Abstract:The determination of shear strength parameters for coarse granular materials such as rockfill and waste rocks is challenging due to their oversized particles and the minimum required ratio of 10 between the specimen width (W) and the maximum particle size (dmax) of tested samples for direct shear tests. To overcome this problem, a common practice is to prepare test samples by excluding the oversized particles. This method is called the scalping scaling down technique. Making further modifications on scalped samples to achieve a specific particle size distribution curve (PSDC) leads to other scaling down techniques. Until now, the parallel scaling down technique has been the most popular and most commonly applied, generally because it produces a PSDC parallel and similar to that of field material. Recently, a critical literature review performed by the authors revealed that the methodology used by previous researchers to validate or invalidate the scaling down techniques in estimating the shear strength of field materials is inappropriate. The validity of scaling down techniques remains unknown. In addition, the minimum required W/dmax ratio of 10, stipulated in ASTM D3080/D3080M-11 for direct shear tests, is not large enough to eliminate the specimen size effect (SSE). The authors’ recent experimental study showed that a minimum W/dmax ratio of 60 is necessary to avoid any SSE in direct shear tests. In this study, a series of direct shear tests were performed on samples with different dmax values, prepared by applying scalping and parallel scaling down techniques. All tested specimens had a W/dmax ratio equal to or larger than 60. The test results of the scaled down samples with dmax values smaller than those of field samples were used to establish a predictive equation between the effective internal friction angle (hereafter named “friction angle”) and dmax, which was then used to predict the friction angles of the field samples. Comparisons between the measured and predicted friction angles of field samples demonstrated that the equations based on scalping scaling down technique correctly predicted the friction angles of field samples, whereas the equations based on parallel scaling down technique failed to correctly predict the friction angles of field samples. The scalping down technique has been validated, whereas the parallel scaling down technique has been invalidated by the experimental results presented in this study.

Estimation of the shear strength of heterogeneous granular soils with matrix

Estimation of the shear strength of a coarse soil with high fines content by parallel gradation method

Effect of Fines Loss on the Microstructure and Shear Behaviors of Gap-Graded Soils: A Multiscale Perspective

Quantifying and Modelling Fabric Anisotropy of Granular Soils

A CFD–DEM Study on the Suffusion and Shear Behaviors of Gap-Graded Soils under Stress Anisotropy

The Influence of Particles' Aspect Ratio on the Shear Behaviour of Granular Materials

The Influence of the Fundamental Parameters on the Mechanical Behavior of Coarse-Grained Soils

Consequences of scalping and scalping/replacement procedures on strength properties of coarse-grained gap-graded soils

Novel Methodology for Determining the Mechanical Characteristics of Coarse-Grained Soils

Evaluation of coarse-grained mechanical properties using small direct shear test

Shear Strength Properties of Coarse-Grained Soils Determined Using Large-Size Direct Shear Test

Numerical Study on the Shear Strength of Granular Materials under the Low Confining Pressure

Influence of Grading on the Undrained Behavior of Granular Materials

Shear Strength of Granular Materials Based on Fractal Fragmentation of Particles

Effect of Initial Density, Particle Shape, and Confining Stress on the Critical State Behavior of Weathered Gap-Graded Granular Soils

Experimental Study on the Reliability of Scaling Down Techniques Used in Direct Shear Tests to Determine the Shear Strength of Rockfill and Waste Rocks

Effect of Gradation on the Strength and Stress-Dilatancy of Coarse-Grained Soils: A Comparison of Monotonic Direct Simple Shear and Triaxial Tests

Determination of the Effect of Soil Particle Size Distribution on the Shear Behavior of Sand

Effect of shear rate and saturation on shear strength of mineral and anthropogenic soil

The influence of particle characteristics on the behaviour of coarse grained soils

Metaheuristic model for the interface shear strength between granular soil and structure considering surface morphology