Abstract:Exchange underpins the magnetic properties of quantum matter. In its most basic form, it occurs through the interplay of Pauli's exclusion principle and Coulomb repulsion, being referred to as Coulomb or direct exchange. Pauli's exclusion principle combined with inter-atomic electron hopping additionally leads to kinetic exchange and superexchange. Here we disentangle the different exchange channels in anisotropic Kitaev–Heisenberg context. By quantum chemical computations, we show that anisotropic Coulomb exchange, completely neglected so far in the field, may be as large as (or even larger than) other contributions — kinetic exchange and superexchange. This opens new perspectives onto anisotropic exchange mechanisms and sets the proper conceptual framework for further research on tuning Kitaev–Heisenberg magnetism.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the exchange mechanism of the Kitaev - Heisenberg model in magnetic materials, especially the origin of symmetric anisotropic magnetic interactions. Specifically, through quantum - chemical calculation methods, the researchers explored the influence of anisotropic Coulomb exchange on Kitaev coupling (\(K\)) and off - diagonal anisotropic coupling (\(\Gamma_0\)) in Ru - based compounds with hexagonal and triangular network structures. ### Main problems: 1. **Origin of Kitaev coupling**: Traditionally, it is believed that Kitaev coupling is mainly contributed by kinetic exchange and superexchange. However, this paper points out that anisotropic Coulomb exchange may be an important but overlooked factor, and its contribution can be even comparable to or greater than that of kinetic exchange and superexchange. 2. **Origin of off - diagonal anisotropic coupling \(\Gamma_0\)**: The off - diagonal anisotropic coupling \(\Gamma_0\) is an interaction that may lead to a spin - liquid ground state. The paper found that the main origin of this coupling is also anisotropic Coulomb exchange, accounting for about 90% of the total effective coupling parameter. ### Research methods: - **Quantum - chemical calculations**: Use single - configuration (SC), multi - configuration self - consistent field (CASSCF), and multi - reference configuration interaction (MRCI) methods to calculate high - symmetry \(\alpha\)-RuCl\(_3\) and NaRuO\(_2\). - **Point - charge embedding**: Use the EWALD package to generate point - charge arrays to simulate the Madelung field in crystals. - **Spin - orbit coupling**: Consider spin - orbit coupling (SOC) in different levels of theoretical calculations to obtain more accurate results. ### Main findings: - **Contribution of Kitaev coupling \(K\)**: The contribution of anisotropic Coulomb exchange to \(K\) is approximately - 1.75 meV, while the contribution of kinetic exchange and superexchange is approximately - 2 meV. - **Contribution of off - diagonal anisotropic coupling \(\Gamma_0\)**: The contribution of anisotropic Coulomb exchange to \(\Gamma_0\) is approximately 0.42 meV, accounting for about 90% of the total effective coupling parameter. - **Redefining the conceptual framework**: These findings challenge the existing views in Kitaev - Heisenberg magnetic research and emphasize the importance of the direct exchange mechanism, especially in understanding and regulating the magnetic properties of these materials. ### Conclusion: Through quantum - chemical calculations, the paper reveals the importance of anisotropic Coulomb exchange in the Kitaev - Heisenberg system, providing a new perspective and theoretical basis for future research. These findings not only help to understand the basic physical mechanisms of these materials but also provide guidance for designing and regulating new materials with specific magnetic properties.

Coulomb exchange as source of Kitaev and off-diagonal symmetric anisotropic couplings

Anisotropic Coulomb exchange as source of Kitaev and off-diagonal symmetric anisotropic couplings

Kitaev-Heisenberg cobaltates: Coulomb exchange as leading nearest-neighbor interaction mechanism

Exchange Anisotropy, Disorder, and Frustration in Diluted, Predominantly Ferromagnetic, Heisenberg Spin Systems

A new microscopic representation of the spin dynamics in quantum systems with the Coulomb exchange interactions

Quantitative theory of magnetic interactions in solids

Anisotropic Exchange Coupling in A Nanowire Double Quantum Dot with Strong Spin-Orbit Coupling

On the Competition Between the Kondo Effect and the Exchange Interaction in a Parallel Double Quantum Dot System

NaRuO$_2$: Kitaev-Heisenberg exchange in triangular-lattice setting

Realization of an Extremely Anisotropic Heisenberg Magnet in Rydberg Atom Arrays

Relativistic magnetic interactions from non-orthogonal basis sets

Quantum exchange symmetry induces charge diffusion and trapping in ultracold gases

Few-body solutions under spin-exchange interaction: magnetic bound state and the Kondo screening effect

Impact of gapped spin-orbit excitons on low energy pseudospin exchange interactions

Physical origin of the anisotropic exchange tensor close to the first-order spin–orbit coupling regime and impact of the electric field on its magnitude

Exchange coupling constants at finite temperature

Phase Transitions in the Classical Exchange-Anisotropic Kitaev-Heisenberg Model

Beyond Kitaev physics in strong spin-orbit coupled magnets

Relevance of Anisotropy in the Kondo Effect -- Lessons From the Symplectic Case

Kinetic energy driven two-sublattice double-exchange: a general mechanism of magnetic exchange in transition metal compounds