Employee Benefits for Dependents with ADHD: An Opportunity for Improvement

Michelle M. Macias

2005-02-01

Abstract:Pediatric practitioners that work with children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) recognize this group has special health care needs, yet comprehensive treatment is often difficult to obtain due to limitations in coverage by health insurance. The impact of health care benefits for children with ADHD has generated little discussion in the literature, despite the obvious importance of the topic. The article by Perrin, et al, in this issue of JDBP is an important contribution to the literature, as it describes benefits provided by ‘‘family friendly’’ companies beyond typical medical benefits. Indeed, we face just the first challenge as we struggle to diagnose, then implement and disseminate the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) guidelines on assessment and treatment of ADHD. How is patient adherence to our evaluations and treatment plans affected if the services and interventions we recommend are not covered by a health plan? ADHD is the most common behavioral/mental health disorder in children. As a chronic disorder with symptoms continuing into adulthood, it is imperative that symptoms be identified and diagnosed so morbidity associated with the disorder is attenuated and these youth have an opportunity for the most successful outcome. Evidence-based guidelines for the assessment and management of ADHD have been delineated by the American Academy of Pediatrics. Implementation of these guidelines specifically includes psychosocial treatments found empirically to improve outcome and to provide the most comprehensive, appropriate care for the patient with ADHD. There is evidence that even when another developmental or behavioral condition coexists with ADHD impairment is decreased with improved health services, specifically access to behavioral health services. The AAP has recently published principles for improving the financial situation for provision of ADHD services. This document highlights the barriers to receiving optimal care, including insufficient insurance benefits coverage, restrictive eligibility standards, and poor reimbursement patterns for providers. Improved care for children with ADHD will be facilitated by changes in payment and coverage policies by health insurance plans and corporate consumers. Principles endorsed by the AAP to ensure that children with ADHD receive appropriate care include the following: (1) open access to appropriate therapy, consultative, and collaborative services; (2) eligibility of primary care clinicians to provide services for children with ADHD and their families; (3) equity in financing care of ADHD; and 4) reinforcing best care for children with ADHD. As the general public is better educated on ADHD, the identification of this disorder increases with resultant increasing expectation of service and a direct impact on health care utilization. Service use trends show a doubling of physician visits for ADHD over the last decade. Studies of health care utilization and costs have revealed that children with ADHD sustain two to three times the per capita total costs than children without ADHD. Children with ADHD and a comorbid mental health disorder increase the cost of treating ADHD by another two-fold. Children with ADHD are treated for mental health disorders up to five times as much as matched controls. The economic burden placed on families of children with ADHD is mostly unrecognized. Resource allocation decisions must consider the cost of not just primary care management of ADHD, but also outpatient mental health costs and pharmacy costs. Employer based health insurance provides most employees in the US with access to health care. Higher-wage workers are more likely than lower-wage workers (< $15 an hour, or $30,000/year) to have comprehensive benefits including preventative care services. The focus is often on the provision of affordable health insurance, but the cost of failing to help workers or their families stay healthy and productive is rarely considered. In addition, the ranks of the uninsured have expanded in recent years due to declining employment-based health coverage. The proportion of the population without insurance is estimated to be at 15.6%, or 45 million people, including 8.4 million children. The associated health outcomes of children with ADHD have increasingly been considered in the literature. Employers need comprehensive understanding of associated disorders and the impact on the family. A diagnosis of ADHD has important consequences to the identified patient as well as family members. Individuals with ADHD have more psychosocial comorbidities, chronic health conditions, and adverse health outcomes. High rates of comorbid Commentary