Abstract:Background: Mandibular second premolar agenesis is a common problem in orthodontics and is often treated in conjunction with maxillary counterbalancing extractions. However, in cases without maxillary crowding or dental protrusion, space closure may pose challenges leading to compromised occlusal results or patient profile. Multiple techniques have been described to treat these patients; nevertheless, there is a paucity of data comparing effectiveness of space closure utilizing various anchorage techniques. The goal of this study is to assess the effectiveness of the Herbst device during mandibular molar protraction and compare it to the use of temporary anchorage device (TADs) in patients with mandibular second premolar agenesis. Materials and methods: This retrospective study included 33 patients with mandibular premolar agenesis treated without maxillary extractions. Of these patients, 21 were treated with protraction Herbst devices and 12 with TADs. Changes in molar and incisor positions, skeletal base positions and occlusal plane angulations were assessed on pretreatment (T0) and post-treatment (T1) lateral cephalograms. Scans/photographs at T0 and T1 were used to evaluate canine relationship changes representing anchorage control. Space closure and breakage/failure rates were also compared. Data was analyzed with paired and unpaired t-tests at the significance level of 0.05. Results: Within the Herbst group, changes in mandibular central incisor uprighting and mandibular molar crown angulations were statistically significant. However, no significant differences were noted between the Herbst and TAD groups. Protraction rates as well as overall treatment times were comparable (0.77 mm/month vs. 0.55 mm/month and 3.02 years vs. 2.67 years, respectively). Canine relationships were maintained or improved toward a class I in 82.85% of the Herbst sample, compared to in 66.7% of the TAD sample. Emergency visits occurred in 80.1% of the Herbst group, with cementation failures or appliance breakages as the most common reasons. Conclusion: The Herbst device could be a viable modality in cases with missing mandibular premolars where maximum anterior anchorage is desired, or if patients/parents are resistant to TADs. Furthermore, they could be beneficial in skeletal class II patients with mandibular deficiency who also need molar protraction. However, the increased incidence of emergency visits must be considered when treatment is planned.

Control of anterior anchorage with miniscrews and sliding mechanics in an adolescent with missing second premolars: A clinical report with biomechanical validation

Effects of Removable Functional Appliances on the Dentoalveolar Unit in Growing Patients

Torque control with set-up and auxiliary spring in an adult severe class II case treated by lingual straight-wire appliance, premolar extractions and orthognathic surgery

Long distance bilateral premolar and molar mesialization by temporary anchorage device: a case report of congenitally missing maxillary canines

Biomechanical Multipurpose Miniscrew Strategy for Simultaneous Distalization in Class II Patients-The BiGa System

Simplifying the approach of open bite treatment with aligners and selective micro-osteoperforations: An adult case report

Three-dimensional analysis of miniscrew position changes during bone-borne expansion in young and late adolescent patients

Evaluating the efficiency of mandibular molar protraction using Herbst appliances versus temporary anchorage devices: a retrospective case-controlled study

A 3D finite element analysis of biomechanical effects on teeth and bone during true intrusion of anteriors using miniscrews

Finite element analysis of the stress state produced by an orthodontic skeletal anchorage system based on miniscrews

Three-Dimensional Evaluation of Treatment Effects and Post-Treatment Stability of Maxillary Molar Intrusion Using Temporary Anchorage Devices in Open Bite Malocclusion

Microscrew anchorage in skeletal anterior open-bite treatment.

Orthodontic treatment of Class II malocclusion with miniscrew implants

Treatment of Anterior Open Bite Using Miniscrew Anchorage

Lower Jaw Full-Arch Restoration: A Completely Digital Approach to Immediate Load

Three-dimensional finite element analysis of upper anterior teeth retraction and intrusion using clear aligners and mini-implants

Asymmetric Molar Distalization with Miniscrews to Correct A Severe Unilateral Class Iii Malocclusion

Early Diagnosis and Treatment of Mandibular Second Premolar Impaction: A Case Report

Agenesis of the maxillary permanent lateral incisors with the deciduous retained: Conservative and biomimetic approach using the BAIR technique

The Biomechanics of Clear Aligners associated with temporary skeletal anchorage devices (TSAD)

Nonsurgical treatment of an adult patient with severe transversal skeletal discrepancy: Tooth bone-borne tandem expander and hybrid aligner approach