Response to Prof. Rosa Soares’ Letter

K. Gwee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2982.2005.00721.x

2006-03-01

Abstract:Dear Editor, The report from Brazil by Soares and co-workers (Neurogastroenterol Motil 2005; 17: 883) following my recent review on irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) in developing countries (Neurogastroenterol Motil 2005; 17: 317–24) is notable for the rare glimpse that it gives us of IBS in South America. The estimate from this study (13.5–14.8%) suggests that IBS is as prevalent in Brazil as in the rest of the world. The suggestion by the authors that the high prevalence they observed may be due to westernization of the diet in the two cities studied, while interesting, will require further study to support it. Limitations of this study included the following – small sample size, selection criteria, and absence of an objective indicator of westernization of diet and its impact on the development of IBS. Irritable bowel syndrome is generally considered to be a multifactorial disorder and attempts at controlling for confounding factors by making comparison between their two populations with regard to emotional triggers, food intolerance and gender were important but inadequate given the small sample size. In the absence of detailed demographic data on these two populations, it is difficult to comment whether the study groups were representative of the general populations. A frequent observation from many populations in the west, and similarly in these two Brazilian populations, is the higher prevalence of IBS among women. The fact that they had more women in Oriximina (75%) than in Rio de Janeiro (61%), may have contributed to a greater overall prevalence of IBS in the former group, independent of any influence from industrialization. Thus, while this report from Brazil provides food for thought, more robust methodology will be required to test the hypothesis that an increasing prevalence of IBS in developing countries is linked to westernization of diet. Going forward, selection of study populations should include societies in different stages of westernization. Perhaps charting the number of western fast food outlets per 100 000 population, against the prevalence of IBS, could prove to be more than an amusing anecdote, and provide insight into the pathogenesis of this intriguing enigma that is IBS.