The Public Health Dilemma in the Alcohol Intervention Area: Unfinished Business Between Limits and Freedom

Franca Beccaria
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3109/10826084.2015.1042335
2015-07-29
Substance Use & Misuse
Abstract:Medical doctors have been interested in the individual and societal problems and consequences due to heavy drinking during the last three centuries (Heather & Robertson, 1989; Levine, 1978). The first sociologists exploring this topic, were the research group directed by Jellinek at Yale University during the 1940s, followed by Seldon Bacon at the Center of Alcohol Studies. Bacon placed the role of sociology into the discussion about alcohol studies, asking for broader attention be paid both to drinking and not drinking habits, and on how their cultural aspects influence institutional responses (Bacon, 1943). But it was especially thanks to the anthropologists Dwight Heath, Mary Douglas, and Edgerton that cultural aspects of drinking were investigated; helping to develop the concept of a drinking culture. Heath (1999), by comparing the meanings of alcohol consumption in traditional societies and in Western societies revealed that in contemporary Western societies the emphasis on alcohol focuses mainly on drinking as a social problem, a concept that was completely unknown in traditional societies even if negative consequences of drinking were also present. Since the 1970s, other alcohol drinking-related problems in addition to the health consequences today called ‘harm to others’—such as car and work accidents, violence, family problems, and so forth—attracted the attention of the scientific community, which found the total consumption model—elaborated by Sully Ledermann (1956)—to be a good tool for interpretation and for developing political strategies. Ledermann found a rather strong connection between total alcoholic beverage consumption in a population and mortality due to alcohol drinking-related pathologies. He showed that the number of heavy consumers and the total number of consumers are related, so that an increase in the number of alcohol consumers corresponds to an increase in problematic drinkers and consequently in alcohol consumption-related
What problem does this paper attempt to address?