Abstract:Because leaf size scales negatively and isometrically with leaf number per shoot size (leafing intensity) in woody species, and because most tree and shrub species have small leaves, Kleiman and Aarssen (J Ecol 95:376–382, 2007 ) recently proposed that natural selection favors high leafing intensity resulting in small leaves, i.e., the leafing-intensity-premium hypothesis. However, empirical evidence for or against this hypothesis is still lacking. In addition, this hypothesis has not been examined in the context of how leaf size varies among habitats. To fill this void, we investigated leaf size frequency distributions of woody species from temperate China and explored the relationships among leaf mass, leaf number, and stem mass of current-year shoots of 133 woody species at low and high altitudes of three mountain ranges. The scaling relationships between leaf size and leafing intensity (leaf number per stem mass) were determined using both standardized major axis regression analyses and phylogenetically independent comparative techniques. In light of the leafing-intensity-premium hypothesis, we made three predictions: (1) leaf size frequency distributions should be right-skewed for each local study area and for the entire study region, (2) leafing intensities at different altitudes at different sites should differ while leafing intensities at comparable altitudes should be similar baring large taxonomic differences among sites, and (3) that leafing intensity should be higher for any given leaf size in habitats with small-leaved species. Significant negative and isometric scaling relationships between leaf size and leafing intensity were found to be consistently conserved independent of habitat type, both across species and across correlated evolutionary divergences. Within each mountain range or across the entire study region, leaf size frequency distributions were right-skewed, in accordance with our prediction. However, leafing intensity was smaller for any given leaf size at the altitude with smaller leafed species than for altitudes characterized by large leafed species, i.e., altitudes characterized by species with small leaves did not have consistently higher leafing intensities than other altitudes on each mountain range. Our analyses therefore indicate the direct adaptive value of leaf size but not the selective advantage in high leafing intensity as posited by the leafing-intensity-premium hypothesis. We suggest that this hypothesis explains less about the variation of leaf size among different habitats as it does about variation within habitats, i.e., the relative importance of the adaptive significance of leafing intensity and leaf size can and does vary with habitats.

The Generality of Leaf Size Versus Number Trade-off in Temperate Woody Species

Isometric Scaling Relationship Between Leaf Number and Size Within Current-Year Shoots of Woody Species Across Contrasting Habitats

Testing the generality of the ‘leafing intensity premium’ hypothesis in temperate broad-leaved forests: a survey of variation in leaf size within and between habitats

Effects of ontogenetic stage and leaf age on leaf functional traits and the relationships between traits in Pinus koraiensis

The underlying basis for the trade‐off between leaf size and leafing intensity

STUDIES ON THE LEAF SIZE-TWIG SIZE SPECTRUM OF SUBTROPICAL EVERGREEN BOARD-LEAVED WOODY SPECIES

The Effects of Leaf Size, Leaf Habit, and Leaf Form on Leaf/Stem Relationships in Plant Twigs of Temperate Woody Species

Trade-Offs Between The Metabolic Rate And Population Density Of Plants

Scaling Relationships Between Leaf Mass and Total Plant Mass Across Chinese Forests

Size-dependent Variations in Individual Traits and Trait Scaling Relationships Within a Shade-Tolerant Evergreen Treespecies

Size-dependent Leaf Area Ratio in Plant Twigs: Implication for Leaf Size Optimization.

Taxonomic, Phylogenetic, and Environmental Trade-Offs Between Leaf Productivity and Persistence

Influence of tree size on the scaling relationships of lamina and petiole traits: A case study using Camptotheca acuminata Decne

Functional Relationships of Leafing Intensity to Plant Height, Growth Form and Leaf Habit

Twig–leaf size relationships in woody plants vary intraspecifically along a soil moisture gradient

The "Leafing Intensity Premium" Hypothesis and the Scaling Relationships of the Functional Traits of Bamboo Species

Predicting vegetation type through physiological and environmental interactions with leaf traits: evergreen and deciduous forests in an earth system modeling framework

Effects of succession stages and altitudinal gradient on leaf surface area and biomass allocation of typical plants in the subalpine of Eastern Tibetan Plateau

The Scaling Relationships Between Leaf Mass And Leaf Area Of Vascular Plant Species Change With Altitude

Allometric relationships between lamina area, lamina mass and petiole mass of 93 temperate woody species vary with leaf habit, leaf form and altitude

Insights Into Plant Size-Density Relationships From Models And Agricultural Crops