Abstract:Understanding how neural populations interact is crucial to understand brain function. Most common approaches to infer neural interactions are based on Granger causality (GC) analyses and effective connectivity (EC) models of neural time series. However, an in-depth investigation of the similarity and complementarity of these approaches is currently lacking. GC and EC are classically thought to provide complementary information about the interdependence between neural signals. Whereas GC quantifies the amount of predictability between time series and it is interpreted as a measure of information flow, EC quantifies the amount and sign of the interaction, and it is often interpreted as the causal influence that a neural unit exert over another. Here, we show that, in the context of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data analysis and first-order autoregressive models, GC and EC share common assumptions and are mathematically related. More precisely, by defining a ‘corrected’ version of GC accounting for unequal noise variances affecting the source and target node, we show that the two measures are linked by an approximately quadratic relation, where positive or negative values of EC are associated with identical values of GC. While the relation is obtained in limit of infinite sampling time, we use simulations to show that it can be observed in finite data samples as classically observed in neuroimaging studies, provided sufficiently long sampling, multiple sessions or group averaging. Finally, we compare the GC and EC analyses on fMRI data from the Human Connectome Project, and obtain results consistent with simulation outcomes. While GC and EC analyses do not provide reliable estimates at the single subject or single connection level, they become stable at the group level (more than approximately 20 subjects), where the predicted relation between GC and EC can be clearly observed from the data. To conclude, our study provides a common mathematical framework to make grounded methodological choices in the reconstruction and analysis of directed brain networks from neuroimaging time series.

Neural mechanisms of the continued influence effect of misinformation: Analysis based on fMRI causal connectivity

Influence of individual differences in executive functions of WM on the continued influence effect of misinformation

Intrinsic functional connectivity in medial temporal lobe networks is associated with susceptibility to misinformation

The continued influence of implied and explicitly stated misinformation with different emotional valence

Neural Resonance in Consumers' Right Inferior Frontal Gyrus Predicts Attitudes Toward Advertising

Neural Correlates of Causal Inferences in Discourse Understanding and Logical Problem-Solving: A Meta-Analysis Study

Directed neural interactions in fMRI: a comparison between Granger Causality and Effective Connectivity

Unethical amnesia brain: Memory and metacognitive distortion induced by dishonesty

Tracking politically motivated reasoning in the brain: the role of mentalizing, value-encoding, and error-detection networks

Elucidating the underlying components of metacognitive systematic bias in the human dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and inferior parietal cortex

Effects of contextual relevance on pragmatic inference during conversation: An fMRI study

Neural Systems Underlying Emotional and Non-emotional Interference Processing: An ALE Meta-Analysis of Functional Neuroimaging Studies

Negative news dominates fast and slow brain responses and social judgments even after source credibility evaluation

Does explaining the origins of misinformation improve the effectiveness of a given correction?

Neural correlates of feigned memory impairment.

Neural Mechanisms of Inhibition in Scientific Reasoning: Insights from fNIRS

Combining Dynamic Network Analysis and Cerebral Carryover Effect to Evaluate the Impacts of Reading Social Media Posts and Science Fiction in the Natural State on the Human Brain

Processing of misinformation as motivational and cognitive biases

The mnemonic effect of central and peripheral misinformation on social media

One-way traffic: The inferior frontal gyrus controls brain activation in the middle temporal gyrus and inferior parietal lobule during divergent thinking

The Effects of AI-based Credibility Indicators on the Detection and Spread of Misinformation under Social Influence