Hospital variation in quality indicators for patient blood management in total knee and hip arthroplasty: a retrospective cohort study

Albert Garcia-Casanovas,Elvira Bisbe,Anna Garcia-Altes,Adria Vizoso,Xavier Duran-Jorda,Guillermo Sanchez-Pedrosa,Marta Barquero,Maria J Colomina,Misericordia Basora,MAPBM Working Group,Alicia Aranguren Azparren,Ana Abad Gosálbez,Ana Faura,Ana Morales de la Plaza,Ana Ruiz Puig,Angel Caballero,Ángel Lavado,Cadena Serramitja Montserrat,Carlos Jericó,Carmen Elena Sanabria,Cristina Martinez Escribano,Dra Violeta Turcu Paraschiv,Estefania Cerezo,Esther Méndez,Esther Sancho Ponce,Esther Vila Ribas,Eva Bassas Parga,Francisco José Jimeno Demuth,Gemma Moreno-Jimenez,Gerardo Gómez Montero,Gonzalo Azparren Cabezón,Ignacio de la Fuente Graciani,Inocencia Fornet Ruiz,Isabel Castrillo Martínez,J Enrique Ortega Lucas,Javier Gorricho,Javier Mata Estévez,Jordi Colomina Morales,José Antonio García-Erce,José Luis Campuzano Garcia,Jose Luis Gonzalez-Rodriguez,Jose M García-Gala,José Manuel Vagace,Laura Francisca Ávila Idrovo,Laura Martínez Almirante,Luz María Gonzalez Del Castillo,M Aranzazu Pisano Blanco,M Isabel Campos Peláez,M Pilar Herranz Andrés,Manel Romero Conejo,Maria Pilar Ruiz Dãíaz,Maria Raquel Díaz Comino,Marina Canales Navarro,Marta Albacar-Ingla,Miguel Rey Mesa,Montserrat Torra Riera,N Ibarra,Natalia Gallench Pons,Nuria Ruiz López,Pablo González Navarro,Pamela Millacoy Austenrritt,Patricia Marzal Sorolla,Pilar Arribas Perez,Pilar Solves,Raquel Tolós París,Reis Drudis Morell,René Robles-Cedeño,Rosa I Upegui Villegas,Sonsoles Aragón Alvarez,Teresa Planella,Virginia Dueñas,Yolanda Cabanillas Nuñez,Yolanda Palacios Gómez
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2024.05.019
Abstract:Background: Anaemia, blood loss, and blood transfusion are critical aspects of patient care in major orthopaedic surgery. We assessed hospital adherence to guideline-recommended Patient Blood Management (PBM) care, analysed variations between hospitals, and validated two composite indicators of hospital PBM performance in patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA) or total hip arthroplasty (THA). Methods: This retrospective cohort study included all primary TKA and THA procedures performed during 2021 across 39 hospitals in Spain. We assessed hospital adherence to key guideline-recommended PBM interventions using nine individual quality indicators and two types of composite quality indicators (cQIs): opportunity-based (cQI1) and all-or-none (cQI2). We validated these cQIs by analysing their associations with the adjusted total transfusion index using linear regression. Results: We included 8561 patient episodes from 33 hospitals in the analysis. Delivery of PBM care was similar for TKA and THA. Patients received 62% of the analysed PBM interventions and only 12% of patients underwent the full PBM pathway. Higher hospital cQIs scores were associated with a lower adjusted total transfusion index, both in TKA and THA. The greatest association was found for cQI1 in THA patients (β=-1.18 [95% confidence interval -2.00 to -0.36]; P=0.007). Conclusions: Hospital adherence to guideline-recommended patient blood management care in total hip and knee arthroplasty was suboptimal and varied across centres. Using data that are widely available in hospitals, quality indicators and composite scores could become valuable tools for patient blood management monitoring and comparisons between healthcare organisations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?