schimetta,Petra Böhm,Ilja Manakov,Wolfgang Thomae,Matthias Gmeiner,Andreas Gruber,Harald Stefanits
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1227/ons.0000000000001023
IF: 2.817
2023-12-22
Operative Neurosurgery
Abstract:BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: In high-grade glioma (HGG) surgery, intraoperative MRI (iMRI) has traditionally been the gold standard for maximizing tumor resection and improving patient outcomes. However, recent Level 1 evidence juxtaposes the efficacy of iMRI and 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA), questioning the continued justification of iMRI because of its associated costs and extended surgical duration. Nonetheless, drawing from our clinical observations, we postulated that a subset of intricate HGGs may continue to benefit from the adjunctive application of iMRI. METHODS: In a prospective study of 73 patients with HGG, 5-ALA was the primary technique for tumor delineation, complemented by iMRI to detect residual contrast-enhanced regions. Suboptimal 5-ALA efficacy was defined when (1) iMRI detected contrast-enhanced remnants despite 5-ALA's indication of a gross total resection or (2) surgeons observed residual fluorescence, contrary to iMRI findings. Radiomic features from preoperative MRIs were extracted using a U2-Net deep learning algorithm. Binary logistic regression was then used to predict compromised 5-ALA performance. RESULTS: Resections guided solely by 5-ALA achieved an average removal of 93.14% of contrast-enhancing tumors. This efficacy increased to 97% with iMRI integration, albeit not statistically significant. Notably, for tumors with suboptimal 5-ALA performance, iMRI's inclusion significantly improved resection outcomes ( P -value: .00013). The developed deep learning–based model accurately pinpointed these scenarios, and when enriched with radiomic parameters, showcased high predictive accuracy, as indicated by a Nagelkerke R 2 of 0.565 and a receiver operating characteristic of 0.901. CONCLUSION: Our machine learning–driven radiomics approach predicts scenarios where 5-ALA alone may be suboptimal in HGG surgery compared with its combined use with iMRI. Although 5-ALA typically yields favorable results, our analyses reveal that HGGs characterized by significant volume, complex morphology, and left-sided location compromise the effectiveness of resections relying exclusively on 5-ALA. For these intricate cases, we advocate for the continued relevance of iMRI.
surgery,clinical neurology