Pulmonary venous circulating tumor cell dissemination before tumor resection and disease relapse

Francesca Chemi,Dominic G Rothwell,Nicholas McGranahan,Sakshi Gulati,Chris Abbosh,Simon P Pearce,Cong Zhou,Gareth A Wilson,Mariam Jamal-Hanjani,Nicolai Birkbak,Jackie Pierce,Chang Sik Kim,Saba Ferdous,Deborah J Burt,Daniel Slane-Tan,Fabio Gomes,David Moore,Rajesh Shah,Maise Al Bakir,Crispin Hiley,Selvaraju Veeriah,Yvonne Summers,Philip Crosbie,Sophia Ward,Barbara Mesquita,Marek Dynowski,Dhruva Biswas,Jonathan Tugwood,Fiona Blackhall,Crispin Miller,Allan Hackshaw,Ged Brady,Charles Swanton,Caroline Dive,TRACERx Consortium,Yenting Ngai,Abigail Sharp,Cristina Rodrigues,Oliver Pressey,Sean Smith,Nicole Gower,Harjot Dhanda,Elaine Kilgour,Lynsey Priest,Matthew G Krebs,Mathew Carter,Colin R Lindsay,Thomas B K Watkins,Rachel Rosenthal,Mickael Escudero,Aengus Stewart,Andrew Rowan,Jacki Goldman,Peter Van Loo,Richard Kevin Stone,Tamara Denner,Emma Nye,Emilia Lim,Stefan Boeing,Maria Greco,Kevin Litchfield,Jerome Nicod,Clare Puttick,Katey Enfield,Emma Colliver,Brittany Campbell,Yin Wu,Marcin Skrzypski,Robert E Hynds,Andrew Georgiou,Mariana Werner Sunderland,James L Reading,Sergio A Quezada,Karl S Peggs,Teresa Marafioti,John A Hartley,Pat Gorman,Helen L Lowe,Leah Ensell,Victoria Spanswick,Angeliki Karamani,Maryam Razaq,Stephan Beck,Ariana Huebner,Michelle Dietzen,Cristina Naceur-Lombardelli,Mita Afroza Akther,Haoran Zhai,Nnennaya Kannu,Elizabeth Manzano,Supreet Kaur Bola,Ehsan Ghorani,Marc Robert de Massy,Elena Hoxha,Emine Hatipoglu,Stephanie Ogwuru,Benny Chain,Raffaele Califano,Paul Taylor,Piotr Krysiak,Kendadai Rammohan,Eustace Fontaine,Richard Booton,Matthew Evison,Stuart Moss,Juliette Novasio,Leena Joseph,Paul Bishop,Anshuman Chaturvedi,Helen Doran,Felice Granato,Vijay Joshi,Elaine Smith,Angeles Montero,Gillian Price,Sylvie Dubois-Marshall,Keith Kerr,Shirley Palmer,Heather Cheyne,Joy Miller,Keith Buchan,Mahendran Chetty,Mohammed Khalil,Veni Ezhil,Vineet Prakash,Girija Anand,Sajid Khan,Kelvin Lau,Michael Sheaff,Peter Schmid,Louise Lim,John Conibear,Roland Schwarz,John Le Quesne,Joan Riley,Lindsay Primrose,Luke Martinson,Nicolas Carey,Jacqui A Shaw,Dean Fennell,Apostolos Nakas,Sridhar Rathinam,Louise Nelson,Kim Ryanna,Mohamad Tuffail,Amrita Bajaj,Jan Brozik,Fiona Morgan,Malgorzata Kornaszewska,Richard Attanoos,Haydn Adams,Helen Davies,Zoltan Szallasi,Roberto Salgado,Istvan Csabai,Miklos Diossy,Hugo Aerts,Alan Kirk,Mo Asif,John Butler,Rocco Bilanca,Nikos Kostoulas,Mairead MacKenzie,Maggie Wilcox,Sara Busacca,Alan Dawson,Mark R Lovett,Michael Shackcloth,Sarah Feeney,Julius Asante-Siaw,John Gosney,Angela Leek,Nicola Totten,Jack Davies Hodgkinson,Rachael Waddington,Jane Rogan,Katrina Moore,William Monteiro,Hilary Marshall,Kevin G Blyth,Craig Dick,Andrew Kidd,Eric Lim,Paulo De Sousa,Simon Jordan,Alexandra Rice,Hilgardt Raubenheimer,Harshil Bhayani,Morag Hamilton,Lyn Ambrose,Anand Devaraj,Hema Chavan,Sofina Begum,Aleksander Mani,Daniel Kaniu,Mpho Malima,Sarah Booth,Andrew G Nicholson,Nadia Fernandes,Jessica E Wallen,Pratibha Shah,Sarah Danson,Jonathan Bury,John Edwards,Jennifer Hill,Sue Matthews,Yota Kitsanta,Jagan Rao,Sara Tenconi,Laura Socci,Kim Suvarna,Faith Kibutu,Patricia Fisher,Robin Young,Joann Barker,Fiona Taylor,Kirsty Lloyd,Teresa Light,Tracey Horey,Dionysis Papadatos-Pastos,Peter Russell,Sara Lock,Kayleigh Gilbert,David Lawrence,Martin Hayward,Nikolaos Panagiotopoulos,Robert George,Davide Patrini,Mary Falzon,Elaine Borg,Reena Khiroya,Asia Ahmed,Magali Taylor,Junaid Choudhary,Penny Shaw,Sam M Janes,Martin Forster,Tanya Ahmad,Siow Ming Lee,Javier Herrero,Dawn Carnell,Ruheena Mendes,Jeremy George,Neal Navani,Marco Scarci,Elisa Bertoja,Robert C M Stephens,Emilie Martinoni Hoogenboom,James W Holding,Steve Bandula,Babu Naidu,Gerald Langman,Andrew Robinson,Hollie Bancroft,Amy Kerr,Salma Kadiri,Charlotte Ferris,Gary Middleton,Madava Djearaman,Akshay Patel,Christian Ottensmeier,Serena Chee,Benjamin Johnson,Aiman Alzetani,Emily Shaw,Jason Lester

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-019-0593-1

Abstract:Approximately 50% of patients with early-stage non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) who undergo surgery with curative intent will relapse within 5 years1,2. Detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) at the time of surgery may represent a tool to identify patients at higher risk of recurrence for whom more frequent monitoring is advised. Here we asked whether CellSearch-detected pulmonary venous CTCs (PV-CTCs) at surgical resection of early-stage NSCLC represent subclones responsible for subsequent disease relapse. PV-CTCs were detected in 48% of 100 patients enrolled into the TRACERx study3, were associated with lung-cancer-specific relapse and remained an independent predictor of relapse in multivariate analysis adjusted for tumor stage. In a case study, genomic profiling of single PV-CTCs collected at surgery revealed higher mutation overlap with metastasis detected 10 months later (91%) than with the primary tumor (79%), suggesting that early-disseminating PV-CTCs were responsible for disease relapse. Together, PV-CTC enumeration and genomic profiling highlight the potential of PV-CTCs as early predictors of NSCLC recurrence after surgery. However, the limited sensitivity of PV-CTCs in predicting relapse suggests that further studies using a larger, independent cohort are warranted to confirm and better define the potential clinical utility of PV-CTCs in early-stage NSCLC.