Abstract:Background, Aim, and Scope Lead (Pb) contamination at shooting range sites is increasingly under environmental concern. Controlling Pb leachability from shooting range soil media is an important step to minimize Pb exposure to the surrounding environment. This study investigated stabilization of Pb in shooting range soils treated with cement, quicklime, and phosphate. Materials and Methods Two soils were used and collected from two shooting ranges, referred to as SR1 and SR2. The treatment additives were applied to the soils at rates from 2.5% to 10% (w/w). The effectiveness of each treatment was evaluated by Pb leachability, measured by the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP). The possible mechanisms for Pb immobilization were elucidated using X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD). Results Cement and quicklime treatments were effective in immobilizing Pb in SR1 soil, with reduction of Pb concentration in TCLP leachate (TCLP-Pb) to be below the U.S. EPA non-hazardous regulatory limit of 5 mg L −1 at application rates of ≥5% and 28-d incubation. By contrast, cement and quicklime amendments were less effective for Pb stabilization in SR2 soil because the TCLP-Pb levels in the treated soil were still higher than the limit of 5 mg L −1 at all application rates, although they were significantly reduced in comparison with the untreated soil. Phosphate application was most effective in reducing Pb leaching in both soils. Even at an application rate as low as 5% and 1-d incubation, phosphate could reduce TCLP-Pb to be below the limit of 5 mg L −1 in both soils. Discussion Immobilization of Pb in the SR1 soil amended with cement and quicklime was attributed to the formation of pozzolanic minerals (e.g., calcium silicate hydrate C-S-H and ettringite) that could encapsulate soil Pb. The pozzolanic reaction was limited in the SR2 soil upon the application of cement and quicklime. Reduction of the TCLP-Pb might result from complexation of Pb on the surface of the formed calcite. Phosphate-induced Pb immobilization was mainly attributed to formation of less soluble PbHPO 4 . Conclusions The results indicate that effectiveness of cementitious treatments (cement and quicklime) in immobilizing Pb varies in two soils, being effective in SR1 soil but less in SR2 soil. For one given soil, no difference was observed of the effectiveness between cement and quicklime treatments, whereas phosphate amendment emerges as a most effective treatment means for stabilizing Pb in both two soils, and it also shows a faster immobilization process and little effect on the soil acid buffering capacity. Recommendations and Perspectives Overall, our study reveals that immobilizing Pb can be one of the best management practices for Pb contamination at shooting range sites. Phosphate amendment is most effective in immobilizing Pb in any kind of the soil ranges to minimize negative Pb impacts on the shooting range sites.

Lead stabilization and remediation strategy with soil amendment in situ immobilization in contaminated range lands

Green remediation of high-lead contaminated soil by stabilization/solidification with insoluble humin: Long-term leaching and mechanical characteristics

Immobilization of Soil Pb by Different Amendments

Field Demonstration of On-Site Immobilization of Arsenic and Lead in Soil Using a Ternary Amending Agent

Utilization of Phosphorus Loaded Alkaline Residue to Immobilize Lead in a Shooting Range Soil.

Field Assessment of Lead Immobilization in A Contaminated Soil after Phosphate Application

Immobilization of lead in shooting range soils by means of cement, quicklime, and phosphate amendments

Immobilization of Lead and Cadmium in Contaminated Soil Using Amendments: A Review

An Integrated Approach for Simultaneous Immobilization of Lead in Both Contaminated Soil and Groundwater: Laboratory Test and Numerical Modeling.

Immobilization of Zn, Cu, and Pb in Contaminated Soils Using Phosphate Rock and Phosphoric Acid.

A 3-year field study on lead immobilisation in paddy soil by a novel active silicate amendment

Remediation of Heavy Metal (Cu, Pb) Contaminated Fine Soil Using Stabilization with Limestone and Livestock Bone Powder

Application Methods Affect Phosphorus-Induced Lead Immobilization from a Contaminated Soil.

Immobilization of Lead in Anthropogenic Contaminated Soils Using Phosphates With/Without Oxalic Acid

Stabilization of arsenic, antimony, and lead in contaminated soil with montmorillonite modified by ferrihydrite: Efficiency and mechanism

Immobilization of Pb,Cu,Zn in a Multi-metal Contaminated Soil with Phosphorus Bearing Materials

Phosphate-Induced Lead Immobilization from Different Lead Minerals in Soils under Varying Ph Conditions

Assessment of In Situ Immobilization of Lead (Pb) and Arsenic (As) in Contaminated Soils with Phosphate and Iron: Solubility and Bioaccessibility

In-situ remediation of Pb-contaminated soil from the battery factory by immobilization technology

Exploratory of immobilization remediation of hydroxyapatite (HAP) on lead-contaminated soils

Immobilization and Its Mechanisms of Heavy Metal Contaminated Soils by Phosphate-containing Amendment and Biochar