Abstract:Objectives: To quantitatively evaluate the performance of the most used colormaps in image display using perceptual metrics and to what extent these measures are congruent with the true intensity or uptake of pixels at different levels of defect severity in simulated cardiac images. Methods: Six colormaps, labeled "Gray", "Thermal", "Cool", "CEqual", "Siemens" and "S Pet" extracted from FIJI ImageJ software are included. Colormap data are converted from the red, green, blue color space to CIELAB. Perceptual metrics for measuring "color difference" were calculated, including difference (ΔE76) and "speed". The pairwise color difference in every two levels or entries is visualized in a 2-dimensional "heatmap distance matrix" for each colormap. Curves are plotted for each colormap and compared. In addition, to apply this technique to clinical images, simulated short-axis cardiac slices with incremental defect severity (10% grading) were employed. The circumferential profile curves of true pixel intensity, lightness or luminance, and color difference are plotted simultaneously for each defect severity to visualize the concordance of the three curves in various colormaps. Results: In 0% defect, all the curves are at the highest level, except for "s pet", in that the lightness is not at its maximum value. In the phantom with 10% defect (or 90% of maximum value), discrepancies among curves appear. In "Siemens", the ΔE76 drops sharply. In "Siemens" colormap, the ΔE76 drops sharply. In 80% defect, ΔE76 curve, in "gray" colormap drops more slowly than other curves of other colormaps. In "s pet", lightness curve rises paradoxically, although the count intensity and ΔE76 curve match. In 70% defect, again, the curves are in good agreement in "thermal", "Siemens" and "cequal". However, a consistent lag exists in "gray". Up to 50% defect, curves maintain their expected pattern, but in defects more severe than 40%, lightness and ΔE76 curves in "cool" and "cequal" rise paradoxically, and in "thermal", they start to slow down in descent. In "Siemens", falling pattern of the three curves continues. For "s pet" colormap, an erratic pattern of lightness and ΔE76 curves exists. Conclusion: Of 6 colormaps investigated for estimating defect severity, "grayscale" is less favorable than others and "thermal" performs slightly better. "S pet" or rainbow, which is used traditionally by many practitioners, is strongly discouraged. The "Siemens" colormap suffers from decreased discriminating power in the range of mild to moderate/severe. In contrast, the "cool" and "cequal" colormaps outperform the other colormaps employed in this study to some extent, although they have some shortcomings.

Color‐map recommendation for MR relaxometry maps

Color-map recommendation for MR relaxometry maps

Color Maps: Facilitating the Clinical Impact of Quantitative MRI

Three-dimensional Simultaneous Brain Mapping of T1, T2, T2*and Magnetic Susceptibility with MR Multitasking

Statistical estimation of T1 relaxation times using conventional magnetic resonance imaging

Relaxometry and contrast-free cerebral microvascular quantification using balanced Steady-State Free Precession MR Fingerprinting

Improved Pixel-by-pixel MRI R2* Relaxometry by Nonlocal Means.

Reducing thermal noise in high-resolution quantitative magnetic resonance imaging rotating frame relaxation mapping of the human brain at 3 T

Quantitative multi-parameter mapping of R1, PD, MT, and R2 at 3T: a multi-center validation

On the R2* Relaxometry in Complex Multi-Peak Multi-Echo Chemical Shift-Based Water-Fat Quantification: Applications to the Neuromuscular Diseases

Quantitative brain T1 maps derived from T1-weighted MRI acquisitions: a proof-of-concept study

Recommended Implementation of Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping for Clinical Research in The Brain: A Consensus of the ISMRM Electro-Magnetic Tissue Properties Study Group

Novel MRI T 2 Mapping for Improved Myocardial Tissue Characterisation

High Spatial-Resolution and Acquisition-Efficiency Cardiac MR T1 Mapping Based on Radial bSSFP and a Low-Rank Tensor Constraint

Color Constancy Model Based on Topology Resolve-Map in Medical Image Processing

Improving B1+ ‐inhomogeneity tolerance by resolving non‐bijection in MP2RAGE R1 mapping: A 2D look‐up table approach demonstrated at 3 T

Repeat it without me: Crowdsourcing the T1 mapping common ground via the ISMRM reproducibility challenge

Recommended implementation of quantitative susceptibility mapping for clinical research in the brain: A consensus of the ISMRM electro‐magnetic tissue properties study group

Quantitative Performance Evaluation of Commonly Used Colormaps for Image Display in Myocardial Perfusion Imaging: Analysis based on Perceptual Metrics

Performance of MR learned pulse sequences for 3D bi‐exponential, stretched‐exponential, and mono‐exponential T2 and T1ρ mapping of knee cartilage

3D color-rendered MR neurography heatmaps in visualizing normal lumbosacral (LS) plexus and increasing conspicuity of LS plexopathy