Abstract:Journal of Humanistic Psychology, Ahead of Print. Most people who perform a heroic act will, afterward, deny that their actions were heroic and claim that anyone would have done the same, even though that is demonstrably false (and, often, others were present who failed to act heroically at all). The literature on the psychology of heroism has never investigated why this is. This theoretical paper proposes an answer and seeks to provoke exploration of a previously unexplored topic. We note that people who undertake heroic action face a unique conflict: they embody their community's highest values, while simultaneously breaking norms to stand apart from that community. We hypothesize that this conflict takes a psychological toll and is at the heart of a hero's self-effacing denial. In this paper, we argue that (a) acting heroically is, by definition, committing a violation of social norms and therefore standing apart from the political community; (b) in the moment, heroic agents are willing to violate norms to serve a higher social value (such as saving a life), but afterward they feel the full emotional weight of acting in a non-normative manner; and (c) heroes' eagerness to downplay or generalize their heroic action is not merely an act of humility, but an attempt to seek readmission to the community and the status of being "normal." We believe that exploration of this topic can provide insight on what prevents people from acting heroically when needed, and we discuss why alternative possibilities such as humility and modesty are not sufficient explanations.

Heroic Collective Action: A People's Blessing?

I Am Not a Hero: How Heroic Action Divorces the Hero from the Political Community

Heroism Research: A Review of Theories, Methods, Challenges, and Trends

What Makes a Hero? Theorising the Social Structuring of Heroism

The Question of Heroism and Heroic Virtue in the Philosophy of Education of Josef Pieper

The Hero Transformed: The Dialectics of Heroism and Psychoanalytic Process in Working with Israeli Men

Heroism in Characters of People's Heroes: Spent Symbolic Capital of Yugoslav Nations?

Hotel Rwanda : individual heroism or interconnectedness in the portrayal of Paul Rusesabagina?

Heroes and Villains: The Effects of Combat Heroism on Autocratic Values and Nazi Collaboration in France

Why Honor Heroes? Praise as a Social Signal

High ideals: the misappropriation and reappropriation of the heroic label in the midst of a global pandemic

On Cultural Differences of Heroes: Evidence From Individualistic and Collectivistic Cultures

Creating mindful heroes: a case study with ninth grade students

Collective and Individual Sources of Women’s Creativity: Heroism and Psychological Types Involved in Enhancing the Talent of Emerging Leaders

The Justice of Need and the Activation of Humanitarian Norms

Research of "heroism" as a social phenomenon from the perspective of cultural anthropology

James R. Harrison. (2019). Paul and the Ancient Celebrity Circuit, The Cross and Moral Transformation

Toward a cultural psychology of collective action: Just how “core” are the core motivations for collective action?

Volodymyr Zelenskyy, heroic leadership, and the historical gaze

Human or Superhuman: the Concept of Hero in Ancient Greek Religion and/in Politics

The Concept of the Hero in Modernity