One-phase Treatment for Calculous Pyonephrosis by Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Assisted by EMS LithoClast Master
Wang Jian,Zhou Da-qing,He Meng,Li Wen-gang,Pang Xiang,Yu Xiao-xiang,Jiang Bo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.0366-6999.20122455
IF: 6.133
2013-01-01
Chinese Medical Journal
Abstract:The one-phase therapy for calculous pyonephrosis through percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) is currently vigorously debated. After a definite preoperative diagnosis of pyonephrosis, the traditional approach1 has been initial drainage through puncture and nephrostomy. Upon the stabilization of symptoms, a second-phase operation is performed. If pus is discovered during an intra-operative puncture, a nephrostomy tube is deposited until a second elective operation. With the advancements of science and technology, the third generation EMS LithoClast master is capable of not only efficiently crushing and removing the stones, but also lowering the intra-pelvic pressure through vacuum suction. Thus the surgical risks have been greatly reduced so that many one-phase operations for calculous pyonephrosis may be completed.2 Ever since the application of EMS LithoClast master at our department since 2006, a total of 128 patients with calculous pyonephrosis have been surgically cured within one single phase. No overt complication was observed. In conjunction with the study results of high-pressure perfusion in animal models of pyonephrosis, a report was compiled as below. METHODS Clinical data During the period of 2006-2011, a total of 128 patients with calculous pyonephrosis were admitted and treated at our hospital. There were 57 males and 71 females with an average age of 43 years (range: 24-66). There were renal calculus (n=83), upper ureterolithiasis (n=21) and renoureter calculus (n=24). The average areas of renal and urethral calculus were 4.6 and 1.8 cm2, respectively. The blood routines and temperatures of all patients were within the normal ranges. Thus the possibility of acute stage infection was ruled out. On urinalysis, the count of white blood cells (WBC) varied between 0 and 4+. The preoperative examinations of type B ultrasound or computed tomography (CT) revealed pyonephrosis in 42 cases. And 86 cases of pyonephrosis were diagnosed intraoperatively. Protocol After admission, the routine examinations of mid-stream urine culture, complete blood count, urinalysis, renal function, kidney-ureter-bladder radiography and intravenous pyelogram (KUB+IVP), type B ultrasound, and CT were performed. At Day 1-3 preoperation, antibiotics were prescribed. Before PCNL, the lithotomy position was adopted and a F5 urethral catheter was inserted through retrograde cystoscope to establish artificial hydronephrosis. The perfusion of artificial hydronephrosis was ceased if irrigated pus was found. Any irrigated pus was retained for culturing. Then a procumbent position was assumed. The puncture zone was between posterior axillary and scapular lines and at 11th inter-costal space or under 12th rib. Based on the distribution of stone and the status of hydronephrosis, type B ultrasonic guidance was used to puncture upper renal calyx or posterior middle calyx. There was an outflow of pus if the puncture became successful. And 5-10 ml pus was drawn with an aseptic syringe for culturing. Along a guide wire, fascia dilator and nested dilator were used successively to create a standard F24 nephroscopic tract. Firstly, an EMS ultrasonic probe was used to aspirate pus away completely. Then perfusion fluid was used for low-pressure perfusion. Alternatively, natural flow rate was employed for perfusion without going through a pressuring pump. Based on the hardness of stone, simple ultrasonic lithotripsy was employed as much as possible. If stone hardness was too high, the combined method of ultrasonic and pneumatic lithotripters was employed. Simple pneumatic lithotripters were avoided as much as possible. The operative duration was controlled within 2 hours. If it was impossible to remove residual stones completely within a short period of time, a double-J-shaped F7 irrigation tube was implanted and an F20 nephrostomy tube was inserted for external drainage. Intravenous use of an antibiotic was initiated once preoperatively and the anti-infective therapy was strengthened postopratively. If the drainage fluid of nephrostomy tube was turbid, an intermittent flushing of nephrostomy tube with furacilin was started. Animal model Five male mini-swines weighted 25-30 kg were selected. After anesthesia, right ureter was exposed via laparotomy. At 5 cm from right kidney, 2 ml normal saline supernatant with swine stool was injected with a syringe. The abdomen was closed after ligation. The contralateral kidney was selected as a healthy control. The model of pyonephrosis was established 2-3 days later. After anesthesia, laparotomy was performed to expose bilateral kidneys and ureters. Upon the ligation of bilateral ureters, a pressure-measuring tube and an infusion tube were inserted from proximal ureter into pelvis. Prior to perfusion, a puncture needle each was advanced into healthy and suppurative kidneys for tissue biopsy. Normal saline was infused into the pelvis to allow a rapid rise of intra-pelvic pressure up to 10 mmHg. After a 10-minute maintenance, a pelvis infusion tube was released. At this moment, both healthy and suppurative kidneys were punctured for tissue biopsy. Likewise, puncture biopsy was performed at the intra-pelvic pressure gradients of 20, 30, 40, and 50 mmHg. For each pressure gradient, the infusion fluid should be completely discharged after maintaining for 10 minutes. And the punctured tissues were sent for pathological examinations. RESULTS Results of operation All patients underwent one-phase surgical procedures successfully via a single track. One-phase complete calculi removal was achieved in 93 cases with a calculi removal rate of 73%. For large residual calculi, 26 patients underwent second-stage calculi extraction 1 week later. For small residual calculi, nine patients underwent extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL). Low-grade fever (<38.5°C) occurred in 85 cases. There were no chills, higher fever, septicemia, or septic shock. All patients were discharged uneventfully. There was no mortality. Results of animal experiments When the pathological changes of tubular dilation, capsular dilation, and glomerular compression occurred in both healthy and suppurative kidneys after pelvic pressuring (Figure 1), the suppurative kidneys had the onsets of interstitial edema and infiltration of inflammatory cells. When the infusion pressure was elevated up to 20 mmHg, tubular degeneration and necrosis were found in suppurative kidneys. When the pressure was elevated to 40 mmHg, the glomerular and tubular lesions became more apparent. There were the destruction and disappearance of focal glomerular and tubular structures. And, under the same load of pressure, the healthy side was mainly characterized by tubular dilation, capsular dilation, glomerular compression, etc. There were fewer destructive changes.Figure 1.: Results of pathological examinations (HE staining, original magnification ×200). A: In healthy kidneys, when the pressure was elevated to 20 mmHg, there were tubular and capsular dilations and the structures of nephrons remained intact. B: In healthy kidneys, when the pressure reached 40 mmHg, there were marked tubular and capsular dilations and the structures were basically intact. C: In suppurative kidneys, when the pressure reached 20 mmHg, there were tubular and capsular dilations and partial destruction of tubular wall. D: In suppurative kidneys, when the pressure reached 40 mmHg, the glomerular and tubular structures became disrupted and hemorrhage occurred.DISCUSSION During PCNL, a continuous flow of fluid must be maintained to ensure a distinct operating field for stone-crushing. Whether or not continuous flushing may cause a renal reflux of pathogens to result in septicemia, Stenberg et al3 obtained that a veins backflow was present when the perfusion pressure was at 20-25 mmHg. Another study indicated that liquid was also absorbed through the impaired collecting system and mucous and vascular systems were opened by puncture routes.4 During preliminary explorations of PCNL, our department has performed one-phase PCNL for several dozen cases of calculous pyonephrosis. All patients recovered excellently without any overt complication. For the purpose of exploring the feasibility of this surgical procedure so as to provide theoretic rationales for further therapy, we developed a live swine model of pyonephrosis through high-pressure perfusion. A gradient of perfusion pressures was applied and their corresponding renal pathological changes were examined. As demonstrated by the experimental results, the phenomenon of renal tubular degeneration and necrosis was apparent in purulent infected swine kidneys at 20 mmHg. In comparison, for contralateral healthy kidneys, even if the perfusion pressure was elevated up to 50 mmHg, no overt destruction of nephrons was observed. Thus it was deduced that if the intrapelvic pressure was controlled intraoperatively under 20 mmHg, the possibility of bacterial backflow was extremely small. Even if a small amount of bacteria entered the bloodstream, they would be eliminated by the body's immune system. Thus the operation was deemed safe. In addition, the data were collected under the condition of acute infections. And most clinical cases of pyonephrosis were caused by long-term repeated infections. Especially the asymptomatic patients with calculous pyonephrosis might stay within a period of chronic infections. Covered with a dense coat of pus, the pelvic surface should be able to withstand a greater pressure. The third generation EMS LithoClast master is capable of not only efficiently crushing and removing the stones, but also lowering the intrapelvic pressure through vacuum suction. During the course of PCNL at our department, the intra-pelvic pressures fluctuated within a range of 5.8-44.1 mmHg. The average pressure was (17.0±1.8) mmHg. A high pressure occurred during the single application of pneumatic lithotripsy. When combined with ultrasonic lithotripsy, the pressures stayed at around 22 mmHg.5 The intra-pelvic pressure was mostly below 20 mmHg for ultrasonic lithotripsy. During the period of 2006 to 2011, our department has successfully performed one-phase PCNL to treat 128 patients with calculous pyonephrosis. Septicemia was not observed. Our experiences were summarized as follows. During the period of acute infections, the procedure of drainage through puncture and nephrostomy was initially performed; a routine pre-operative anti-infective therapy was administrated for 1-3 days. One dose of antibiotic was prescribed at the start of intra-operative anesthesia. And the postoperative anti-infective therapy lasted for 1 week or until the stabilization of symptoms. A standard F24 nephroscopic tract was created intraoperatively routinely. The patent tract might yield a distinct surgical field with a lower perfusion and shorten the operative duration. The single intraoperative use of pneumatic lithotripter should be avoided as much as possible. The perfusion fluid was infused at a low rate. Alternatively, a natural flow was used for flushing without a pressuring pump; if the residual stones were too plentiful or hard to be cleared completely within a short time, operation should be stopped timely. Further maneuvers were meaningless. A F20 nephrostomy tube was deposited for an elective second-phase operation. In conclusion, when the intra-pelvic pressure is below 20 mmHg, it is feasible to use the EMS LithoClast master for one-phase PCNL of the relatively symptomatically stable patients with calculous pyonephrosis. Nevertheless, this surgical procedure has always carried high risks and its advantages and disadvantages should be validated by further studies of larger sample sizes.