Abstract:According to the traditional “Size Advantage” (SA) hypothesis, plant species with larger body size are expected to be more successful when competition is intense, that is, within severely crowded vegetation. Recent studies in old‐field habitats, however, have shown that those species with greater numerical abundance as resident plants generally have a relatively small minimum reproductive threshold size (MIN), not a relatively large maximum potential body size (MAX). In this study, we test for a size advantage in terms of species abundance representation in the soil seed bank, and we extend the SA hypothesis to include two additional size metrics: leaf size and seed size. Specifically, we ask, for resident species within a crowded old‐field meadow: is larger seed size, leaf size, and/or body size associated with greater reproductive / recruitment success (i.e. number of germinable seeds within—and establishing plants emerging from—the soil seed bank)? We collected soil cores for a greenhouse experiment to record relative species abundances of germinable seeds in the seed bank, and we used a field experiment to record local abundances of species emerging from the resident seed bank within denuded plant neighbourhoods over three subsequent field seasons. We found no general support for the SA hypothesis involving any of the size metrics, and none of the latter was a strong predictor of the number of germinable seeds emerging from soil cores in the greenhouse experiment. However, for species establishing in the field experiment from the seed bank over the 3‐year survey period, more abundant species in years 2 and 3 tended to be those with smaller MIN, and thus smaller MAX. In addition, within more crowded neighbourhoods, representation of reproductive plants was generally greater for species with relatively small MIN (and hence small MAX). Synthesis. Our results extend the support for the “Reproductive Economy Advantage” hypothesis in old‐field habitats, to include not just established, largely undisturbed vegetation, but also very early stages of recruitment from seed within locally crowded plant neighbourhoods. Specifically, more successful species here are not those with relatively large potential body size (MAX); they are species capable of producing at least some offspring despite severe body size suppression, because they have a relatively small MIN. We summarize our interpretation using a simple conceptual model for predicting selection effects of local neighbourhood crowding on variation in fecundity (fitness estimate) of resident plants, resulting from genetic covariation in MAX and MIN. Relatively large potential body size (MAX) should be expected to promote fitness here, not when competition from near neighbour effects is severe, but when its effects are locally more moderate, or virtually absent—and hence relatively rarely within the generally crowded vegetation of old‐field habitats. Our results extend the support for the “Reproductive Economy Advantage” (REA) hypothesis in old‐field habitats, to include not just established, largely undisturbed vegetation, but also very early stages of recruitment from seed within locally crowded plant neighbourhoods. Specifically, more successful species here are not those with relatively large potential body size (MAX); they are species capable of producing at least some offspring despite severe body size suppression, because they have a relatively small MIN.

Growing or reproducing? Assessing the existence of a trade‐off in the globose cactus Gymnocalycium monvillei

Trade-off dynamics in a rare cactus: What are the demographic consequences of temporal variation in fitness?

Variations in Sexual and Asexual Reproduction of Scirpus Mariqueter along an Elevational Gradient

Size-Dependent Flowering in relation to Grazing in a Short-Lived Monocarpic Perennial

Resident species with larger size metrics do not recruit more offspring from the soil seed bank in old‐field meadow vegetation

High variability and multiple trade‐offs in reproduction and growth of the invasive grass Cortaderia selloana after cutting

Propagule size and seed development duration: high photosynthate allocation and growth allometry

Global patterns in the evolutionary relations between seed mass and germination traits

Limits to reproduction and seed size-number trade-offs that shape forest dominance and future recovery

Allocation of biomass and photoassimilates in juvenile plants of six Patagonian species in response to five water supply regimes

Effects of warming temperatures on germination responses and trade‐offs between seed traits in an alpine plant

Evolutionary trends of reproductive phenotype in Cycadales: an analysis of morphological evolution in Ceratozamia

Insights Into Plant Size-Density Relationships From Models And Agricultural Crops

Trade-off between allocation to reproductive ramets and rhizome buds in Carex brevicuspis populations along a small-scale elevational gradient

Metabolism, Growth, and the Energetic Definition of Fitness: A Quantitative Genetic Study in the Land Snail Cornu aspersum

Measuring Temporal Variation in Reproductive Output Reveals Optimal Resource Allocation to Reproduction in the Northern Grass Lizard, Takydromus Septentrionalis

Geographic variation in growth and reproduction trade‐offs: Implications for future tree performance

A long‐term experiment reveals no trade‐off between seed persistence and seedling emergence

Population size is not a reliable indicator of seed germination

Seed mass diversity along resource gradients: the role of allometric growth rate and size-asymmetric competition

The Generality of Leaf Size Versus Number Trade-off in Temperate Woody Species