Infection prevention and control in 2030: a first qualitative survey by the Crystal Ball Initiative

Hugo Sax,Jonas Marschall,and the Crystal Ball Initiative,Sue Barnes,John M Boyce,Suzanne F Bradley,Dale Fisher,Andrea Grisold,Stephan Harbarth,Anita Huis,Elaine Larson,Andie Lee,Grace Lee,Yves Longtin,Jean-Christophe Lucet,Eli Perencevich,Simone Scheithauer,Julie Storr,Jason-Anthony Tetro,Erich Tschirky,Diana Vilar-Compte

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13756-024-01431-3

2024-08-13

Abstract:Background: Healthcare delivery is undergoing radical changes that influence effective infection prevention and control (IPC). Futures research (short: Futures), the science of deliberating on multiple potential future states, is increasingly employed in many core societal fields. Futures might also be helpful in IPC to facilitate current education and organisational decisions. Hence, we conducted an initial survey as part of the IPC Crystal Ball Initiative. Methods: In 2019, international IPC experts were invited to answer a 10-item online questionnaire, including demographics, housekeeping, and open-ended core questions (Q) on the "status of IPC in 2030" (Q1), "people in charge of IPC" (Q2), "necessary skills in IPC" (Q3), and "burning research questions" (Q4). The four core questions were submitted to a three-step inductive and deductive qualitative content analysis. A subsequent cross-case matrix produced overarching leitmotifs. Q1 statements were additionally coded for sentiment analysis (positive, neutral, or negative). Results: Overall, 18 of 44 (41%) invited experts responded (from 11 countries; 12 physicians, four nurses, one manager, one microbiologist; all of them in senior positions). The emerging leitmotifs were "System integration", "Beyond the hospital", "Behaviour change and implementation", "Automation and digitalisation", and "Anticipated scientific progress and innovation". The statements reflected an optimistic outlook in 66% of all codes of Q1. Conclusions: The first exercise of the IPC Crystal Ball Initiative reflected an optimistic outlook on IPC in 2030, and participants envisioned leveraging technological and medical progress to increase IPC effectiveness, freeing IPC personnel from administrative tasks to be more present at the point of care and increasing IPC integration and expansion through the application of a broad range of skills. Enhancing participant immersion in future Crystal Ball Initiative exercises through simulation would likely further increase the authenticity and comprehensiveness of the envisioned futures.