MEDIAN NAIL DYSTROPHY AND HABIT TIC DEFORMITY: ARE THEY DIFFERENT FORMS OF THE SAME DISORDER?

R. Griego,I. Orengo,R. Scher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-4362.1995.tb04402.x

1995-11-01

International Journal of Dermatology

Abstract:An 18-year-old man witb a lifelong bistory of a mild nail dystropby of botb thumbnails, characterized by subtle transverse ridges, presented witb a new, more pronounced dystrophy of botb thumbnails of 4-montbs duration. The patient was in good bealtb, except for moderate nodulocystlc acne for wbich a 6-month course of isotretinoin, 40 mg twice daily, had been completed 1 week before presentation. The patient's mother reported having manipulated tbe patient's cuticles during infancy. Tbe patient denied otber recent trauma or a habit of picking at eitber nail, which was corroborated by bis mother. The left tbumbnail sbowed a series of fairly evenly spaced transverse grooves witb a central depression (Fig. 1). Examination of tbe right thumbnail sbowed a paramedian fissure from which dark ridges radiated proximally, imparting a fir tree appearance (see Fig. 1). Tbe lunulae of both fingernails were larger tban normal. The proximal nail folds and periungual tissues of both affected nails were normal, except for a callosity just distal to the interpbalangeal joint of tbe left thumb. Tbe diagnoses of median nail dystropby and babit tic nail deformity were made and tbe patient was prescribed flurandrenolide tape (Cordran tape) to be cut to cover tbe proximal nail fold and plate of eacb thumbnail. The patient complied witb the treatment regimen for approximately 3 weeks, then discontinued tberapy, wben bis medication supply was depleted, despite the availability of a refill. Improvement of botb thumbnails was evidenced by resolution of tbe nail dystropby at tbe proximal end of tbe nail plate by week 4 after diagnosis and, by 5 montbs, the dystropby was residual only at the very distal nail plate of both thumbs. ana canaliformis, is typically a paramedian canal or split of the nail plate of one or more nails., most commonly the thumbnail., with transverse fissures emanating from the central split but not reaching the lateral edges of the nail plate.• '̂'* The frequent proximal radiation of the transverse fissures has been likened to a fir tree. Another, tnore comtnon, nail dystrophy is secondary to the habit of picking at the base of the nail with another finger of the same hand. This lesion commonly affects both thumbnails and is characterized by a series of transverse ridges often accompanied by a central depression extending frotn the cuticle to the free edge.*" The transverse ridges are mostly prominent centrally and reach laterally to a variable extent. This condition is created by repeated tninor trauma to the nail matrix and most patients readily admit to the manipulation of this area when questioned.' The etiology of median nail dystropby is not so apparent. Familial occurrences, and the fact, that lesions have cleared with extraction of abscessed teeth and with radiation therapy., has raised several hypotheses for etiologies of median nail dystrophy, including vascular, neurotrophic, focal infectious, hereditary, and psychical influences.'' Many cases have demonstrated a spontaneous return of the nails to normal after a period of months to years, with frequent relapses;^ therefore, assessment of the effect of any intervention is difficult. As with the case presented, most patients with this lesion have been noted to have a larger than normal lunula on the affected nail. This observation has led to the theo-