Assaults in hospitals.

W. Reid,M. Bollinger,G. Edwards

Abstract:Psychiatric News reported several deaths of psychiatrists at the hands of their patients in 1982. This year a psychiatry resident was murdered by a patient in her office. Two years ago an intern was the fatal victim of a former psychiatric patient as he worked in a Kansas City emergency room. These striking reports do little to describe accurately the incidence and severity of assaults in hospitals. There is a need for valid, reliable data concerning potential dangers to psychiatrists, other medical staff, and patients in medical care settings. It is important to know the baselines from which to measure deviations in assault incidence, to discuss what is being done to whom, and to prevent and manage such situations. Unfortunately, most common sense approaches to this problem have limited usefulness. Bromides such as "paranoids are more dangerous" or "female staff hardly ever get assaulted" may have some merit in certain situations; however, our group is now fairly certain that one should put only very limited credence in any of them. One reason for the limited value of these sayings has to do with the great range of health care settings in which violence may occur. In addition, different ways of defining and reporting assaultive incidents significantly alter the form and content of one's results. Recent studies have reported rates of significant assault as low as 25 cases per 27,000 patients per ten years. I Most studies have found a higher incidence. 2 -4 In a large survey of clinicians, one of us (W.H.R.) found data to agree with other investigators that up to one-half of all psychiatrists experience at least one serious assault during their careers. S Tardiff and Sweillam 4 report that about 7.5 percent of patients in the New York State hospital system have committed at least one assault in the hospital. Finally, unpublished data from the Veterans Administration indicates some 12,000 assaultive incidents were reported within the system over a recent five-year period.