Is it Possible to Identify Individuals by Neutron Activation Analysis of Hair?; Failure of a Mission

R. Cornelis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/002580247201200307
1972-07-01
Abstract:NEUTRON activation analysis was introduced by G. de Hevesy, in 1936. It was applied for the first time in France for forensic purposes, in 1951, by H. Griffon and J . Barbaud ( i 9 5 1 ) , in a desperate eflfort to bring the unfortunate Marie Besnard case to a satisfactory issue. The two experts were vigorously criticized in court by the defence and Joliot-Curie, who had been called in belatedly, fared no better (Savel, 1963). Marie Besnard was finally acquitted in 1961, after 5 years of preventive imprisonment and 3 successive trials. Neutron activation analysis was brought to remarkable perfection later on by successive researchers and a time even came when American chemists optimistically thought it would provide the solution to a number of delicate investigations (Jervis, 1967). This, unfortunately, turned out seldom to be the case and disenchantment was to follow. Neutron activation analysis is based on the principle that when materials are irradiated in a nuclear reactor or in another neutron source, some of the atoms present are converted into radioactive isotopes. T h e type and energy of the radiation, and the decay
What problem does this paper attempt to address?