Clinicopathological discrepancies in the diagnoses of childhood causes of death in the CHAMPS network: An analysis of antemortem diagnostic inaccuracies
Haleluya Leulseged,Christine Bethencourt,Kitiezo Aggrey Igunza,Victor Akelo,Dickens Onyango,Richard Omore,Ikechukwu U Ogbuanu,Soter Ameh,Andrew Moseray,Dickens Kowuor,Ima-Abasi Bassey,Shams El Arifeen,Emily S Gurley,Mohammad Zahid Hossain,Afruna Rahman,Muntasir Alam,Nega Assefa,Lola Madrid,Addisu Alemu,Yasir Y Abdullahi,Karen L Kotloff,Samba O Sow,Milagritos D Tapia,Nana Kourouma,Seydou Sissoko,Quique Bassat,Rosauro Varo,Inacio Mandomando,Carla Carrilho,Natalia Rakislova,Fabiola Fernandes,Shabir Madhi,Ziyaad Dangor,Sana Mahtab,Martin Hale,Vicky Baillie,Jeanie du Toit,Zachary J Madewell,Dianna M Blau,Roosecelis B Martines,Portia C Mutevedzi,Robert F Breiman,Cynthia G Whitney,Chris A Rees,Child Health and Mortality Prevention Surveillance (CHAMPS) network,Fatima Solomon,Gillian Sorour,Hennie Lombaard,Jeannette Wadula,Karen Petersen,Nelesh P Govender,Peter J Swart,Sanjay G Lala,Sithembiso Velaphi,Richard Chawana,Yasmin Adam,Amy Wise,Ashleigh Fritz,Nellie Myburgh,Pedzisai Ndagurwa,Cleopas Hwinya,Sanwarul Bari,Shahana Parveen,Mohammed Kamal,Asm Nawshad Uddin Ahmed,Mahbubul Hoque,Saria Tasnim,Ferdousi Islam,Farida Ariuman,Mohammad Mosiur Rahman,Ferdousi Begum K Zaman,Mustafizur Rahman,Dilruba Ahmed,Meerjady Sabrina Flora,Tahmina Shirin,Mahbubur Rahman,Joseph Oundo,Alexander M Ibrahim,Fikremelekot Temesgen,Tadesse Gure,Melisachew Mulatu Yeshi,Mahlet Abayneh Gizaw,Stian Ms Orlien,Solomon Ali,Peter Otieno,Peter Nyamthimba Onyango,Janet Agaya,Richard Oliech,Joyce Akinyi Were,Dickson Gethi,Sammy Khagayi,George Aol,Thomas Misore,Harun Owuor,Christopher Muga,Bernard Oluoch,Christine Ochola,Sharon M Tennant,Carol L Greene,Ashka Mehta,J Kristie Johnson,Brigitte Gaume,Adama Mamby Keita,Rima Koka,Karen D Fairchild,Diakaridia Kone,Diakaridia Sidibe,Doh Sanogo,Uma U Onwuchekwa,Cheick Bougadari Traore,Jane Juma,Kounandji Diarra,Awa Traore,Tiéman Diarra,Kiranpreet Chawla,Tacilta Nhampossa,Zara Manhique,Sibone Mocumbi,Clara Menéndez,Khátia Munguambe,Ariel Nhacolo,Maria Maixenchs,Fatmata Bintu Tarawally,Martin Seppeh,Ronald Mash,Julius Ojulong,Babatunde Duduyemi,James Bunn,Alim Swaray-Deen,Joseph Bangura Amara Jambai,Margaret Mannah,Okokon Ita,Cornell Chukwuegbo,Sulaiman Sannoh,Princewill Nwajiobi,Erick Kaluma,Oluseyi Balogun,Carrie Jo Cain,Solomon Samura,Samuel Pratt,Francis Moses,Tom Sesay,James Squire,Joseph Kamanda Sesay,Osman Kaykay,Binyam Halu,Hailemariam Legesse,Francis Smart,Sartie Kenneh,Jana Ritter,Tais Wilson,Jonas Winchell,Jakob Witherbee,Navit T Salzberg,Jeffrey P Koplan,Margaret Basket,Ashutosh Wadhwa,Kyu Han Lee,Roosecelis Martines,Shamta Warang,Maureen Diaz,Jessica Waller,Shailesh Nair,Lucy Liu,Courtney Bursuc,Kristin LaHatte,Sarah Raymer,John Blevins,Solveig Argeseanu,Kurt Vyas,Manu Bhandari
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjpo-2024-002654
2024-07-20
Abstract:Introduction: Determining aetiology of severe illness can be difficult, especially in settings with limited diagnostic resources, yet critical for providing life-saving care. Our objective was to describe the accuracy of antemortem clinical diagnoses in young children in high-mortality settings, compared with results of specific postmortem diagnoses obtained from Child Health and Mortality Prevention Surveillance (CHAMPS). Methods: We analysed data collected during 2016-2022 from seven sites in Africa and South Asia. We compared antemortem clinical diagnoses from clinical records to a reference standard of postmortem diagnoses determined by expert panels at each site who reviewed the results of histopathological and microbiological testing of tissue, blood, and cerebrospinal fluid. We calculated test characteristics and 95% CIs of antemortem clinical diagnostic accuracy for the 10 most common causes of death. We classified diagnostic discrepancies as major and minor, per Goldman criteria later modified by Battle. Results: CHAMPS enrolled 1454 deceased young children aged 1-59 months during the study period; 881 had available clinical records and were analysed. The median age at death was 11 months (IQR 4-21 months) and 47.3% (n=417) were female. We identified a clinicopathological discrepancy in 39.5% (n=348) of deaths; 82.3% of diagnostic errors were major. The sensitivity of clinician antemortem diagnosis ranged from 26% (95% CI 14.6% to 40.3%) for non-infectious respiratory diseases (eg, aspiration pneumonia, interstitial lung disease, etc) to 82.2% (95% CI 72.7% to 89.5%) for diarrhoeal diseases. Antemortem clinical diagnostic specificity ranged from 75.2% (95% CI 72.1% to 78.2%) for diarrhoeal diseases to 99.0% (95% CI 98.1% to 99.6%) for HIV. Conclusions: Antemortem clinical diagnostic errors were common for young children who died in areas with high childhood mortality rates. To further reduce childhood mortality in resource-limited settings, there is an urgent need to improve antemortem diagnostic capability through advances in the availability of diagnostic testing and clinical skills.