Abstract:In Lake Erie, a wide variety of statistical and process-based models have significantly advanced our understanding of the major causal linkages/ecosystem processes underlying the local water quality problems. In this study, our aim is to identify knowledge gaps, monitoring assessment objectives, and management recommendations that should be critically reviewed through the iterative monitoring-modelling-assessment cycles of adaptive management. In the watershed, the presence of multiple SWAT applications provides assurance that a wide array of physical, chemical, and biological processes with distinct characterizations are used to reproduce the patterns of flow and nutrient export in agricultural lands. While there are models with more advanced mechanistic representation of certain facets of the hydrological cycle (surface runoff, groundwater and sediment erosion) or better equipped to depict urban settings, we believe that greater insights will be gained by revisiting several influential assumptions (tile drainage, fertilizer/manure application rates, land-use/landcover data) and recalibrating the existing SWAT models to capture both baseline and event-flow conditions and daily nutrient concentration (not loading) variability in multiple locations rather than a single downstream site. It is also critical to redesign land-use management scenarios by accommodating recent conceptual and technical advancements of their life-cycle effectiveness, the variability in their starting operational efficiency, and differential response to storm events or seasonality, as well as the role of legacy phosphorus. In the receiving waterbody, the development of data-driven models to establish causal linkages between the trophic status of Lake Erie and external phosphorus loading represents a pragmatic means to draw forecasts regarding the phytoplankton community response to different management actions. Two critical next steps to further augment the empirical modelling work is the iterative updating as more data are acquired through monitoring and the introduction of additional explanatory variables that are likely associated with the occurrence of cyanobacteria-dominated blooms. The majority of the process-based models are not constrained by the available data, and therefore their primary value is their use as heuristic tools to advance our understanding of Lake Erie. The validation of their predictive power should become one of the overarching objectives of the iterative monitoring-modelling-assessment cycles. With respect to the projected responses of the system to nutrient loading reduction, we express our skepticism with the optimistic predictions of the extent and duration of hypoxia, given our limited knowledge of the sediment diagenesis processes in the central basin along with the lack of data related to the vertical profiles of organic matter and phosphorus fractionation or sedimentation/burial rates. Our study also questions the adequacy of the coarse spatiotemporal (seasonal/annual, basin- or lake-wide) scales characterizing the philosophy of both water quality management objectives and modelling enterprise in Lake Erie, as this strategy seems somewhat disconnected from the ecosystem services targeted. We conclude by emphasizing that the valuation of ecosystem services should be integrated into the decision-making process, as we track the evolution of the system over time.

Development of a generalized pseudo-probabilistic approach for characterizing ecological conditions in estuaries using secondary data

Statistical models of fecal coliform levels in Pacific Northwest estuaries for improved shellfish harvest area closure decision making

Evaluating the performance of Bayesian geostatistical prediction with physical barriers in the Chesapeake Bay

Improving Parameter Estimation with an Efficient Sequential Probabilistic Collocation-Based Optimal Design Method

Enterococci predictions from partial least squares regression models in conjunction with a single-sample standard improve the efficacy of beach management advisories.

A probabilistic approach to chronic effects assessments for listed species in a vernal pool case study

Probabilistic co-occurrence assessment for suites of listed species

Environmental DNA Methods for Ecological Monitoring and Biodiversity Assessment in Estuaries

A hydrodynamic model–based approach to assess sampling approaches for dissolved oxygen criteria in the Chesapeake Bay

Reducing Bias and Filling in Spatial Gaps in Fishery-Dependent Catch-per-Unit-Effort Data by Geostatistical Prediction, II. Application to a Scallop Fishery

Castles Built on Sand or Predictive Limnology in Action? Part B: Designing the Next Monitoring-Modelling-assessment Cycle of Adaptive Management in Lake Erie

Monitoring through many eyes: Integrating disparate datasets to improve monitoring of the Great Barrier Reef

Participatory science methods to monitor water quality and ground truth remote sensing of the Chesapeake Bay

SSNdesign -- an R package for pseudo-Bayesian optimal and adaptive sampling designs on stream networks

An evaluation of the error and uncertainty in epibenthos cover estimates from AUV images collected with an efficient, spatially-balanced design

Proving a negative; estimating species ′Confidence in Absence for Decision-Making′ (CIADM) using environmental DNA monitoring

Balancing observational data and experiential knowledge in environmental flows modeling

Ecological forensic testing: Using multiple primers for eDNA detection of marine vertebrates in an estuarine lagoon subject to anthropogenic influences

Castles Built on Sand or Predictive Limnology in Action? Part A: Evaluation of an Integrated Modelling Framework to Guide Adaptive Management Implementation in Lake Erie.

Hindcasting estuary ecological states using sediment cores, modelled historic nutrient loads, and a Bayesian network

Using resiliency, redundancy, and representation in a Bayesian belief network to assess imperilment of riverine fishes