RURAL HEALTH IN PUNJAB – NEEDS REFORMS AND INVESTMENTS – DR
S. Singh
Abstract:S OF SIKH STUDIES: JULY-SEPT 2010 / 542 NS 38 better health levels compared to the people living in Southern states like Kerala and Tamil Nadu where one could see much better education and health related indicators than that of Punjab (Brar, 2002). Since the mid-1980s in Punjab, the under-currents of political turmoil, severe state resource crunch and nonresponsive administration in the state on one hand, and the adoption of new economic policy (NEP) of 1991 that insist upon the integration of nation’s economy into world economy (through the forces of l iberal ization, privatization and globalization) on the other hand forced the state to allocate meager public funds to the social sectors, especially to the public health sector. This has brought out a faster deterioration in the public health infrastructure and services, particularly in rural Punjab. The paper makes modest attempt to examine the rural health scenario in Punjab as well as builds a case for radical policy reforms. The paper has been divided into six Parts. Part I analyzes, in brief, the theoretical implications of global forces on the health sector of state. Part II presents the progress in health indicators and emerging health scenario in the state. Part III, examines the growth and pattern of public expenditure on health services in Punjab. Part IV deals with the main features health care infrastructure developed so far in the state. Non-functional and dismal performance of rural health services has been presented in Part V. The summary of main conclusions and emerging issues are set forth in Part VI. GLOBAL FORCES AND HEALTH SECTOR THEORETICAL UNDERSTANDING Global forces are influencing India’s health sector in many ways (Misra, et al., 2003) In its true essence, global forces mean the growing process of economic interdependence of nation-states through the increasing volume and variety of cross-border transactions of goods/services, free movement of capital, people, ideas and knowledge, and more importantly, diffusion of new technology at an astonished speed (Gill, Singh and Brar, 2010). It means that process of globalization has economic, political, 39 RURAL HEALTH IN PUNJAB – NEEDS REFORMS AND INVESTMENTS technological, and cultural dimensions that are interwoven with each other and affecting the main activities of nation-states. But defining the globalization as mere ‘openness of economy’ does not convey and capture the multiple, often contradictory, contours of real forces/mechanism that are at work among the nation-states. This process of integrating a nation’s economy to world economy, indeed, affects the people’s health and health delivery system positively/negatively and directly/indirectly. Its positive impacts may be observed in the range of better health outcomes (more incomes, better living conditions, better access to health technology/medicine, better prevent/control over diseases, high life expectancy, etc.). And, its highly deleterious impacts on human health are high treatment costs, elite oriented policies, high incidence of man-made diseases, ir rational use of drugs/ technology, etc. The global forces directly influence a nation’s health mainly through: (i) enhanced movement of pharmaceutical products, health personnel and patients across the national boundaries; (ii) elite oriented health consumerism and medical tourism via the internet and other means; and (iii) establishment of big corporate hospitals having Five Star facilities. On the other hand, more mobility of people increases more chances of spreading/contracting diseases across the borders. Further, globalization, if accompanied by low public funds to health sector, plays havoc with health of the poor in developing countries (Baum, 2001). On the other side, in an indirect way, global forces affect the people’ health in most of developing countries through the heightened industrial activities, depletion of natural resources, indiscriminate use of insecticides/pesticides, increasing environmental pollution (Air and water pollution), unsafe/untreated disposal of industrial waste, etc. Moreover, high consumption of tobacco/alcoholic products, rising consumption of packed/frozen foods and aerated beverages have also affecting the people’s health negatively. The emergence of high risk diseases like diabetes, cancer, heart disease, and other life style diseases (TB, HIV/AIDS, ABSTRACTS OF SIKH STUDIES: JULY-SEPT 2010 / 542 NS 40S OF SIKH STUDIES: JULY-SEPT 2010 / 542 NS 40 etc.) can be linked to the global economic policies. Moreover, for the resource poor people, falling prey to high risk chronic and life style diseases means less employment, subsequently more poverty and malnourishment of women/children in the family which is also attributed to global forces by some authors (Cornia, 2001 and Chatterjee, 2007). In India, during the early 1990s, with the formal acceptance of structural adjustment programme (SAP), integration of Indian economy to global economy became a reality. In fact, the imposition of SAP has considerably reduced state investment in the social sectors including health sector in India. In public health fields, the role of the state has increasingly been marginalized. Further, health sector reforms piloted by the World Bank in India are actively promoting private sector initiatives, giving more emphasis to non government bodies, contracting out, and suggesting other forms of organization (Public-Private Partnership) in health management. In nutshell, main aspects of IMF-World Bank inspired health reforms in India are: cuts in public health sector investments, opening up of health care to the private sector, levying of users’ charges, contracting out some services of public hospitals and relying upon purely techno-centric public health interventions (Qadeer, 2000). And, due to cutbacks in public health sector funds, primary health care services suffered a major setback in India. For want of more funds, infectious diseases control programmes were disrupted, FW programme began to focus on reproductive health of married women only, children’ health and their nutritional needs were ignored. By handing over the health care to private sector players, without any regulatory mechanism to ensure the quality and standards of treatment, state is withdrawing itself from the constitutional obligations and seriously affecting the equal access of health services to the marginalized section of society (Baru, 1998). All these forces are found to be working more vigorously in the state of Punjab (Gill, Singh and Brar, 2010). II 41 RURAL HEALTH IN PUNJAB – NEEDS REFORMS AND INVESTMENTS The economic theory states that high per capita income often leads to improvements in living standards and health status of people. Rising per capita income in Punjab has a favorable impact on life expectancy at birth for males and females. For instance, life expectancy of males during 2001-06 was 69.8 years, whereas it was 68.4 years during 1996-2001. Similarly, the life expectancy of females was 72.0 years during 2001-06 compared to 71.4 years during 1996-2001 (Table 1). Although the rural areas in Punjab had performed very well in bringing down the birth rate to 18.8 per thousand people and the death rate to 7.4 per thousand people in 2006, yet both these rates can further be improved (Singh, 2005). However, infant mortality rate in rural Punjab is still high (48 per thousand live births). And, total fertility rate (TFR) and maternal mortality rate (MMR) estimated to be very high (2.98 children per woman and. 178 per lakh live births. Besides these, there exists a big gap in proportion of other public facilities such as accessibility of safe drinking water (piped water) and sanitation (toilet facilities, connectivity to drainage, etc) in rural Punjab. About one-fourth of Punjab’s villages (24.04 percent) did not enjoy any drinking water supply scheme. These facilities, in fact, greatly influence the health status/quality of life of people (IIPS, 2001). It clearly shows that, rural people still deprived of basic health related facilities, despite achieving high economic growth in the past. Further, the data on incidence of morbidity in rural Punjab showed that, on the whole, 127 persons per 1000 population were suffering from one or other types of illness during the first half of 2004. Incidence of morbidity was much higher in rural areas (136 persons per 1000 population) compared to that of in urban areas (107 persons per 1000 population). Further, morbidity incidence was significantly higher among females both in rural and urban areas (Table 2). It was very much higher when compared to all India average incidence of morbidity. In fact, Punjab became second highest morbidity state after the Kerala in the country (NSSO, 2006). An analysis of estimated number of persons reporting ailment/s in Punjab over two and half decades (1973-74, 1995-96 ABSTRACTS OF SIKH STUDIES: JULY-SEPT 2010 / 542 NS 42S OF SIKH STUDIES: JULY-SEPT 2010 / 542 NS 42 and 2004) revealed that number of ailing persons in the state grew at the rate 3.8 per annum during 1973-74 to 1995-96. Between 1995-96 and 2004, growth in number of ailing persons rose to 7.1 per cent. The pace of growing morbidity was much higher in rural Punjab, especially during the latter period of 1995-96 to 2004 (8.1 per cent per annum) compared to the earlier period of 197374 to 1995-96 (3.0 per cent per annum). However, in urban Punjab, growth rate in the morbidity was 6.2 per cent per annum between 1973-74 and 1995-96 compared to the growth rate of 4.8 per cent per annum between 1995-96 and 2004. At all-India level, morbidity was also grown during the latter time period (1995-96 to 2004) compared to the previous time period. The data on morbidity by type of diseases/ailments (grouped into 21 categories) state that the respiratory/ENT diseases, fevers of unknown origin, cardiovascular diseases, gastro-intestinal diseases, disorders of joints a