Effect of Yoga on Sleep Quality among Adult Cancer Patients: A Systematic Review Protocol
Gina Alexander,Suzy Lockwood
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11124/jbisrir-2013-612
2013-01-01
JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports
Abstract:Review question/objective The objective of this review is to identify the effectiveness of yoga practice on sleep quality. More specifically, the objective is to identify the effectiveness of yoga practice in adult cancer patients over the age of 18 who are concurrently undergoing conventional treatment for cancer. The specific review question is: What is the effect of yoga practice on sleep quality in adult cancer patients over the age of 18 who are concurrently undergoing conventional treatment for cancer? Background Although research and technological advances have fostered improvement in the biomedical care delivered to cancer patients, achievements in the care of psychological and social needs faced throughout the cancer experience have not been realized.1 These psychosocial needs stem from lack of information regarding diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment plans; emotional strain and uncertainty; lack of transportation to clinical appointments; disruptions in daily life, including work, school, and family dynamics; and inadequate financial resources to meet the demands of therapy and follow‐up recommendations.1 The cumulative effect of these stressors has a negative impact on sleep patterns, contributing significantly to the poor sleep quality often reported by cancer patients.2‐9 The importance of sleep for optimal healing and recovery of cancer patients cannot be overstated, as indicated in a recent review regarding the experience of sleep‐wake disturbances reported by adults with cancer.7 Specific concerns described by these patients included difficulty falling asleep, premature awakenings, nonrestorative sleep, daytime drowsiness, and persistent fatigue. A recent epidemiologic investigation of the health of cancer survivors one year following diagnosis revealed a significant correlation between insomnia and increased risk of death and loss to follow‐up.10 Given the effects of insomnia on psychosocial indicators (quality of life and mood, among others), cancer patients consider diminished sleep quality one of the most distressing symptoms they face, particularly when sleep disturbances interfere with the management of other symptoms and persist after treatment. 11 In the midst of treatment and recovery, some individuals turn to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) to relieve recalcitrant symptoms and to enhance overall well‐being. Recent population estimates indicate that among patients diagnosed with cancer, over 39% of those in the United States and 35.9% of those in Europe have used CAM.12,13 CAM consists of a number of therapeutic formats, ranging from whole systems to herbal treatments to mind‐body therapies.14 The practice of yoga is a form of mind‐body therapy, in which the power of concentrated thought and mindfulness triggers a hormonal and immunological response, evoking a state of motor and emotional arousal with associated powerful effects on the body.14‐15 Core components of yoga include meditation, physical postures (asanas), and breathing exercises (pranayama) designed to promote mental, physical, and spiritual well‐being.15 As a framework for understanding the therapeutic mechanisms of yoga, the field of psychoneuroimmunology (PNI) emphasizes the dynamic physiological impact of emotions on the immune response.16‐19 As posited by the PNI framework, the nervous, immune, and endocrine systems are intricately interconnected.20 The cumulative effect of negative emotions and chronic stress stimulate the sympathetic nervous system, causing an increased circulation of stress hormones and impairing the body's ability to heal and function normally.21 This cascade of events places individuals at greater risk for developing inflammatory patterns of dysfunction and disease.22 Interventions that induce relaxation, positive emotion, and overall well‐being diminish the activation of the sympathetic nervous system, thereby alleviating the effects of stress, fostering a return to hormonal balance, and minimizing the inflammatory response.23 Previous research among individuals with cancer suggests that the practice of yoga yields a range of mental and physical benefits, such as improved quality of life; reduced fatigue, stress, and depression; and enhanced physical function. 24‐30 Although evidence suggests that yoga practice may lead to improved sleep quality among individuals with cancer,31‐33 no systematic review examining the effect of yoga practice on sleep quality among adult cancer patients was identified by initial searches of the Cochrane Library of Systematic Reviews, JBI Library of Reviews, CRD DARE database, CRD PROSPERO database, or other bibliographic databases, such as EMBASE, CINAHL, PubMed/MEDLINE. The proposed systematic review will contribute to the understanding of the effect of yoga practice on adult cancer patients undergoing treatment and will also identify areas for further research.