Abstract:Background: While single cell RNA sequencing becomes a powerful technology, the presence of the large number of zero counts represents a challenge for both wet-lab processing and data analysis. Imputation of these dropouts can now be performed by three categories of algorithms: Model or smoothing, Matrix theory or Deep learning. However, two fundamental questions remain unsettled: (1) whether imputation should be performed; (2) which imputation algorithm to use with various downstream applications. Notably, imputation is not commonly used in real scRNA-seq applications because of their uncertain benefits, concerns about false inferences in downstream applications, and the lack of in-depth benchmark. Methods: Here, we performed two tasks. First, we developed an algorithm using adaptive low-rank full matrix factorization (afMF) based on a previous limited implementation confined to using low rank matrix decomposition (ALRA). Second, to evaluate the impact of various imputation algorithms on downstream analyses, a new benchmark framework incorporating commonly used downstream applications was developed. This benchmark framework put emphasis on real datasets which had ground truth or matched bulk data such that algorithm performance was compared to more convinced data rather than less realistic simulated parameters. Results: Our results indicated that afMF and ALRA (matrix based) provided good imputation and outperformed raw log-normalization in various downstream applications. afMF outperformed ALRA in several evaluations (cell-level differential expression analysis, GSEA, classification, biomarker prediction, clustering, SC-bulk profiling similarity). Besides, afMF ranked among the top levels in automatic cell type annotation, trajectory inference by DPT, and AUCell & SCENIC. Both showed acceptable scalability, while afMF had longer running time. MAGIC (smoothing based) and AutoClass (deep learning based) also performed well but may produce false positives. In contrast, more complicated methods (other deep learning or model based) were prone to overfitting and data distortion. We also found that certain downstream algorithms are not compatible with imputation, including trajectory inference with Slingshot and cell-cell communication. Prior imputation either showed no improvement or generated false positive findings with these downstream applications. Conclusions: We hope this in-depth evaluation and the algorithm developed in this study can enhance the selection of appropriate imputation algorithm for specific scRNA-seq downstream analyses.

scRNMF: An imputation method for single-cell RNA-seq data by robust and non-negative matrix factorization

scNMF-Impute: imputation for single-cell RNA-seq data based on nonnegative matrix factorization.

CMF-Impute: an Accurate Imputation Tool for Single-Cell RNA-seq Data.

scRMD: Imputation for single cell RNA-seq data via robust matrix decomposition

Low-Rank Full Matrix Factorization for dropout imputation in single cell RNA-seq and benchmarking with imputation algorithms for downstream applications

Dimensionality Reduction for Single Cell RNA Sequencing Data Using Constrained Robust Non-Negative Matrix Factorization

Scwmc: Weighted Matrix Completion-Based Imputation of Scrna-Seq Data Via Prior Subspace Information

Scimc: a Platform for Benchmarking Comparison and Visualization Analysis of Scrna-Seq Data Imputation Methods.

scCGImpute: An Imputation Method for Single-Cell RNA Sequencing Data Based on Similarities between Cells and Relationships among Genes

Zero-preserving Imputation of Scrna-Seq Data Using Low-Rank Approximation

Imputing dropouts for single-cell RNA sequencing based on multi-objective optimization

SCC: an accurate imputation method for scRNA-seq dropouts based on a mixture model

BANMF-S: a blockwise accelerated non-negative matrix factorization framework with structural network constraints for single cell imputation

Imputation method for single-cell RNA-seq data using neural topic model

A novel method for single-cell data imputation using subspace regression

A Posterior Probability Based Bayesian Method for Single-Cell RNA-seq Data Imputation.

scCAN: Clustering With Adaptive Neighbor-Based Imputation Method for Single-Cell RNA-Seq Data

MISC: missing imputation for single-cell RNA sequencing data

Cellular Similarity based Imputation for Single cell RNA Sequencing Data

Evaluating Imputation Methods for Single-Cell RNA-seq Data

Missing Value Imputation With Low-Rank Matrix Completion in Single-Cell RNA-Seq Data by Considering Cell Heterogeneity