The tale of TILs in breast cancer: A report from The International Immuno-Oncology Biomarker Working Group
Khalid El Bairi,Harry R. Haynes,Elizabeth Blackley,Susan Fineberg,Jeffrey Shear,Sophia Turner,Juliana Ribeiro de Freitas,Daniel Sur,Luis Claudio Amendola,Masoumeh Gharib,Amine Kallala,Indu Arun,Farid Azmoudeh-Ardalan,Luciana Fujimoto,Luz F. Sua,Shi-Wei Liu,Huang-Chun Lien,Pawan Kirtani,Marcelo Balancin,Hicham El Attar,Prerna Guleria,Wenxian Yang,Emad Shash,I-Chun Chen,Veronica Bautista,Jose Fernando Do Prado Moura,Bernardo L. Rapoport,Carlos Castaneda,Eunice Spengler,Gabriela Acosta-Haab,Isabel Frahm,Joselyn Sanchez,Miluska Castillo,Najat Bouchmaa,Reena R. Md Zin,Ruohong Shui,Timothy Onyuma,Wentao Yang,Zaheed Husain,Karen Willard-Gallo,An Coosemans,Edith A. Perez,Elena Provenzano,Paula Gonzalez Ericsson,Eduardo Richardet,Ravi Mehrotra,Sandra Sarancone,Anna Ehinger,David L. Rimm,John M. S. Bartlett,Giuseppe Viale,Carsten Denkert,Akira I. Hida,Christos Sotiriou,Sibylle Loibl,Stephen M. Hewitt,Sunil Badve,William Fraser Symmans,Rim S. Kim,Giancarlo Pruneri,Shom Goel,Prudence A. Francis,Gloria Inurrigarro,Rin Yamaguchi,Hernan Garcia-Rivello,Hugo Horlings,Said Afqir,Roberto Salgado,Sylvia Adams,Marleen Kok,Maria Vittoria Dieci,Stefan Michiels,Sandra Demaria,Sherene Loi,Vera Schelfhout,Elham Arbzadeh,Anastasiya Bondanar,Silvio Antonio Galeano Reyes,Jose Ramirez Ruz,Jun Kang,Lu Xiang,Martina Zimovjanova,Pilar Togores,Tulin Ozturk,Asawari Patil,Marcus Corpa,Ann Whitehouse,Benjamin Tan,Alfredo de Paula,Claudia Rossetti,Corinna Lang-Schwarz,Sarah Mahon,Cinzia Giacometti,Barbro Linderholm,Frederik Deman,Giacomo Montagna,Gyungyub Gong,Marta Pavcovich,Yeesoo Chaer,Isabel Alvarado Cabrero,Mayana Lopes de Brito,Nevena Ilieva,Annamaria Fulop,Maiara Souza,Domenico Bilancia,Michael Idowu,Ritika Johri,Joanna Szpor,Lira Bachani,Fernando Schmitt,Mag Giannotti,Yutaka Kurebayashi,Bruno Elias Anota Ramirez,Eduardo Salido,Laura Bortesi,Sara Bonetto,Kevin Elomina,Patricia Lopez,Vijay Sharma,Amalika Edirisinghe,Dhanvi Mathur,Ayushi Sahay,Makhlouf Ait Mouloud,Chau Huynh Giang,Edwin Mukolwe,Edgar Kiruka,Nancy Samberg,Norie Abe,Mark Brown,Ewan Millar,Xiaoxian Li,Zheng Yuan,Asokan Pasupathy,Raffaele Miele,Ronald Luff,Monica Modesto Araujo e Porfirio,Ogugua Ajemba,Rashida Soni,Enrico Orvieto,Michael DiMaio,Jeremy Thomas,Reena Merard,Manish Mani Subramaniam,Thiago Apolinario,Ovidiu Preda,Ricardo Preda,Alexander Makanga,Marcelo Souto Maior,Lingyu Li,Mahasti Saghatchian,Tricia Saurine,Emiel Janssen,John Cochran,Nikitina Vlada,Rocco Cappellesso,Katherine Elfer,Morven Hollick,Sangeeta Desai,Gizem Oner,Arthur Schreurs,Steve Liu,Rashindrie Perera,Paola Mercurio,Felip Garcia,Kareem Hosny,Hirofumi Matsumoto,Carolien van Deurzen,Giampaolo Bianchini,Ipek Coban,Arif Jahangir,Arman Rahman,Daniel Stover,Paulo Luz,Anne Martel,Yannick Waumans,Albrecht Stenzinger,Javier Cortes,Polina Dimitrova,Inne Nauwelaers,Montse Velasco,Fang Fan,Guray Akturk,Michael Firer,Ioannis Roxanis,Mary Schneck,Hannah Wen,Vincent Cockenpot,Aleksei Konstantinov,Ana Calatrava,M. N. Vidya,Hyun Joo Choi,Paul Jank,Aini Hyyti ÇÏinen,Dhanusha Sabanathan,Giuseppe Floris,Doris Hoeflmayer,Tetsuo Hamada,Nele Laudus,Anita Grigoriadis,Ilaria Porcellato,Balazs Acs,Federica Miglietta,Jeannette Parrodi,David Clunie,Benjamin Calhoun,Fang-I Lu,Alex Lefevre,Sami Tabbarah,William Tran,Isaac Garcia-murillas,Petar Jelinic,Carolien Boeckx,Sandra Souza,MarÇða Cebollero,Eudald Felip,Jose Luis Solorzano Rendon,Ehab El Gabry,Joel Saltz,Emilio Bria,Giovanna Garufi,Johan Hartman,Manu Sebastian,Helena Olofsson,Loes Kooreman,Joël Cucherousset,Marie-Christine Mathieu,Carmen Ballesteros-Merino,Popi Siziopikou,Jacinta Fong,Molly Klein,Ignasi Roig I. Qulis,Jelle Wesseling,Enrique Bellolio,Juan Carlos Araya,Stephen Naber,Maggie Cheang,Isabella Castellano,Ales Ales,Anne-Vibeke Laenkholm,Janina Kulka,Cecily Quinn,Anna Sapino,Isabel Amendoeira,Caterina Marchio,Jeremy Braybrooke,Anne Vincent-Salomon,Konstanty Korski,Michail Sofopoulos,Elisabeth Ida Specht Stovgaard,Simonetta Bianchi,Zsuzsanna Bago-Horvath,Clare Yu,Peter Regitnig,Sean Hall,Zuzana Kos,Sneha Sant,Jean-Christophe Tille,Brandon Gallas,Daniel Bethmann,Peter Savas,Larissa Mendes,Teresa Soler,Maartje van Seijen,Tina Gruosso,Angela Quintana,Jennifer Giltnane,Gert Van den Eynden,Eleonora Duregon,Rafa de Cabo,Phil Coates Recamo,Louis Gaboury,Johannes Zimmerman,Claudia Stanciu Pop,Alejandra Wernicke,David Williams,Anthony Gill,Benjamin Solomon,Bibhusal Thapa,Gelareh Farshid,Leslie Gilham,Michael Christie,Sandra O’Toole,Shona Hendry,Stephen B. Fox,Stephen J. Luen,Sunil R. Lakhani,Talia Fuchs,Tom John,Iva Brcic,Johannes Hainfellner,Lax Sigurd,Matthias Preusser,Philip Poortmans,Alex Decaluwe,Caroline Carey,Cecile Colpaert,Denis Larsimont,Dieter Peeters,Glenn Broeckx,Koen van de Vijver,Laurence Buisseret,Luc Dirix,Marjan Hertoghs,Martine Piccart,Michail Ignatiadis,Mieke Van Bockstal,Nicolas Sirtaine,Peter Vermeulen,Roland de Wind,Sabine Declercq,Thomas Gevaert,Benjamin Haibe-Kans,Brad H. Nelson,Peter H. Watson,Sam Leung,Torsten Nielsen,Leming Shi,Eva Balslev,Jeppe Thagaard,Alhadi Almangush,Antti Makitie,Heikki Joensuu,Johan Lundin,Damien Drubay,Elvire Roblin,Fabrice Andre,Frederique Penault-Llorca,Jerome Lemonnier,Julien Adam,Magali Lacroix-Triki,Nils Ternes,Nina Radosevic-Robin,Frederick Klaushen,Karsten Weber,Nadia Harbeck,Oleg Gluz,Stephan Wienert,Gabor Cserni,Andrea Vingiani,Carmen Criscitiello,Cinzia Solinas,Giuseppe Curigliano,Eiichi Konishi,Eiji Suzuki,Katsuhiro Yoshikawa,Kosuke Kawaguchi,Masahiro Takada,Masakazu Toi,Mitsuaki Ishida,Nobuhiro Shibata,Shigehira Saji,Takahiro Kogawa,Takashi Sakatani,Takeru Okamoto,Takuya Moriya,Tatsuki Kataoka,Tatsunori Shimoi,Tomohagu Sugie,Tomoharu Sugie,Toru Mukohara,Yazaki Shu,Yuichiro Kikawa,Yuji Kozuka,Shahin Sayed,Reena Rahayu,Reena Ramsaroop,Elżbieta Senkus-Konefka,Ewa Chmielik,Fatima Cardoso,Joana Ribeiro,Jack Chan,Rebecca Dent,Miguel Martin,Carlos Hagen,Angel Guerrero,Federico Rojo,Laura Comerma,Paolo Nuciforo,Victor Vivo Serrano,Vincente Peg Cámaea,Tessa Steenbruggen,Francesco Ciompi,Iris Nederlof,Jan Hudecek,Jeroen van der Laak,Jose van den Berg,Leonie Voorwerk,Mark van de Vijver,Michiel de Maaker,Sabine Linn,Hayley McKenzie,Navita Somaiah,Andrew Tutt,Charles Swanton,Crispin Hiley,David A. Moore,Jacqueline A. Hall,John Le Quesne,Khalid Abdul Jabbar,Maise al Bakir,Robert Hills,Sheeba Irshad,Yinyin Yuan,Zaibo Li,Minetta Liu,Jonathan Klein,Oluwole Fadare,Alastair Thompson,Alexander J. Lazar,Allen Gown,Amy Lo,Ana C. Garrido Castro,Anant Madabhushi,Andre Moreira,Andrea Richardson,Andrew H. Beck,Andrew M. Bellizzi,Antonio Wolff,Aparna Harbhajanka,Ashish Sharma,Ashley Cimino-Mathews,Ashok Srinivasan,Baljit Singh,Chakra S. Chennubhotla,Cynthia Chauhan,Deborah A. Dillon,Dimitrios Zardavas,Douglas B. Johnson,Aubrey E. Thompson,Edi Brogi,Emily Reisenbichler,Erich Huang,Fred R. Hirsch,Heather McArthur,James Ziai,Jane Brock,Jennifer Kerner,Jiping Zha,Jochen K. Lennerz,Jodi M. Carter,Jorge Reis-Filho,Joseph Sparano,Justin M. Balko,Katherine Pogue-Geile,Keith E. Steele,Kim R. M. Blenman,Kimberly H. Allison,Lajos Pusztai,Lee Cooper,Valeria M. Estrada,Margaret Flowers,Mark Robson,Marlon C. Rebelatto,Matthew G. Hanna,Matthew P. Goetz,Mehrnoush Khojasteh,Melinda E. Sanders,Meredith M. Regan,Michael Misialek,Mohamed Amgad,Nadine Tung,Rajendra Singh,Richard Huang,Robert H. Pierce,Roberto Leon-Ferre,Sandra Swain,Scott Ely,Seong-Rim Kim,Shahinaz Bedri,Soonmyung Paik,Stuart Schnitt,Timothy d’Alfons,Uday Kurkure,Veerle Bossuyt,Weida Tong,Yihong Wang,Carlos Henrique Dos Anjos,Fabien Gaire,Paul J. Van Diest,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41523-021-00346-1
2021-12-01
npj Breast Cancer
Abstract:Abstract The advent of immune-checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) in modern oncology has significantly improved survival in several cancer settings. A subgroup of women with breast cancer (BC) has immunogenic infiltration of lymphocytes with expression of programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1). These patients may potentially benefit from ICI targeting the programmed death 1 (PD-1)/PD-L1 signaling axis. The use of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) as predictive and prognostic biomarkers has been under intense examination. Emerging data suggest that TILs are associated with response to both cytotoxic treatments and immunotherapy, particularly for patients with triple-negative BC. In this review from The International Immuno-Oncology Biomarker Working Group , we discuss (a) the biological understanding of TILs, (b) their analytical and clinical validity and efforts toward the clinical utility in BC, and (c) the current status of PD-L1 and TIL testing across different continents, including experiences from low-to-middle-income countries, incorporating also the view of a patient advocate. This information will help set the stage for future approaches to optimize the understanding and clinical utilization of TIL analysis in patients with BC.
oncology