Night Physician–Nurse Collaboration: Developing the Scale of Physicians' Difficulties and Exploring Related Factors in Acute Care Hospitals
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/jmdh.s454578
2024-06-13
Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare
Abstract:Soichiro Hotta, 1 Kaoru Ashida, 2 Makoto Tanaka 1 1 Department of Adult Health Nursing, Graduate School of Health Care Sciences, Tokyo Medical and Dental University, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan; 2 Department of Nursing, College of Nursing, Kanto Gakuin University, Kanazawa-ku, Yokohama, Japan Correspondence: Soichiro Hotta, Department of Adult Health Nursing, Graduate School of Health Care Sciences, Tokyo Medical and Dental University, 1-5-45 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan, Tel +81 3 3813 6111 Ex 7768, Email Background: Responding to inpatient deterioration is less favorable at night than during the day, and this may be related to barriers in collaboration between physicians and nurses. However, there had been no way to assess the problem. This study aimed to develop a scale for physicians to measure difficulties in nighttime collaboration with nurses in response to deteriorating inpatients and to identify factors associated with the developed scale scores. Methods: We developed a draft scale of Nighttime Collaboration Difficulties between Nurses and Physicians for Physicians (NCDNP-P) based on key informant interviews with physicians. Psychometric validations, including structural validity, criterion-related validity, and reliability tests, were conducted among physicians who worked on night duty or on call in acute-care hospitals in Japan using a cross-sectional web-based questionnaire. Multiple linear regression analyses were performed using independent variables including individual backgrounds, style of working at night, and facility characteristics. Results: By performing exploratory factor analysis, we confirmed the structural validity of the NCDNP-P, consisting of seven items and two domains (Domain 1: Dissatisfaction with reporting, Domain 2: Barriers to working with nurses). Cronbach's alpha and McDonald's omega coefficients were 0.81– 0.84 and 0.81– 0.89, respectively. The criterion-related validity for interprofessional collaboration was confirmed. Multiple regression analysis revealed that the variables employment status, number of night shifts, frequency of nighttime calls about patients under another physician's charge, and handover between physicians before changing shifts were statistically significantly associated with NCDNP-P scores. Conclusion: We developed the NCDNP-P, confirming its reliability and validity. Identified factors reflect physicians' characteristics and the problems experienced working at night and may be associated with barriers in nighttime collaboration. The NCDNP-P can highlight issues in clinical settings and lead to the consideration of initiatives to address such issues. Keywords: clinical deterioration, interprofessional collaboration, scale development, nighttime In hospitalized patients, clinical deterioration often occurs during usual care. If the patient is provided with inappropriate care, this increases the risk of adverse outcomes such as unanticipated disease progression, cardiac arrest, and death. 1–3 There has been increasing interest in an efficient response to clinical deterioration in hospitalized patients from a perspective of patient safety and improving the quality of care, and active measures such as rapid response systems (RRS) to respond to clinical deterioration have been implemented. Despite these measures, challenges remain related to care processes such as the occurrence of delays in RRS activation at night, 3,4 and poorer clinical outcomes, including increased mortality rates, at night. 4–6 Appropriate escalation of care requires a series of efficient processes, including recognition of clinical deterioration, recording and reporting, and response. Physicians usually play a central leadership role and are required to have appropriate situation awareness and prompt responses or orders in responding to deteriorating patients. 7,8 Nurses play a key role in executing the escalation of care process, from recognition to reporting, and require competencies to correctly assess and care for patients and make referrals of deteriorating patients to physicians. 9,10 Many studies have documented challenges in communication or collaboration between physicians and nurses in this process; however, these barriers remain in clinical practice. 11–13 In addition, a previous scoping review regarding nighttime detection and response to clinical deterioration identified a gap in research concerning nighttime interprofessional communication and collaboration in response to deteriorating patients. 14 Accordingly, knowledge development that focuses on nighttime interprofessional collaboration may help address the challenges of responding to clinical deterioration a -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services