Pulsed-field vs. cryoballoon-based pulmonary vein isolation: Lessons from repeat procedures

Marc D Lemoine,Julius Obergassel,Sandro Jaeckle,Moritz Nies,Sophia Taraba,Celine Mencke,Jan Rieß,Ilaria My,Laura Rottner,Fabian Moser,Djemail Ismaili,Bruno Reißmann,Feifan Ouyang,Paulus Kirchhof,Andreas Rillig,Andreas Metzner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/europace/euae221
2024-08-21
Abstract:Background and aims: Pulsed-field ablation (PFA) is an emerging technology to perform pulmonary vein isolation (PVI). Initial data demonstrated high safety and efficacy. Data on long-term PVI durability and reconduction patterns in comparison to established energy sources for PVI are scarce. We compare findings in repeat ablation procedures after a first pulsed-field ablation (PFA) to findings in repeat ablation procedures after a first cryoballoon ablation (CBA) based PVI. Methods: 550 consecutively enrolled patients underwent PFA or CBA index PVI. Repeat ablations in patients with symptomatic atrial arrhythmia recurrences were analyzed. Results: A total of 22/191 (12%) patients after index PFA-PVI and 44/359 (12%) after CBA-PVI underwent repeat ablation. Reconduction of any pulmonary vein (PV) was detected by multipolar spiral mapping catheter at each PV with careful evaluation of PV potentials and by 3D-mapping in 16/22 patients (73%) after PFA-PVI and in 33/44 (75%) after CBA-PVI (p=1.000). Of 82 initially isolated PVs after PFA-PVI, 31 (38%) were reconducting; of 169 isolated PVs after CBA-PVI, 63 (37%) were reconducting (p=0.936). Clinical atrial tachycardia occurred similarly in patients after PFA (5/22; 23%) and CBA (7/44; 16%; p=0.515). Roof lines were set more often after PFA- (8/22; 36%) compared to CBA-PVI (5/44 ; 11%; p=0.023). Repeat procedure duration (PFA: 87 [76,123] min; CBA: 93 [75,128] min; p=0.446) was similar and fluoroscopy time (PFA: 11 [9,14] min; CBA: 11 [8,14] min; p=0.739) equal between groups at repeat ablation. Conclusion: During repeat ablation after previous PFA- or CBA-based PVI, electrical PV-reconduction rates and patterns were similar.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?