Teaching in casualty.

D. H. Wilson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.285.6351.1355-f

1982-11-06

British Medical Journal

Abstract:however, because the principal treatment method used with alcoholics is group therapy. A further major difficulty (perhaps to a degree unique among alcoholics and drug addicts) is a low degree of motivation and, more important, an unwillingness to co-operate, certainly over a long period of treatment. This is well shown in Dr Gareth Lloyd's article (18 September, p 785). Many patients frankly tell us at a later date that while they were attending treatment and going through the motions they had no intentions of stopping drinking, nor did they accept that they were alcoholic. More important, they soon made it clear by their non-attendance that they would not co-operate with treatment. It is as if hypertensive patients did not accept that they were hypertensive and refused to take their drugs or attend follow-up clinics. In these circumstances it is not likely that the antihypertensive drugs or hypertension clinic would be regarded as of no value. In order to show that treatment is ineffective in the severely dependent alcoholic, which is the type of patient who attends hospital, it will be necessary to show at least that there is no change occurring in drinking behaviour in patients who have shown quantifiably that they have undergone regular persistent treatment over a period of at least several years. This quantifiable assessment would have to be shown in a direct measurement of clinic attendances, etc. B D HORE