Abstract:The increasing availability of longitudinal student achievement data has heightened interest among researchers, educators and policy makers in using these data to evaluate educational inputs, as well as for school and possibly teacher accountability. Researchers have developed elaborate "value-added models" of these longitudinal data to estimate the effects of educational inputs (e.g., teachers or schools) on student achievement while using prior achievement to adjust for nonrandom assignment of students to schools and classes. A challenge to such modeling efforts is the extensive numbers of students with incomplete records and the tendency for those students to be lower achieving. These conditions create the potential for results to be sensitive to violations of the assumption that data are missing at random, which is commonly used when estimating model parameters. The current study extends recent value-added modeling approaches for longitudinal student achievement data Lockwood et al. [J. Educ. Behav. Statist. 32 (2007) 125--150] to allow data to be missing not at random via random effects selection and pattern mixture models, and applies those methods to data from a large urban school district to estimate effects of elementary school mathematics teachers. We find that allowing the data to be missing not at random has little impact on estimated teacher effects. The robustness of estimated teacher effects to the missing data assumptions appears to result from both the relatively small impact of model specification on estimated student effects compared with the large variability in teacher effects and the downweighting of scores from students with incomplete data.

The Effect of the Prior Teacher on Value-Added

Teacher Value-Added at the High-School Level

An Evaluation of Empirical Bayes’s Estimation of Value-Added Teacher Performance Measures

Missing data in value-added modeling of teacher effects

Value-Added Modeling and Educational Accountability

A Correlated Random Effects Model for Nonignorable Missing Data in Value-Added Assessment of Teacher Effects

Teacher value-added and gender gaps in educational outcomes

A Potential Outcomes View of Value-Added Assessment in Education

Do First Impressions Matter? Predicting Early Career Teacher Effectiveness

Teacher-Level Value-Added Models on Trial: Empirical and Pragmatic Issues of Concern Across Five Court Cases

A Florida Teacher Wrongfully Terminated? Alleged (Mis)Uses of Value-Added Model (VAM) Estimates for High-Stakes Teacher Evaluation Decisions

A comparison of value-added models for school accountability

Making the grade: The effect of teacher grading standards on student outcomes

NEW EVIDENCE ON NATIONAL BOARD CERTIFICATION AS A SIGNAL OF TEACHER QUALITY

Rethinking principal effects on student outcomes

The Short- and the Long-Run Impact of Gender-Biased Teachers

Accounting for Co-Teaching: A Guide for Policymakers and Developers of Value-Added Models

Teacher-to-Classroom Assignment and Student Achievement

Accounting for Student Disadvantage in Value-Added Models

Front End to Back End: Teacher Preparation, Workforce Entry, and Attrition

Teacher and Classroom Context Effects on Student Achievement: Implications for Teacher Evaluation