Comparative study of image quality and radiation dose of cone beam and low-dose multislice computed tomography - an in-vitro investigation

E. Hofmann,M. Schmid,M. Sedlmair,R. Banckwitz,U. Hirschfelder,M. Lell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00784-013-0948-9

2013-03-05

Clinical Oral Investigations

Abstract:

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

[Comparative Dosimetry of Dental Cone-Beam Computed Tomography and Multi-Slice Computed Tomography for Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology].

Xing-min Qu,Gang Li,Zu-yan Zhang,Xu-chen Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1002-0098.2011.10.006

2011-01-01

Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To compare the effective radiation dose levels of cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) with those of multi-slice computed tomography (MSCT) when scanning the same maxillofacial regions.METHODS:The effective doses of 2 CBCT (NewTom 9000 and DCT Pro) and 1 MSCT (bright speed edge select 8 slice) scanners were calculated using thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLD) that were placed in a head and neck phantom, and expressed according to the International Commission on Radiation Protection (ICRP) 2007 guidelines.RESULTS:Effective dose values ranged from 41.8 to 249.1 µSv for CBCT. The doses of MSCT scanning for maxilla, mandible and maxilla + mandible were 506.7, 829.9 and 1066.1 µSv, respectively. Dose levels of scanning only for maxilla or mandible were significantly lower than those for maxilla + mandible.CONCLUSIONS:When scanning the same maxillofacial regions, the dose levels for NewTom 9000 and DCT Pro CBCT images were lower than those for Bright speed edge select 8 slice MSCT images. Dose levels reduction could be obtained when smaller regions were scanned.
A comprehensive study on the relationship between image quality and imaging dose in low-dose cone beam CT

Hao Yan,Laura Cervino,Xun Jia,Steve B. Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0031-9155/57/7/2063

2012-01-28

Abstract:While compressed sensing (CS) based reconstructions have been developed for low-dose CBCT, a clear understanding on the relationship between the image quality and imaging dose at low dose levels is needed. In this paper, we qualitatively investigate this subject in a comprehensive manner with extensive experimental and simulation studies. The basic idea is to plot image quality and imaging dose together as functions of number of projections and mAs per projection over the whole clinically relevant range. A clear understanding on the tradeoff between image quality and dose can be achieved and optimal low-dose CBCT scan protocols can be developed for various imaging tasks in IGRT. Main findings of this work include: 1) Under the CS framework, image quality has little degradation over a large dose range, and the degradation becomes evident when the dose < 100 total mAs. A dose < 40 total mAs leads to a dramatic image degradation. Optimal low-dose CBCT scan protocols likely fall in the dose range of 40-100 total mAs, depending on the specific IGRT applications. 2) Among different scan protocols at a constant low-dose level, the super sparse-view reconstruction with projection number less than 50 is the most challenging case, even with strong regularization. Better image quality can be acquired with other low mAs protocols. 3) The optimal scan protocol is the combination of a medium number of projections and a medium level of mAs/view. This is more evident when the dose is around 72.8 total mAs or below and when the ROI is a low-contrast or high-resolution object. Based on our results, the optimal number of projections is around 90 to 120. 4) The clinically acceptable lowest dose level is task dependent. In our study, 72.8mAs is a safe dose level for visualizing low-contrast objects, while 12.2 total mAs is sufficient for detecting high-contrast objects of diameter greater than 3 mm.

Medical Physics
Dental Imaging in Clinical Photon-Counting CT at a Quarter of DVT Dose

Stefan Sawall,Joscha Maier,Sinan Sen,Holger Gehrig,Ti-Sun Kim,Heinz-Peter Schlemmer,Stefan O. Schönberg,Marc Kachelrieß,Maurice Rütters

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2024.104859

IF: 4.991

2024-01-25

Journal of Dentistry

Abstract:Objective To investigate the image quality of a low-dose dental imaging protocol in the first clinical photon-counting computed tomography (PCCT) system in comparison to a normal-dose acquisition in a digital volume tomography (DVT) system. Materials and Methods Clinical PCCT systems offer an increased spatial resolution compared to previous generations of clinical systems. Their spatial resolution is in the order of dental DVT systems. Resolution-matched acquisitions of ten porcine jaws were performed in a PCCT (Naeotom Alpha, Siemens Healthineers) and in a DVT (Orthophos XL, Dentsply Sirona). PCCT images were acquired with 90 kV at a dose of 1 mGy CTDI 16cm . DVT used 85 kV at 4 mGy. Image reconstruction was performed using the standard algorithms of each system to a voxel size of 160 × 160 × 200 μm. The dose-normalized contrast-to-noise ratio (CNRD) was measured between dentine and enamel and dentine and bone. Two readers evaluated overall diagnostic quality of images and quality of relevant structures such as root channels and dentine. Results CNRD is higher in all PCCT acquisitions. CNRD is 37% higher for the contrast dentine-enamel and 31% higher for the dentine-bone contrast (p<0.05). Overall diagnostic image quality was higher for PCCT over DVT (p<0.02 and p<0.04 for readers 1 and 2). Quality scores for anatomical structures were higher in PCCT compared to DVT (all p 0.64). Conclusions PCCT provides an increased image quality over DVT even at a lower dose level and might enable complex dental imaging protocols in the future. Clinical Significance The evolution of photon-counting technology and it's optimization will increasingly move dental imaging towards standardized 3D visualizations providing both minimal radiation exposure and high diagnostic accuracy.

dentistry, oral surgery & medicine
Cone Beam CT vs. Fan Beam CT: A Comparison of Image Quality and Dose Delivered Between Two Differing CT Imaging Modalities

Lawrence Lechuga,Georg A. Weidlich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.778

2016-09-12

Cureus

Abstract:A comparison of image quality and dose delivered between two differing computed tomography (CT) imaging modalities-fan beam and cone beam-was performed. A literature review of quantitative analyses for various image quality aspects such as uniformity, signal-to-noise ratio, artifact presence, spatial resolution, modulation transfer function (MTF), and low contrast resolution was generated. With these aspects quantified, cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) shows a superior spatial resolution to that of fan beam, while fan beam shows a greater ability to produce clear and anatomically correct images with better soft tissue differentiation. The results indicate that fan beam CT produces superior images to that of on-board imaging (OBI) cone beam CT systems, while providing a considerably less dose to the patient.
Cranial Computer Tomography with Photon Counting and Energy-Integrated Detectors: Objective Comparison in the Same Patients

Klempka,Schröder,Neumayer,Groden,Clausen,Hetjens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics14101019

IF: 3.6

2024-05-16

Diagnostics

Abstract:This study provides an objective comparison of cranial computed tomography (CT) imaging quality and radiation dose between photon counting detectors (PCCTs) and energy-integrated detectors (EIDs). We retrospectively analyzed 158 CT scans from 82 patients, employing both detector types on the same individuals to ensure a consistent comparison. Our analysis focused on the Computed Tomography Dose Index and the Dose-Length Product together with the contrast-to-noise ratio and the signal-to-noise ratio for brain gray and white matter. We utilized standardized imaging protocols and consistent patient positioning to minimize variables. PCCT showed a potential for higher image quality and lower radiation doses, as highlighted by this study, thus achieving diagnostic clarity with reduced radiation exposure, underlining its significance in patient care, particularly for patients requiring multiple scans. The results demonstrated that while both systems were effective, PCCT offered enhanced imaging and patient safety in neuroradiological evaluations.

medicine, general & internal
SU‐E‐J‐07: A Preliminary Study on Optimal Dose‐Allocation Parameters for Low‐Dose Cone‐Beam CT

zhen zhang,xiaobing han,ewan r pearson,jianguo bian,emil y sidky,charles a pelizzari,xiaochuan pan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1118/1.3611775

IF: 4.506

2011-01-01

Medical Physics

Abstract:Purpose: Cone‐beam CT(CBCT) is widely used for providing image guidance in radiotherapy and interventional procedures. Due to the patient safety concern involved in repetitive CBCT scans, significant effort has been devoted to possibly lowering imagingdose in CBCT. For a given total dose, it is also important to investigate how image quality can be affected by dose allocations over projection views and by image‐reconstruction algorithms. In this work, we investigate quantitatively how image quality changes resulted from different combinations of dose‐allocation parameters and some existing reconstruction algorithms. Methods: We performed simulation studies by using a numerical phantom containing structures ofdifferent contrast levels. We also acquired real data of a Catphan phantom (The Phantom Laboratory, Salem, NY) by using the on‐board imaging system (Varian Medical Systems, Palo Alto, CA). At three different total dose levels, we allocated each of them to different numbers of views ranging from 120 to 650. For each allocation scheme we applied the FDK and ASD‐POCS algorithms to obtain reconstructed images. A set of quantitative metrics were used to evaluate image quality based on relevant tasks. Results: Preliminary results showed that for total dose levels under study, both FDK and ASD‐POCS algorithms yield images with comparable quality when a large number of views are considered and that imagesreconstructed by the ASD‐POCS from smaller number of views generally exhibit higher quality. Overall, for each given total dose level the ASD‐POCS algorithm yields images of comparable or higher quality than does the FDK algorithm. Conclusions: We demonstrated that CBCTimage quality can be optimized for a fixed total dose by choosing an appropriate combination of dose‐ allocation parameters and reconstruction algorithm. This finding may potentially be used for improving current CBCTimage quality and for designing innovative, low‐dose CBCTimaging protocols.
Iterative reconstruction for image enhancement and dose reduction in diagnostic cone beam CT imaging.

D. Matenine,M. Schmittbuhl,J. D. De Guise,P. Després,S. Bedwani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3233/XST-190523

Journal of X-Ray Science and Technology

Abstract:BACKGROUND Iterative reconstruction is well-established in diagnostic multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) for dose reduction and image quality enhancement. Its application to diagnostic cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) is only emerging and warrants a quantitative evaluation. METHODS Several phantoms and a canine head specimen were imaged using a commercially available small-field CBCT scanner. Raw projection data were reconstructed using the Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK) method with different filters, including denoising via total variation (TV) minimization (FDK-TV). Iterative reconstruction was carried out using the TV-regularized ordered subsets convex technique (OSC-TV). Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), noise power spectrum (NPS) and spatial resolution of images were estimated. Dose levels were measured via the weighted computed tomography dose index, while low-dose image quality degradation was estimated via structural similarity (SSIM). RESULTS OSC-TV and FDK-TV were shown to significantly improve image signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) compared to FDK with a standard filter, 5.8 and 4.0 times, respectively. Spatial resolution attained with different algorithms varied moderately across different experiments. For low-dose acquisitions, image quality decreased dramatically for FDK but not for FDK-TV nor OSC-TV. For low-dose canine head images acquired using about 1/5 of the dose compared to a reference image, SSIM dropped to about 0.3 for FDK, while remaining at 0.92 for FDK-TV and 0.96 for OSC-TV. CONCLUSION OSC-TV was shown to improve image quality compared to FDK and FDK-TV. Moreover, this iterative approach allowed for significant dose reduction while maintaining image quality.

Medicine,Mathematics,Engineering
Investigation Of Low-Contrast Tumor Detection In Algorithm-Enabled Low-Dose Cbct

Junguo Bian,Xiao Han,Emil Y. Sidky,Jeffrey H. Siewerdsen,Xiaochuan Pan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/NSSMIC.2010.5874453

2010-01-01

Abstract:Flat-panel-based X-ray cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) can provide images of high utility in medical applications such as image-guided surgery and radiotherapy by offering location and contrast information concerning the target and surrounding region. A potential issue in these applications of CBCT is the imaging dose involved because repeated scans are necessary in the image-guided procedures. We investigate algorithm-enabled low-dose CBCT imaging for potential applications to image-guided surgery and radiotherapy procedures, involving detection of low-contrast tumor structures from sparse-view CBCT. Results of our study suggest that images of quality comparable to that of the FDK-reference image can be reconstructed from data much less than full data currently used.
Low-Dose High-Resolution Photon-Counting CT of the Lung: Radiation Dose and Image Quality in the Clinical Routine

Matthias Michael Woeltjen,Julius Henning Niehoff,Arwed Elias Michael,Sebastian Horstmeier,Christoph Moenninghoff,Jan Borggrefe,Jan Robert Kroeger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics12061441

IF: 3.6

2022-06-11

Diagnostics

Abstract:This study aims to investigate the qualitative and quantitative image quality of low-dose high-resolution (LD-HR) lung CT scans acquired with the first clinical approved photon counting CT (PCCT) scanner. Furthermore, the radiation dose used by the PCCT is compared to a conventional CT scanner with an energy-integrating detector system (EID-CT). Twenty-nine patients who underwent a LD-HR chest CT scan with dual-source PCCT and had previously undergone a LD-HR chest CT with a standard EID-CT scanner were retrospectively included in this study. Images of the whole lung as well as enlarged image sections displaying a specific finding (lesion) were evaluated in terms of overall image quality, image sharpness and image noise by three senior radiologists using a 5-point Likert scale. The PCCT images were reconstructed with and without a quantum iterative reconstruction algorithm (PCCT QIR+/−). Noise and signal-to-noise (SNR) were measured and the effective radiation dose was calculated. Overall, image quality and image sharpness were rated best in PCCT (QIR+) images. A significant difference was seen particularly in image sections of PCCT (QIR+) images compared to EID-CT images (p < 0.005). Image noise of PCCT (QIR+) images was significantly lower compared to EID-CT images in image sections (p = 0.005). In contrast, noise was lowest on EID-CT images (p < 0.001). The PCCT used significantly less radiation dose compared to the EID-CT (p < 0.001). In conclusion, LD-HR PCCT scans of the lung provide better image quality while using significantly less radiation dose compared to EID-CT scans.

medicine, general & internal
Image quality evaluation of dual-layer spectral detector CT of the chest and comparison with conventional CT imaging

Jonas Doerner,Myriam Hauger,Tilman Hickethier,Jonathan Byrtus,Christian Wybranski,Nils Große Hokamp,David Maintz,Stefan Haneder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.05.016

IF: 4.531

2017-08-01

European Journal of Radiology

Abstract:OBJECTIVES: To evaluate image quality parameters of virtual mono-energetic (MonoE) and conventional (CR) imaging derived from a dual-layer spectral detector CT (DLCT) in oncological follow-up venous phase imaging of the chest and comparison with conventional multi-detector CT (CRMDCT) imaging.MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 55 patients who had oncologic staging with conventional CT and DLCT of the chest in venous phase were included in this study. Established image quality parameters were derived from all datasets in defined thoracic landmarks. Attenuation, image noise, and signal-/contrast- to noise ratios (SNR, CNR) were compared between CRDLCT and MonoE as well as CRMDCT imaging. Two readers performed subjective image analysis.RESULTS: CRMDCT showed significant lower attenuation values compared to CRDLCT and MonoE at 40-70keV (p≤0.05). Moreover, MonoE at 40-70keV revealed significantly higher attenuations values compared to CRDLCT (p<0.001). Noise was statistically lower in CRMDCT compared with CRDLCT and MonoE at 40keV (11.4±2.3 HU vs. 12.0±3.1 HU vs. 11.7±5.2 HU; p<0.001). In contrast, all MonoE levels showed significantly lower noise levels compared to CRDLCT (p<0.001). SNR was not significantly different between CRMDCT and CRDLCT (13.5±3.7 vs. 14.4±5.3; p>0.99). SNR values were significantly increased for MonoE at 40-80keV compared to CRMDCT and CRDLCT (p<0.001). CRDLCT and MonoE (40-70keV) from DLCT revealed significantly higher CNR values than CRMDCT (p<0.001). In subjective analysis, MonoE at 40keV surpassed all other image reconstructions except for noise in MonoE at 70 keV.CONCLUSION: In dual-layer spectral detector CT, MonoE at low keV showed superior image quality compared to conventional images derived from the same system and may therefore be added to clinical routine imaging protocols. Whether MonoE reconstructions yield additional diagnostic information is still unknown.

radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Thin slice photon‐counting CT coronary angiography compared to conventional CT: Objective image quality and clinical radiation dose assessment

Judith van der Bie,Daniel Bos,Marcel L. Dijkshoorn,Ronald Booij,Ricardo P. J. Budde,Marcel van Straten

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/mp.16992

IF: 4.506

2024-02-16

Medical Physics

Abstract:Background Photon‐counting CT (PCCT) is the next‐generation CT scanner that enables improved spatial resolution and spectral imaging. For full spectral processing, higher tube voltages compared to conventional CT are necessary to achieve the required spectral separation. This generated interest in the potential influence of thin slice high tube voltage PCCT on overall image quality and consequently on radiation dose. Purpose This study first evaluated tube voltages and radiation doses applied in patients who underwent coronary CT angiography with PCCT and energy‐integrating detector CT (EID‐CT). Next, image quality of PCCT and EID‐CT was objectively evaluated in a phantom study simulating different patient sizes at these tube voltages and radiation doses. Methods We conducted a retrospective analysis of clinical doses of patients scanned on a conventional and PCCT system. Average patient water equivalent diameters for different tube voltages were extracted from the dose reports for both EID‐CT and PCCT. A conical phantom made of polyethylene with multiple diameters (26/31/36 cm) representing different patient sizes and containing an iodine insert was scanned with a EID‐CT scanner using tube voltages and phantom diameters that match the patient scans and characteristics. Next, phantom scans were made with PCCT at a fixed tube voltage of 120 kV and with CTDIVOL values and phantom diameters identical to the EID‐CT scans. Clinical image reconstructions at 0.6 mm slice thickness for conventional CT were compared to PCCT images with 0.4 mm slice thickness. Image quality was quantified using the detectability index (d′), which estimated the visibility of a 3 mm diameter contrast‐enhanced coronary artery by considering noise, contrast, resolution, and human visual perception. Alongside d′, noise, contrast and resolution were also individually assessed. In addition, the influence of various kernels (Bv40/Bv44/Bv48/Bv56), quantum iterative reconstruction strengths (QIR, 3/4) and monoenergetic levels (40/45/50/55 keV) for PCCT on d′ was investigated. Results In this study, 143 patients were included: 47 were scanned on PCCT (120 kV) and the remaining on EID‐CT (74 small‐sized at 70 kV, 18 medium‐sized at 80 kV and four large‐sized at 90 kV). EID‐CT showed 7%–17% higher d′ than PCCT with Bv40 kernel and strength four for small/medium patients. Lower monoenergetic images (40 keV) helped mitigate the difference to 1%–6%. For large patients, PCCT's detectability was up to 31% higher than EID‐CT. PCCT has thinner slices but similar noise levels for similar reconstruction parameters. The noise increased with lower keV levels in PCCT (≈30% increase), but higher QIR strengths reduced noise. PCCT's iodine contrast was stable across patient sizes, while EID‐CT had 33% less contrast in large patients than in small‐sized patients. Conclusion At 120 kV, thin slice PCCT enables CCTA in phantom scans representing large patients without raising radiation dose or affecting vessel detectability. However, higher doses are needed for small and medium‐sized patients to obtain a similar image quality as in EID‐CT. The alternative of using lower mono‐energetic levels requires further evaluation in clinical practice.

radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Simulated Radiation Dose Reduction in Whole-Body CT on a 3rd Generation Dual-Source Scanner: An Intraindividual Comparison

Andreas S. Brendlin,Moritz T. Winkelmann,Phuong Linh,Vincent Schwarze,Felix Peisen,Haidara Almansour,Malte N. Bongers,Christoph P. Artzner,Jakob Weiss,Jong Hyo Kim,Ahmed E. Othman,Saif Afat,Phuong Linh Do

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics11010118

IF: 3.6

2021-01-13

Diagnostics

Abstract:To evaluate the effect of radiation dose reduction on image quality and diagnostic confidence in contrast-enhanced whole-body computed tomography (WBCT) staging. We randomly selected March 2016 for retrospective inclusion of 18 consecutive patients (14 female, 60 ± 15 years) with clinically indicated WBCT staging on the same 3rd generation dual-source CT. Using low-dose simulations, we created data sets with 100, 80, 60, 40, and 20% of the original radiation dose. Each set was reconstructed using filtered back projection (FBP) and Advanced Modeled Iterative Reconstruction (ADMIRE®, Siemens Healthineers, Forchheim, Germany) strength 1–5, resulting in 540 datasets total. ADMIRE 2 was the reference standard for intraindividual comparison. The effective radiation dose was calculated using commercially available software. For comparison of objective image quality, noise assessments of subcutaneous adipose tissue regions were performed automatically using the software. Three radiologists blinded to the study evaluated image quality and diagnostic confidence independently on an equidistant 5-point Likert scale (1 = poor to 5 = excellent). At 100%, the effective radiation dose in our population was 13.3 ± 9.1 mSv. At 20% radiation dose, it was possible to obtain comparably low noise levels when using ADMIRE 5 (p = 1.000, r = 0.29). We identified ADMIRE 3 at 40% radiation dose (5.3 ± 3.6 mSv) as the lowest achievable radiation dose with image quality and diagnostic confidence equal to our reference standard (p = 1.000, r > 0.4). The inter-rater agreement for this result was almost perfect (ICC ≥ 0.958, 95% CI 0.909–0.983). On a 3rd generation scanner, it is feasible to maintain good subjective image quality, diagnostic confidence, and image noise in single-energy WBCT staging at dose levels as low as 40% of the original dose (5.3 ± 3.6 mSv), when using ADMIRE 3.

medicine, general & internal
Visualization of bone details in a novel photon-counting dual-source CT scanner—comparison with energy-integrating CT

Stefanie J. Bette,Franziska M. Braun,Mark Haerting,Josua A. Decker,Jan H. Luitjens,Christian Scheurig-Muenkler,Thomas J. Kroencke,Florian Schwarz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-021-08441-4

IF: 7.034

2021-12-22

European Radiology

Abstract:Abstract Objectives Photon-counting detector CT (PCD-CT) promises a leap in spatial resolution due to smaller detector pixel sizes than implemented in energy-integrating detector CTs (EID-CT). Our objective was to compare the visualization of smallest bone details between PCD-CT and EID-CT using a mouse as a specimen. Materials and methods Two euthanized mice were scanned at a 20-slice EID-CT and a dual-source PCD-CT in single-pixel mode at various CTDI Vol values. Image noise and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) were evaluated using repeated ROI measurements. Edge sharpness of bones was compared by the maximal slope within CT value plots along sampling lines intersecting predefined bones of the spine. Two readers evaluated bone detail visualization at four regions of the spine on a three-point Likert scale at various CTDI Vol ’s. Two radiologists selected the series with better detail visualization among each of 20 SNR-matched pairs of EID-CT and PCD-CT series. Results In CTDI Vol -matched scans, PCD-CT series showed significantly lower image noise (Noise CTDI = 5 mGy : 16.27 ± 1.39 vs. 23.46 ± 0.96 HU, p < 0.01), higher SNR (SNR CTDI = 5 mGy : 20.57 ± 1.89 vs. 14.00 ± 0.66, p < 0.01), and higher edge sharpness (Edge Slope lumbar spine : 981 ± 160 vs. 608 ± 146 HU/mm, p < 0.01) than EID-CT series. Two radiologists considered the delineation of bone details as feasible at consistently lower CTDI Vol values at PCD-CT than at EID-CT. In comparison of SNR-matched reconstructions, PCD-CT series were still considered superior in almost all cases. Conclusions In this head-to-head comparison, PCD-CT showed superior objective and subjective image quality characteristics over EID-CT for the delineation of tiniest bone details. Even in SNR-matched pairs (acquired at different CTDI Vol ’s), PCD-CT was strongly preferred by radiologists. Key Points • In dose-matched scans, photon-counting detector CT series showed significantly less image noise, higher signal-to-noise ratio, and higher edge sharpness than energy-integrating detector CT series . • Human observers considered the delineation of tiny bone details as feasible at much lower dose levels in photon-counting detector CT than in energy-integrating detector CT . • In direct comparison of series matched for signal-to-noise ratio, photon-counting detector CT series were considered superior in almost all cases .

radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Task-based image quality evaluation of iterative reconstruction methods for low dose CT using computer simulations

Yang Chen,Zhou Yang,Yining Hu,Guanyu Yang,Yongcheng Zhu,Yinsheng Li,Limin luo,Wufan Chen,Christine Toumoulin

2012-01-01

Abstract:The x-ray exposure to patients has become a major concern in computed tomography (CT) and minimizing the radiation exposure has been one of the major efforts in the CT field. Due to plenty high-attenuation tissues in the human chest, under low-dose scan protocols, thoracic low-dose CT (LDCT) images tend to be severely degraded by excessive mottled noise and non-stationary streak artifacts. Their removal is rather a challenging task because the streak artifacts with directional prominence are often hard to discriminate from the attenuation information of normal tissues. This paper describes a two-step processing scheme called ‘artifact suppressed large-scale nonlocal means’ for suppressing both noise and artifacts in thoracic LDCT images. Specific scale and direction properties were exploited to discriminate the noise and artifacts from image structures. Parallel implementation has been introduced to speed up the whole processing by more than 100 times. Phantom and patient CT images were both acquired for evaluation purpose. Comparative qualitative and quantitative analyses were both performed that allows conclusion on the efficacy of our method in improving thoracic LDCT data. S Online supplementary data available from stacks.iop.org/PMB/57/2667/mmedia (Some figures may appear in colour only in the online journal) 0031-9155/12/092667+22$33.00 © 2012 Institute of Physics and Engineering in Medicine Printed in the UK & the USA 2667
Comparing Image Quality in Phase Contrast sub$μ$ X-Ray Tomography -- A Round-Robin Study

Simon Zabler,Maximilian Ullherr,Christian Fella,Richard Schielein,Oliver Focke,Berit Zeller-Plumhoff,Pierre Lhuissier,Wesley DeBoever,Randolf Hanke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2019.162992

2019-11-26

Abstract:How to evaluate and compare image quality from different sub-micrometer (sub$\mu$) CT scans? A simple test phantom made of polymer microbeads is used for recording projection images as well as 13 CT scans in a number of commercial and non-commercial scanners. From the resulting CT images, signal and noise power spectra are modeled for estimating volume signal-to-noise ratios (3D SNR spectra). Using the same CT images, a time- and shape-independent transfer function (MTF) is computed for each scan, including phase contrast effects and image blur ($\mathrm{MTF_{blur}}$). The SNR spectra and MTF of the CT scans are compared to 2D SNR spectra of the projection images. In contrary to 2D SNR, volume SNR can be normalized with respect to the object's power spectrum, yielding detection effectiveness (DE) a new measure which reveals how technical differences as well as operator-choices strongly influence scan quality for a given measurement time. Using DE, both source-based and detector-based sub$\mu$ CT scanners can be studied and their scan quality can be compared. Future application of this work requires a particular scan acquisition scheme which will allow for measuring 3D signal-to-noise ratios, making the model fit for 3D noise power spectra obsolete.

Instrumentation and Detectors,Applied Physics
Preliminary Investigation of Dose Allocation in Low-Dose Cone-Beam CT

Xiao Han,Erik Pearson,Junguo Bian,Seungryong Cho,Emil Y. Sidky,Charles A. Pelizzari,Xiaochuan Pan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nssmic.2010.5874137

2010-01-01

Abstract:Current cone-beam CT imaging requires dense angular sampling that is imposed by the FDK-type image-reconstruction algorithm. In an attempt to investigate the possibility of low-dose CBCT by reducing the number of projection views, we applied the adaptive-steepest-descent-projection-onto-convex-sets (ASD-POCS) algorithm for CBCT image reconstruction. Given a reduced amount of total radiation-dose, we applied both ASD-POCS and FDK algorithms for reconstruction of CBCT images from real measurement data acquired at different mass settings, and investigated how the quality of images reconstructed by these algorithms changes when the amount of total dose is allocated to angular views in different ways. Preliminary results of the study suggest that the ASD-POCS algorithm can yield images of quality better than that achieved by the FDK algorithm with each low-dose data set, and comparable to images obtained with the standard dose level. While FDK image quality degrades with decreased number of views, the ASD-POCS image quality appears to be less affected by different dose-allocation parameters under investigation.
Image Quality in a Low Radiation Exposure Protocol for Retrospectively ECG-Gated Coronary CT Angiography

Tobias Pflederer,Larissa Rudofsky,Dieter Ropers,Sven Bachmann,Mohamed Marwan,Werner G. Daniel,Stephan Achenbach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2214/ajr.08.1025

2009-04-01

American Journal of Roentgenology

Abstract:OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our study was to systematically compare the image quality of dual-source CT coronary angiography using 100 kV instead of 120 kV.SUBJECTS AND METHODS: One hundred patients with a body weight </= 85 kg were included. A dual-source CT scanner was used (330-milliseconds rotation, 0.6-mm collimation, 56 +/- 7 mL of IV contrast agent at 5 mL/s). Each patient was randomized either to scanning protocol group 1 (120 kV and 330 mAs) or protocol group 2 (100 kV and 330 mAs). ECG pulsing was used for all patients. Data sets were assessed by two independent observers for image quality, signal-to-noise ratio, and contrast-to-noise-ratio. Effective dose was determined based on dose-length product.RESULTS: There were no significant differences in body weight or heart rate between the two groups (70 +/- 10 kg and 57 +/- 8 bpm [beats per minute] vs 70 +/- 9 kg and 59 +/- 8 bpm). Use of 100 kV led to significant reduction of radiation exposure (group 1: 12.7 +/- 1.7 mSv; volume CT dose index [CTDI(vol)], 47.8 +/- 6.1 mGy and group 2: 7.8 +/- 2.0 mSv; CTDI(vol), 28.6 +/- 6.3 mGy; p < 0.001). Interobserver agreement in assessing image quality (kappa = 0.71) was close. Mean patient-based image quality scores were not significantly different (group 1, 2.7 +/- 0.5 and group 2, 2.6 +/- 0.4; p = 0.75). Also, vessel-based scores showed no significant differences. Beyond the level of significance, group 1 and group 2 showed one and two nonassessable patients and two and three nonassessable vessels, respectively. Mean intraluminal attenuation, contrast enhancement, and image noise were significantly higher for 100 kV, whereas signal-to-noise and contrast-to-noise-ratios were not different between the two scanning protocols.CONCLUSION: The use of lower tube voltage leads to significant reduction in radiation exposure in noninvasive coronary CT angiography. Image quality in nonobese patients is not negatively influenced.

radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Quantitative analysis of the image quality in megavoltage cone-beam computed tomography

Wei-gang RU,Zhen ZHANG,Xi CHANG,Ji ZHU,Zhi-yong XU,Jin-tian TANG,Guo-liang JIANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1004-4221.2009.03.226

2009-01-01

Abstract:Objective To quantitatively analyze the image quality of megavoltage cone-beam CT (MVCBCT) under different scanning conditions to provide reference in clinical applications. Methods Si-emens ONCOR linear accelerator with MVCBCT was used to scan the phantom under different conditions. The image quality was evaluated in terms of image noise, uniformity, spatial resolution, contrast resolution, the number of Monitor Units(MUs) used in imaging,and the size of the reconstruction matrix. The comparison of the image quality between MVCBCT and conventional simulator CT was also analyzed. Results The image noise was decreased with the increase of the number of MUs. The uniformity index showed that the system u-niformity was weakly dependent on MU numbers or the size of the reconstruction matrix. Except for the ima-ges with 5 MUs,all other images had the spatial resolution of 0.4 lp/mm with a reconstruction matrix of 256 ×256. Better low contrast resolution was achieved by using more MUs. For typical pelvis and head-and-neck patients,the imaging dose at the center was 0.8 cGy/MU and 0.7 cGy/MU, respectively,and the maxi-mum dose was about 1.2 cGy/MU. For typical abdomen patients,the image maximum dose and center dose was 1.3 cGy/MU and 0.7 cGy/MU,respectively. Conclusions The image quality of MVCBCT is inferior to the conventional kilo-voltage CT. However,with the optimization of the parameters in imaging,we can a-chieve sufficient image contrast in the bone,air and some soft-tissue structures with low imaging dose to pa-tients. Such images can be used for IGRT.
Dose measurements for dental cone-beam CT: a comparison with MSCT and panoramic imaging

P Deman,P Atwal,C Duzenli,Y Thakur,N L Ford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0031-9155/59/12/3201

IF: 3.5

2014-05-27

Physics in Medicine and Biology

Abstract:To date there is a lack of published information on appropriate methods to determine patient doses from dental cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) equipment. The goal of this study is to apply and extend the methods recommended in the American Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) Report 111 for CBCT equipment to characterize dose and effective dose for a range of dental imaging equipment. A protocol derived from the one proposed by Dixon et al (2010 Technical Report 111, American Association of Physicist in Medicine, MD, USA), was applied to dose measurements of multi-slice CT, dental CBCT (small and large fields of view (FOV)) and a dental panoramic system. The computed tomography dose index protocol was also performed on the MSCT to compare both methods. The dose distributions in a cylindrical polymethyl methacrylate phantom were characterized using a thimble ionization chamber and Gafchromic™ film (beam profiles). Gafchromic™ films were used to measure the dose distribution in an anthropomorphic phantom. A method was proposed to extend dose estimates to planes superior and inferior to the central plane. The dose normalized to 100 mAs measured in the center of the phantom for the large FOV dental CBCT (11.4 mGy/100 mAs) is two times lower than that of MSCT (20.7 mGy/100 mAs) for the same FOV, but approximately 15 times higher than for a panoramic system (0.6 mGy/100 mAs). The effective dose per scan (in clinical conditions) found for the dental CBCT are 167.60 ± 3.62, 61.30 ± 3.88 and 92.86 ± 7.76 mSv for the Kodak 9000 (fixed scan length of 3.7 cm), and the iCAT Next Generation for 6 cm and 13 cm scan lengths respectively. The method to extend the dose estimates from the central slice to superior and inferior slices indicates a good agreement between theory and measurement. The Gafchromic™ films provided useful beam profile data and 2D distributions of dose in phantom.

engineering, biomedical,radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Image Quality Analysis of Photon-Counting CT Compared with Dual-Source CT: A Phantom Study for Chest CT Examinations

Marine Deleu,Jean-Baptiste Maurice,Laura Devos,Martine Remy,François Dubus

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics13071325

IF: 3.6

2023-04-04

Diagnostics

Abstract:A comparison was made between the image quality of a photon-counting CT (PCCT) and a dual-source CT (DSCT). The evaluation of image quality was performed using a Catphan CT phantom, and the physical metrics, such as the noise power spectrum and task transfer function, were measured for both PCCT and DSCT at three CT dose indices (1, 5 and 10 mGy). Polyenergetic and virtual monoenergetic reconstructions were used to evaluate the performance differences by simulating a Gaussian spot with a radius of 5 mm and calculating the detectability index. The highest iterative reconstruction level was able to decrease the noise by about 70% compared with the filtered back projection using a parenchyma reconstruction kernel. The PCCT task transfer functions remained constant, while those of the DSCT increased with the reconstruction strength level. At monoenergetic 70 keV, a 50% decrease in noise was observed for DSCT with image smoothing, while PCCT had the same 50% decrease in noise without any smoothing. The PCCT detectability index at a reconstruction strength level of two was equivalent to the highest level of ADMIRE 5 for DSCT. The PCCT showed its superiority over the DSCT, especially for lung nodule detection.

medicine, general & internal

Comparative study of image quality and radiation dose of cone beam and low-dose multislice computed tomography - an in-vitro investigation

[Comparative Dosimetry of Dental Cone-Beam Computed Tomography and Multi-Slice Computed Tomography for Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology].

A comprehensive study on the relationship between image quality and imaging dose in low-dose cone beam CT

Dental Imaging in Clinical Photon-Counting CT at a Quarter of DVT Dose

Cone Beam CT vs. Fan Beam CT: A Comparison of Image Quality and Dose Delivered Between Two Differing CT Imaging Modalities

Cranial Computer Tomography with Photon Counting and Energy-Integrated Detectors: Objective Comparison in the Same Patients

SU‐E‐J‐07: A Preliminary Study on Optimal Dose‐Allocation Parameters for Low‐Dose Cone‐Beam CT

Iterative reconstruction for image enhancement and dose reduction in diagnostic cone beam CT imaging.

Investigation Of Low-Contrast Tumor Detection In Algorithm-Enabled Low-Dose Cbct

Low-Dose High-Resolution Photon-Counting CT of the Lung: Radiation Dose and Image Quality in the Clinical Routine

Image quality evaluation of dual-layer spectral detector CT of the chest and comparison with conventional CT imaging

Thin slice photon‐counting CT coronary angiography compared to conventional CT: Objective image quality and clinical radiation dose assessment

Simulated Radiation Dose Reduction in Whole-Body CT on a 3rd Generation Dual-Source Scanner: An Intraindividual Comparison

Visualization of bone details in a novel photon-counting dual-source CT scanner—comparison with energy-integrating CT

Task-based image quality evaluation of iterative reconstruction methods for low dose CT using computer simulations

Comparing Image Quality in Phase Contrast sub$μ$ X-Ray Tomography -- A Round-Robin Study

Preliminary Investigation of Dose Allocation in Low-Dose Cone-Beam CT

Image Quality in a Low Radiation Exposure Protocol for Retrospectively ECG-Gated Coronary CT Angiography

Quantitative analysis of the image quality in megavoltage cone-beam computed tomography

Dose measurements for dental cone-beam CT: a comparison with MSCT and panoramic imaging

Image Quality Analysis of Photon-Counting CT Compared with Dual-Source CT: A Phantom Study for Chest CT Examinations