Abstract:Background: One third of adult women report lifetime psychological intimate partner violence (IPV). Controlling behavior is a common dimension of psychological IPV; however, evidence is mixed on its cross-national and cross-time measurement invariance, limiting its use to monitor Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 5.2.1, to eliminate all forms of violence against women. We explored easier-to-modify survey-design features and harder-to-modify individual-level and national-level characteristics that may account for non-invariance of these controlling-behavior items. Methods: We analyzed data on five controlling behaviors administered to 373,167 ever-partnered women 15-49 years in 19 low- or middle-income countries in which at least two national Demographic and Health Surveys were administered during 2005-2019. We performed multiple-group confirmatory factor analysis (MGCFA) to test for exact forms of invariance and alignment optimization (AO) to test for approximate invariance across 7-9 survey-design groups, defined by the number of preceding questionnaire modules (to proxy respondent burden) and weeks of interviewer training (to proxy interviewer skills). Adjustment for covariates in the MGCFA assessed whether individual- and national-level characteristics could account for any observed non-invariance across survey-design groups. Results: In MGCFA without covariates, configural invariance of the controlling-behavior items was observed across survey-design groups. Exact invariance, partial invariance (with 20% of parameter estimates freed), and approximate invariance were not observed across groups. In adjusted MGCFA, neither woman-level covariates (schooling, attitudes about IPV against women) nor national-level covariates (women's mean schooling, mean attitudes about IPV against women, gender-related legal environment) alone or combined accounted for the non-invariance of controlling-behavior items across survey-design groups. Conclusions: Comparing estimates for controlling behavior across country, time, and survey design variations warrants caution. Standardizing questionnaire length and interviewer training may improve the invariance of these items. Other characteristics, like ethnicity and language, may account for the non-invariance of controlling-behavior items across survey-design groups and should be tested. Current controlling-behavior items should be refined to enhance their comparability, and new controlling-behavior items should be identified and tested to improve the item set's content validity. Given current evidence of the high prevalence and health impacts of psychological IPV against women, advancing this research agenda is needed to monitor SDG 5.2.1.

From the U.S. to Denmark and Beyond: It's Time to Reimagine the Use of Control Variables in Observational Research

Mastering the Use of Control Variables: the Hierarchical Iterative Control (HIC) Approach

Control Variables in Leadership Research: A Qualitative and Quantitative Review

Social psychological research on gender, sexuality, and relationships: reflections on contemporary scientific and cultural challenges

Are "Global Measures" of Psychological Intimate Partner Violence Against Women Really Comparable? A Measurement Invariance Analysis of Controlling Behaviors in 19 Low- and Middle- Income Countries

Sex contextualism in laboratory research: Enhancing rigor and precision in the study of sex-related variables

Impersonal Sex and Pornography: Potential Confounding, Moderation, and Implications for Public Health

Standardization and Control for Confounding in Observational Studies: A Historical Perspective

How EIRD Is Sex Research?: A Commentary and Reanalysis of Klein et al. (2021)

U.S. Males and Pornography: Replication and Experimental Extension

Misstatements, misperceptions, and mistakes in controlling for covariates in observational research

A Methodological Review of Exploratory Factor Analysis in Sexuality Research: Used Practices, Best Practices, and Data Analysis Resources

Discussion of Papers by Frank, and Robbins & Wallerstein.

“Rarely safe to assume”: Evaluating the use and interpretation of manipulation checks in experimental social psychology

Contextualizing Sexual Objectification

Sexual Interaction in Digital Contexts and Its Implications for Sexual Health: A Conceptual Analysis

Public attitudes towards social media field experiments

The Future of Sex and Gender in Psychology: Five Challenges to the Gender Binary

Using Sociolinguistic Variables to Reveal Changing Attitudes Towards Sexuality and Gender

Preliminary Insights from a U.S. Probability Sample on Adolescents’ Pornography Exposure, Media Psychology, and Sexual Aggression

Adolescent Pornography Exposure, Condom Use, and the Moderating Role of Parental Sexual Health Communication: Replication in a U.S. Probability Sample