Scientific and technological analysis of newly discovered ochre from dushan cave site in guangxi
LI Dawei,ZHANG Shangxin,WANG Wei,WANG Chaowen,YIN Ke,LIAO Wei,REN Xiaolei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11928/j.issn.1001-7410.2023.01.23
2023-01-01
Abstract:Since only a few studies have been done in Southern China about ochre use during the Paleolithic,making the judgement of human behavioral modernity based on symbolic characteristics in East Asia ambiguous.The present research is expected to break this deadlock.Different from the old methods assuming some red-colored rocks as ochre samples,this study will employ various scientific methods on several newly discovered ochre samples unearthed in the Dushan cave site.The Dushan cave site （23°30’80″N,107°80’55″E） is located at the Linfeng Town,Tiandong County,Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region in South China.The site was investigated and excavated by the Natural History Museum of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region in 2010.The Dushan cave has one main chamber with a northwestfacing entrance.The cave is 30 m in length and 9 m in width（the widest part）.The excavated area was near the entrance and located at the middle part of the gallery,with 3.15 m×1.80 m,to a maximum depth of 1.9 m.In total,four new pieces of ochre materials were found,all unearthed from the third layer,which is dated to about15000 years ago based on radiocarbon dates of the associated charcoal samples.Combined with the assemblage characteristics of the third layer shown by lithics and other evidence,the pieces of ochre at the Dushan cave site is categorized into the late Paleolithic.Four kinds of scientific methods are applied in the present research,including X-ray fluorescence （XRF）analysis,X-ray diffraction（XRD） analysis,as well as polarized light microscopic analysis and Raman analysis.Results of XRF analysis showed that the contents of Fe and Si were high in the chemical composition of the samples,and they indeed contained Fe.Results of XRD analysis showed that the samples contained quartz,chlorite,illite,kaolinite and hematite.Results of polarized light microscopic analysis showed that all samples were real red ochre（oxide red）,and the sample is dark red under single polarizing light,with rounded edges.It is completely extincted under orthogonal slice light and has a large refractive index.The results showed that all ochre samples were mainly the iron red.Results of Raman analysis suggested that the peak values of all samples were consistent with ochre,the peak values were mainly concentrated around 223 cm-1,295 cm-1,408 cm-1and 605 cm-1.Generally speaking,the main components of the ochre samples found at the the third layer were the iron red pigments,and no other red pigments were found.To be summarized,the analyses of newly discovered ochre materials from the Dushan cave site not only provide a basis for applying the scientific methods to study late Paleolithic ochre in China,but also give hands to evaluate reliability of naked-eye identification of ochre（-like） materials.The use of ochre is one of the signs of modern human symbolic behavior,suggesting their cognitive ability and other deep-seated spiritual capacity,which can be complementary to other evidence of behavioral modernity,such as innovation of lithic technology,structure building techniques,and effective hunting strategies.The present research is expected to serve as a cornerstone to study ochre using in the Southern China with the aid of scientific methods.