Abstract:A central question in consciousness theories is whether one is dealing with a dichotomous (“all-or-none”) or a gradual phenomenon. In this 7T fMRI study we investigated whether dichotomy or gradualness in fact depends on the brain region associated with perceptual awareness reports. Both male and female human subjects performed an emotion discrimination task (fear vs neutral bodies) presented under continuous flash suppression with trial-based perceptual awareness measures. Behaviorally, recognition sensitivity increased linearly with increased stimuli awareness and was at chance level during perceptual unawareness. Physiologically, threat stimuli triggered a slower heart rate than neutral ones during ‘almost clear’ stimulus experience, indicating freezing behavior. Brain results showed that activity in occipito-temporal, parietal and frontal regions as well as in amygdala increased with increased stimulus awareness while early visual areas showed the opposite pattern. The relationship between temporal area activity and perceptual awareness best fitted a gradual model while the activity in fronto-parietal areas fitted a dichotomous model. Furthermore, our findings demonstrate that specific experimental decisions, such as stimulus type or the approach used to evaluate awareness, play pivotal roles in consciousness studies and warrant careful consideration. Significance Statement The neural basis of consciousness is still highly debated as major theoretical and methodological questions on perceptual awareness and its assessment remain unsolved. Most studies have employed a dichotomous measure (yes/no, seen/unseen) to assess awareness and consequently found that consciousness is an “all-or-none” phenomenon. However, finer measures have revealed intermediate levels of awareness. It is still an open question whether affective signal processing, such as for body expressions, presents a gradual or a dichotomous relationship to perceptual awareness. We take up this challenge and show that perceptual awareness is gradual or dichotomous depending on the brain region considered, possibly reflecting different area functionality.

Physical effort modulates perceptual awareness judgment independent of level of processing

The Level of Processing Modulates Visual Awareness: Evidence from Behavioral and Electrophysiological Measures

Reconceptualizing Perceptual Load As a Rate Problem: the Role of Time in the Allocation of Selective Attention.

Perceptual processing demands influence voluntary task choice

Perceptual Load Modulates Contour Integration in Conscious and Unconscious States

Effect of Level of Processing Prior to Response on Cognitive Control:Evidence from ERP

Influence of Simple Action on Subsequent Manual and Ocular Responses

The Perception Versus Action Hypothesis and Attention Guide

Neural mechanisms of awareness of action

Simple actions modulate context-dependent visual size perception at late processing stages

The involvement of the human prefrontal cortex in the emergence of visual awareness

High Visual Perceptual Load Reduces Prepulse Inhibition Induced by Task-Unrelated and Task-Related Sound.

The interplay of perceptual processing demands and practice in modulating voluntary and involuntary motor responses

Event-related Potential Patterns of Selective Attention Modulated by Perceptual Load.

Is auditory awareness graded or dichotomous: Electrophysiological correlates of consciousness at different depths of stimulus processing

Pupil size variations correlate with physical effort perception

Ultrahigh field fMRI reveals different roles of temporal and fronto-parietal cortices in subjective awareness

Ultrahigh Field fMRI Reveals Different Roles of the Temporal and Frontoparietal Cortices in Subjective Awareness

Establishing gaze markers of perceptual load during multi-target visual search

Action information contributes to metacognitive decision-making

Stimulus driven attention-shift as a driver of apparent motion perception