The Theory of Rate Processes and Gene Mutation
W. D. Mcelroy,C. Swanson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/398376
1951-12-01
The Quarterly Review of Biology
Abstract:T H HE stability of genes, as reflected in their frequency of mutation under naturally or experimentally imposed contions, resides, as in any chemical system, in the frequency with which the genic structures transgress the limits of chemical stability to pass into new states of equilibrium and rearrangement. These considerations have been dealt with previously by Timofeeff-Ressovsky, Zimmer, and Delbriick (1935), and, in a popular fashion, by Schrodinger (1944). The former investigators, taking into account the temperature coefficient of the rates of spontaneous mutation and the frequency of induced mutations as a direct function of the total dose of ionizing radiations, have, as a first approximation, defined a mutation as a definite rearrangement in a definite molecule. They have, moreover, pointed out that the differences in rates of spontaneous mutation characteristic of specific genes can be logically understood by assuming only slight differences in the amount of energy of activation needed for a gene to exceed the limits of stability and thus pass over to an altered mode of expression, i.e., a small difference in the energy of activation would lead to enormous differences in the probability of occurrence of an event, in this case, a mutation. These same genes, however, would be expected to respond similarly to ionizing radiations, since each effective ionizing event imparts to the genic bond a far greater amount of energy than that necessary to exceed successfully the limits of stability. In a general way, these expectations have been experimentally confirmed. It would appear, therefore, that the hypothesis of Timofeeff-Rossovsky, Zimmer, and Delbriick, relating mutations, both spontaneous and induced, to the probability that the degree of freedom of the bond will exceed the limit of stable fluctuation, accounted in an entirely satisfactory manner for the data obtained for gene mutations. The events leading to mutation are considered to be chemical events consummated within the limits of time ascribed to chemical reactions, and dependent, insofar as ionizing radiations are concerned, in a linear fashion upon the amount of introduced energy. The attempt to interpret mutation events and genic stabilities in terms of the known laws of physics and chemistry suffers, as the above investigators have pointed out, from the fact that the chemical molecule and the genic molecule had not been at the time, and are not yet, equated, plus the further complication that the criteria for change in chemistry and in genetics are, while similarly quantitative, at quite different levels of organization and integration. Recent studies in the area of induced mutations, however, suggest that, as in 1935, the time is again opportune to reconsider genic stability and change in terms of chemical kinetics. The discovery of chemical mutagenicity by Auerbach and Robson (1946), followed by the discovery of numerous mutagenic substances of quite unrelated structure, the phenomenon of delayed mutations in organisms such as bacteria and Drosophila, the potentiation and inhibition of x-ray, ultraviolet, and mustard effects by chemical and physical means, and the partial dependence of x-ray effects on oxygen tension and temperature, all suggest that the primary action of mutagens is in part, if not altogether, indirect, through the medium of activated radicals or complexes within the nucleus, rather than direct by the processes of ionization or photochemical absorption. A tentative approach to this problem has been made by Auerbach (1949) who, as the result of studies on mosaicism induced in Drosophila by mustard gas, has suggested that labile genic states can arise as the result of treatment, and that these, persisting for various intervals of time "in a shallow trough of energy, separated by low energy thresholds from two or more stable equilibria," can be pushed by subsequent slight additional supplies of energy in one or more directions toward a more stable state, either the original