Comparison of Patient Health Questionnaire-9, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and Hospital Anxiety and Depression - Depression subscale scores by administration mode: An individual participant data differential item functioning meta-analysis

Daphna Harel,Yin Wu,Brooke Levis,Suiqiong Fan,Ying Sun,Mingyao Xu,Danielle B Rice,Jill Boruff,Sarah Markham,John P A Ioannidis,Yemisi Takwoingi,Scott B Patten,Roy C Ziegelstein,Pim Cuijpers,Simon Gilbody,Simone Vigod,Dickens Akena,Andrea Benedetti,Brett D Thombs,DEPRESsion Screening Data (DEPRESSD) Collaboration,Marleine Azar,Parash Mani Bhandari,Matthew J Chiovitti,Chen He,Mahrukh Imran,Ankur Krishnan,Zelalem Negeri,Dipika Neupane,Kira E Riehm,Xin Wei Yan,Lorie A Kloda,Melissa Henry,Zahinoor Ismail,Carmen G Loiselle,Nicholas D Mitchell,Samir Al-Adawi,Rubén Alvarado,Dagmar Amtmann,Bruce Arroll,Liat Ayalon,Hamid R Baradaran,Jacqueline Barnes,Kevin R Beck,Cheryl Tatano Beck,Charles N Bernstein,Carola Bindt,Charles H Bombardier,Birgitte Boye,Natalie Büel-Drabe,Ryna Imma Buji,Adomas Bunevicius,Peter Butterworth,Ceyhun Can,Gregory Carter,Marcos H Chagas,Juliana C N Chan,Lai Fong Chan,Chih-Ken Chen,Dixon Chibanda,Genesis Chorwe-Sungani,Kerrie Clover,Ronán M Conroy,Aaron Conway,Yeates Conwell,Humberto Correa,Thiago Castro E Couto,Daniel Cukor,Federico M Daray,Janneke M de Man-van Ginkel,Jennifer De Souza,Marina G Downing,Valsamma Eapen,Jesse R Fann,Nicolas Favez,Ethel Felice,Gracia Fellmeth,Panagiotis P Ferentinos,Michelle Fernandes,Sally Field,Barbara Figueiredo,Felix H Fischer,Jane R W Fisher,Alastair J Flint,Maiko Fujimori,Daniel S S Fung,Pamela Gallagher,Milena Gandy,Bizu Gelaye,Leila Gholizadeh,Lorna J Gibson,Felicity Goodyear-Smith,Luigi Grassi,Eric P Green,Catherine G Greeno,Brian J Hall,Liisa Hantsoo,Emily E Haroz,Martin Härter,Ulrich Hegerl,Nadine Helle,Asuncion Hernando,Leanne Hides,Stevan E Hobfoll,Simone Honikman,Louise M Howard,Thomas Hyphantis,Maria Iglesias-González,Masatoshi Inagaki,Josef Jenewein,Hong Jin Jeon,Nathalie Jetté,Miguel Julião,Pirjo A Kettunen,Mohammad E Khamseh,Kim M Kiely,Sung-Wan Kim,Marie Kjærgaard,Jane Kohlhoff,Brandon A Kohrt,Hans-Helmut König,Zoltán Kozinszky,Yunxin Kwan,Femke Lamers,María Asunción Lara,Angeliki A Leonardou,Holly F Levin-Aspenson,Shen-Ing Liu,Margrit Löbner,Wim L Loosman,Manote Lotrakul,Sonia R Loureiro,Anthony W Love,Bernd Löwe,Nagendra P Luitel,Crick Lund,Michael Maes,Ulrik F Malt,Ruth Ann Marrie,Laura Marsh,Pablo Martínez,Brian P Marx,Yutaka Matsuoka,Anthony McGuire,Anja Mehnert,Ioannis Michopoulos,Sherina Mohd Sidik,Jacqueline Müller-Nordhorn,Kumiko Muramatsu,Sandra Nakić Radoš,Laura Navarrete,Christian J Nelson,Chong Guan Ng,Daisuke Nishi,Meaghan L O'Donnell,Suzanne J O'Rourke,Flávia L Osório,Alexander Pabst,Julie A Pasco,Susan J Pawlby,Jurate Peceliuniene,Brian W Pence,Philippe Persoons,Inge Petersen,Angelo Picardi,Jennie L Ponsford,Stephanie L Pugh,Federico Pulido,Terence J Quinn,Chantal Quispel,Sujit D Rathod,Silje E Reme,Katrin Reuter,Steffi G Riedel-Heller,Alasdair G Rooney,Iná S Santos,Rebecca M Saracino,Melanie P J Schellekens,Marcelo L Schwarzbold,Vesile Senturk Cankorur,Juwita Shaaban,Deborah J Sharp,Louise Sharpe,Eileen H Shinn,Abbey Sidebottom,Sébastien Simard,Susanne Singer,Alkistis Skalkidou,Johanne Smith-Nielsen,Lena Spangenberg,Lesley Stafford,Alan Stein,Robert C Stewart,Natalie A Strobel,Kuan-Pin Su,Serge Sultan,Inger Sundström-Poromaa,Sharon C Sung,Keiko Suzuki,Meri Tadinac,Pei Lin Lynnette Tan,S Darius Tandon,Martin Taylor-Rowan,Antonio L Teixeira,Iva Tendais,Istvan Tiringer,Annamária Töreki,Thach D Tran,Kylee Trevillion,Mira Tschorn,Alyna Turner,Mette S Væver,Christina M van der Feltz-Cornelis,Thandi van Heyningen,Johann M Vega-Dienstmaier,Michael Wagner,Lynne I Wagner,Liang-Jen Wang,Jian Li Wang,David Watson,Siegfried B Weyerer,Jennifer White,Mary A Whooley,Birgitt Wiese,Lana J Williams,Kirsty Winkley,Karen Wynter,Mitsuhiko Yamada,Kimberly A Yonkers,Qing Zhi Zeng,Yuying Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2024.06.033

2024-09-15

Abstract:Administration mode of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) may influence responses. We assessed if Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression subscale (HADS-D) item responses and scores were associated with administration mode. We compared (1) self-administration versus interview-administration; within self-administration (2) research or medical setting versus private; and (3) pen-and-paper versus electronic; and within interview-administration (4) in-person versus phone. We analysed individual participant data meta-analysis datasets with item-level data for the PHQ-9 (N = 34,529), EPDS (N = 16,813), and HADS-D (N = 16,768). We used multiple indicator multiple cause models to assess differential item functioning (DIF) by administration mode. We found statistically significant DIF for most items on all measures due to large samples, but influence on total scores was negligible. In 10 comparisons conducted across the PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D, Pearson's correlations and intraclass correlation coefficients between latent depression symptom scores from models that did or did not account for DIF were between 0.995 and 1.000. Total PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D scores did not differ materially across administration modes. Researcher and clinicians who evaluate depression symptoms with these questionnaires can select administration methods based on patient preferences, feasibility, or cost.