Comparing Essential Tremor with and without Soft Dystonic Signs and Tremor Combined with Dystonia: The TITAN Study
Roberto Erro,Giulia Lazzeri,Carmen Terranova,Giulia Paparella,Angelo Fabio Gigante,Rosa De Micco,Luca Magistrelli,Francesca Di Biasio,Francesca Valentino,Vincenzo Moschella,Andrea Pilotto,Marcello Esposito,Enrica Olivola,Maria Chiara Malaguti,Roberto Ceravolo,Carlo Dallocchio,Francesca Spagnolo,Alessandra Nicoletti,Anna De Rosa,Raffaella Di Giacopo,Cristiano Sorrentino,Alessandro Padovani,Maria Concetta Altavista,Claudio Pacchetti,Roberta Marchese,Elena Contaldi,Alessandro Tessitore,Salvatore Misceo,Matteo Bologna,Vincenzo Rizzo,Giulia Franco,Paolo Barone,TITAN study group,Luca Angelini,Simone Aramini,Ruggero Bacchin,Salvatore Bertino,Marta Bianchi,Anna Castagna,Federico Colombatto,Eleonora Del Prete,Lazzaro di Biase,Alessio Di Fonzo,Giovanni Di Maggio,Augusta Giglio,Caterina Giordano,Nicoletta Manzo,Nicola Modugno,Giovanni Mostile,Laura Maria Raglione,Maria Russo,Giovanna Savorgnan,Assunta Trinchillo,Giampiero Volpe,Stefano Zoccolella
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/mdc3.14026
Abstract:Background: Tremor disorders remain as clinical diagnoses and the rate of misdiagnosis between the commonest non-parkinsonian tremors is relatively high. Objectives: To compare the clinical features of Essential Tremor without other features (pure ET), ET plus soft dystonic signs (ET + DS), and tremor combined with dystonia (TwD). Methods: We compared the clinical features of patients with pure ET, ET + DS, and TwD enrolled in The ITAlian tremor Network (TITAN). Linear regression models were performed to determine factors associated with health status and quality of life. Results: Three-hundred-eighty-three patients were included. Sex distribution was significantly different between the groups with males being more represented in pure ET and females in TwD. The initial site of tremor was different between the groups with about 40% of TwD having head tremor and ET + DS unilateral upper limb tremor at onset. This pattern mirrored the distribution of overt dystonia and soft dystonic signs at examination. Sensory trick, task-specificity, and position-dependence were more common, but not exclusive, to TwD. Pure ET patients showed the lowest degree of alcohol responsiveness and ET + DS the highest. Midline tremor was more commonly encountered and more severe in TwD than in the other groups. Regression analyses demonstrated that tremor severity, sex, age, and to a lesser degree the variable "group", independently predicted health status and quality of life, suggesting the existence of other determinants beyond tremor. Conclusions: Pure ET and TwD manifest with a phenotypic overlap, which calls for the identification of diagnostic biomarkers. ET + DS shared features with both syndromes, suggesting intra-group heterogeneity.