NaRuO$_2$: Kitaev-Heisenberg exchange in triangular-lattice setting

Pritam Bhattacharyya,Nikolay A. Bogdanov,Satoshi Nishimoto,Stephen D. Wilson,Liviu Hozoi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41535-023-00582-7

2023-07-03

Abstract:Kitaev exchange, a new paradigm in quantum magnetism research, occurs for 90$^{\circ}$ metal-ligand-metal links, $t_{2g}^5$ transition ions, and sizable spin-orbit coupling. It is being studied in honeycomb compounds but also on triangular lattices. While for the former it is known by now that the Kitaev intersite couplings are ferromagnetic, for the latter the situation is unclear. Here we pin down the exchange mechanisms and determine the effective coupling constants in the $t_{2g}^5$ triangular-lattice material NaRuO$_2$, recently found to host a quantum spin liquid ground state. We show that, compared to honeycomb compounds, the characteristic triangular-lattice cation surroundings dramatically affect exchange paths and effective coupling parameters, changing the Kitaev interactions to antiferromagnetic. The quantum chemical analysis and subsequent effective spin model computations provide perspective onto the nature of the experimentally observed quantum spin liquid -- it seemingly implies finite longer-range exchange, and the atypical proximity to ferromagnetic order is related to sizable ferromagnetic Heisenberg nearest-neighbor couplings.

Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the properties of Kitaev-Heisenberg exchange in the triangular lattice of the NaRuO₂ material. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues:

1. **Sign change of Kitaev interaction**: The study finds that in the triangular lattice material NaRuO₂, the Kitaev interaction is antiferromagnetic, whereas it is typically ferromagnetic in honeycomb lattice materials. The paper attempts to explain the reason for this sign change.

2. **Nearest-neighbor coupling mechanism**: Through quantum chemical calculations, the effective parameters of the nearest-neighbor magnetic coupling in NaRuO₂ (including Kitaev, Heisenberg, and off-diagonal Γ coupling constants) are determined.

3. **Impact of charge distribution**: The paper shows through numerical experiments that nearby positive ions have a significant impact on the magnetic coupling paths and effective parameters. Specifically, the additional positive charge in the triangular lattice causes the Kitaev interaction to change from ferromagnetic to antiferromagnetic.

4. **Realization of quantum spin liquid state**: The study finds that despite the presence of large Heisenberg coupling, NaRuO₂ can still realize a quantum spin liquid state. This requires considering longer-range Heisenberg coupling and higher-order interactions (such as ring exchange).

5. **Electric dipole effect**: The paper points out that the strong orbital polarization effect in the triangular lattice leads to changes in the transition matrix elements and superexchange processes, thereby affecting the magnetic coupling.

Through these studies, the paper provides new perspectives for understanding the magnetic behavior in NaRuO₂ and lays the foundation for future research on more complex magnetic systems.